Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Opinion

USN Current Issue

For a Fairer America

By Mortimer B. Zuckerman
Posted 9/24/06

What would Mark Twain make of America today? When he wrote his utopian satire, The Gilded Age (1873), there were certainly a lot of targets for his barbed shafts. The country worshipped gold, its politics were venal, and 1 percent of Americans sat on 20 percent of the nation's wealth. And they weren't shy about it, either. At a dinner in New York, by one account, guests smoked cigarettes rolled in hundred-dollar bills (about $2,000 today).

Yet, oddly, most Americans were better off than their parents had been. There were 5 1/2 million families who earned poverty-level wages, but 5 1/2 million were in the middle class, the most prosperous such group in the world. Capitalism played a big role, but government did, too, with the passage of the Homestead Act of 1862, giving 160 acres to settlers who would live on the land for at least five years. In the early 20th century, the wages of industrial workers kept poor families moving up into the middle class. After World War II, income growth soared, thanks to the happy confluence of private enterprise and government benefits. Social Security and Medicare freed families from worries about providing for their elderly parents, while the GI Bill and student loans enlarged the educated middle class. Income inequality, as a consequence, shrank sharply through the 1970s in a phenomenon called the "Great Compression."

Today, however, the wealth escalator doesn't work. In fact, while many families thought they were going up, they have actually been going down. In sectors of the economy where jobs could be mechanized or automated, tens of thousands now have no work. At the same time, most of the income gains we have reaped from productivity went to just the top 1 percent of Americans, who earned more than the bottom 50 percent-a degree of income disparity never before seen in America.

Feeling the squeeze. Since the 1970s, inequality of income and wealth has increased dramatically. In the 1980s and 1990s, middle-income families gained only about 10 percent in terms of after-tax income while the top 1 percent saw gains of 15 times that rate. Since 2000, a typical middle-class family has seen real household income rise less than 1 percent. Since the start of the current economic recovery, October 2001, median weekly earnings have fallen by 3.2 percent in real terms. Average hourly earnings for all nonmanagerial workers have also dropped, unlike in all previous recoveries. Today, as a result, we confront a situation in which economic growth no longer helps most American workers.

Increasing the squeeze, as documented in the seminal book The Two-Income Trap, is the fact that, for several decades, increases in income have fallen significantly behind increases in fixed costs for home mortgages, car payments, health insurance, and education. The income gains from having both parents work have been wiped out: The income from most two-parent families, in inflation-adjusted dollars, leaves them with less discretionary income than in the one-parent, single-paycheck family of the 1970s.

advertisement

advertisement

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.