President Donald Trump, accompanied by Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao, left, speaks at a roundtable on infrastructure at the Department of Transportation, Friday, June 9, 2017, in Washington. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik) The Associated Press
President Donald Trump launched "infrastructure week" on Monday to promote his push to improve America's infrastructure projects. The president's infrastructure plan includes $200 billion dollars in government spending over 10 years, which is intended to ultimately generate a total of $1 trillion in public and private investment. Speaking in Cincinnati on Wednesday, Trump said, "Our infrastructure program will be based on forging new partnerships and demanding new accountability for every federal taxpayer dollar. Under this vision, the federal government will drastically reduce burdensome regulations and massively streamline approvals and permitting."
Trump stressed the need to overhaul America's infrastructure during his 2016 campaign and has billed that part of his White House agenda as a key opportunity for bipartisanship. "I'm calling on all Democrats and Republicans to join together, if that's possible, in the great rebuilding of America," Trump declared to the crowd gathered near the Ohio River.
However, the president's approach to infrastructure – specifically his embrace of alternatives to government funding – has proved divisive.
Gary Cohn, head of Trump's National Economic Council, told The New York Times last week, "We like the template of not using taxpayer dollars to give taxpayers wins." Regarding the administration's "partnership" method, Cohn explained, "We want to be in the facilitation business, and we're willing to provide capital wherever necessary to help certain infrastructure along."
Congressional Democrats have expressed criticism of the administration's plan as too advantageous to the private sector, though. After the administration released its plan this week, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, who had initially shown interest working with the president on infrastructure, stated, "A private-sector-driven infrastructure plan means tolls, tolls, tolls – paid by average, working Americans."
"Not only are they not putting serious dollars into infrastructure, they're actually going to do it by selling off to private individuals and private companies on Wall Street the ability to supposedly create this infrastructure investment and these jobs," said Rep. Mark Pocan, D-Wis., on Wednesday, as reported by U.S. News' Andrew Soergel. "The problem is, in places like Wisconsin, for the vast majority of our state, we're not going to see a dime, because it's not a profitable enterprise."
So, is Trump taking the right approach to infrastructure? Here's the Debate Club's take.
Viewpoints
David Brodwin
David Brodwin
A Treat for Big Business, Not Taxpayers
David Brodwin is a cofounder and board member of American Sustainable Business Council. Follow him on Twitter at @davidbrodwin.
Donna Cooper
Donna Cooper
A Bigger, Better Plan for Trump
Donna Cooper is a former fellow with the Center for American Progress and author of a series of reports for CAP on infrastructure including the Infrastructure Imperative. Ed Rendell served as the 45th governor of Pennsylvania and is co-chair of Building America's Future.
Ray LaHood
Ray LaHood
Just a Start
Ray LaHood is a former secretary of transportation and the current co-chairman of the bipartisan advocacy group Building America’s Future.
Doug Peterson
Doug Peterson
Partners in Infrastructure
Doug Peterson is president and chief executive officer of S&P Global and co-chair of the Bipartisan Policy Center’s Executive Council on Infrastructure.
John K. Delaney
John K. Delaney
An Insufficient Infrastructure Plan
John K. Delaney represents Maryland’s Sixth District in the House of Representatives. Congressman Delaney is the only former CEO of a publicly-traded company in the House and was named one of the World’s Greatest Leaders by Fortune in 2017.
John Foote
John Foote
The Public Must Pay
John Foote is a research fellow at the Taubman Center for State and Local Government at Harvard's Kennedy School and a lecturer at Cornell University’s Institute for Public Affairs, teaching courses in public finance and transportation policy.
Recommended Articles
Cartoons on President Donald Trump
July 11, 2017, at 5:04 p.m.
Political Cartoons on the Economy
June 28, 2017, at 5:03 p.m.
Moving Beyond Mosul
July 14, 2017
Here's what Iraq needs to do now that the Islamic State group has been ousted from Mosul.
Better Education Starts With Adults
July 14, 2017
Our treatment of educators and leaders is key to improving early childhood education.
Daily Cartoons: July 14, 2017
July 14, 2017, at 12:00 a.m.
The Rules Are For Suckers
July 13, 2017
Why Donald Trump and his son won't face any consequences for what happened during the campaign.
How to Handle Team Trump on TV
July 13, 2017
5 ways hosts can prevent interviews with White House provocateurs from devolving into a circus.
What Canada Gets About Pot
July 13, 2017
6 takeaways for U.S. marijuana policy.
Trumpcare Has a Fatal Flaw
July 13, 2017
No tweaks can change the rot at the heart of the Senate's Obamacare repeal effort.
Trump and the Triumph of Anti-Reason
July 13, 2017
Trump has elevated intellectual impoverishment to a high art, and America is buying it.