[an error occurred while processing this directive]

advertisement

Tuesday, May 29, 2012
January 23, 2006

A one-issue court debate

On her blog Asymmetrical Information, Megan McCardle has two strong items on abortion. One argues that the sure way to reduce the number of abortions is to make them illegal, since roughly half of abortions are performed on women using no protection. Her argument is that since abortions are relatively cheap and easy to obtain, there isn't much downside to avoiding contraception and therefore getting pregnant. Her second item deplores the fact that the Alito hearings were so obsessed with Roe v. Wade that other issues were avoided:

Are we debating the scope of executive power? The limits to congressional fiat? The rights of people to be free from searches? The wild extension of local power represented by the Kelo decision? The detention of prisoners in the War on Terror? The rights of people who, while nominally citizens, have de facto declared war on the United States? No, we can't, because apparently the only important legal issue in the entire country is whether or not a woman must, or must not be forced to, notify her parents and/or husband when she decides to terminate her pregnancy. This, my little chickadees, is what has become of the majesty of American law: nine justices quibbling about whether an abortion law needs an exemption for medical emergencies in order to qualify for the magical penumbras of constitutional protection.

Posted at 12:01 PM by John Leo

John Leo
John Leo has covered the social sciences and intellectual trends for Time magazine and the New York Times. He is also the author of two books: Two Steps Ahead of the Thought Police and a book of humor, How the Russians Invented Baseball and Other Essays of Enlightenment.

advertisement

BLOG BACK

...Data Loading. (Requires javascript to be turned on)

RECENT POSTS

  • No context in 'They killed my baby!' journalism: Washington Post reporter Anthony Shadid is at it again. Shadid is the world's foremost practitioner of "They killed my baby!"...
  • Stem cell morals: Are social and religious conservatives antiscience? Many are. But resistance to public funding of stem cell research is not an...
  • Superman as Christ: The theme of Superman as a Christ figure isn't new, but it has never been stronger or more obvious than...
  • Blockading free speech: Columnist Paul Craig Roberts attended Stanford's graduation and learned something new: Back in April, President Bush went to the university...
  • Surprise! Boys are different: Wendy McElroy wrote a July 4 column strongly recommending The Dangerous Book for Boys, a surprise bestseller in Britain and...

JOHN LEO'S BLOG ARCHIVE

RSS FEEDS

JOHN LEO'S BLOG FAVORITES

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.