Friday, November 13, 2009

Nation & World

Transcript of document discussion

Posted 3/24/06
Page 3 of 9

15 although I'm not trying to imply any concern about

16 Mr. Borgen – regarding dealing with classified documents.

17 And the question is whether or not it's possible

18 to create basically a SCIF or an SCI facility within the

19 courthouse that would satisfy the concerns of all of the

20 parties involved. We continue to have significant concerns

21 about it being left with the FBI, given the fact that the

22 FBI again is a defendant in this lawsuit. If what the Court

23 is saying is true, then that leaves the alternative of

24 moving it to Seattle, which creates obviously logistical

25 problems for everyone involved.

6

1 But I'm wondering if – my understanding is that

2 the litigation security section can be called, again it's a

3 neutral party, they're often contacted in both criminal –

4 generally criminal and probably some civil cases, like

5 they've been dealing with the documents related to the

6 Guantanamo litigation, which is something Mr. Wax is

7 familiar with, and whether it's possible to set up a SCIF

8 within the courthouse, given the fact that the courthouse

9 does have security at this point, and whether there's

10 something more that can be done, akin to bringing in a safe

11 or whatever, that may satisfy the requirement of this being

12 in a SCIF.

13 THE COURT: There is also the possibility – and

14 this is what Mr. Borgen mentioned to me – of discussing

15 this with the originator of the document to determine

16 whether it can be declassified or redacted – I'm not quite

17 sure what all can be done at this point – and perhaps

18 reduce the security requirements.

19 MR. GOLDBERG: This is Goldberg again. Obviously,

20 that sounds like a terrific idea.

21 THE COURT: Now, at this point I need to discuss

22 two things before we go forward. Does plaintiff have a copy

23 of this document?

24 MR. GOLDBERG: None of the attorneys involved with

25 the case have copies of the document. All of the copies

7

1 have been destroyed and we've sealed the only remaining

2 document with the Court.

3 THE COURT: You said "none of the attorneys."

4 Does your client representative have it?

5 MR. GOLDBERG: Your Honor, I have a problem –

6 THE COURT: You may have a problem answering that.

7 MR. GOLDBERG: – answering anything that may

8 implicate attorney-client privilege.

9 THE COURT: All right. But you're indicating that

10 the attorneys do not have a copy. Any copies you have –

11 MR. GOLDBERG: Any copies which any of the

advertisement

advertisement

10 Things You Didn't Know About...

Why doesn't Barack Obama like ice cream? Find out.

Washington Whispers

Face it, you need to know the buzz in D.C., and that's where Whispers comes in.

advertisement

50 Ways to Improve Your Life

U.S. News offers tips for improving your life.

America's Best Leaders

What makes someone a great leader?

Thomas Jefferson Street

Daily insight on politics and culture from the Thomas Jefferson Street bloggers.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.