Shedding Light on Dark Corners
By Dan Gilgoff
 |  |
Tramping through New York's grim tenements and lodging houses in the mid-
1880s, police reporter Jacob Riis felt words alone could never convey the depth of urban squalor. With the advent of magnesium
powder flash a few years later, his wish came true.
Lugging a frying pan and a revolver to spark the
flash, Riis snapped the first shots of the slums that
harbored three quarters of the Big Apple's populationone Lower East Side ward packed in 334,000 people per square mile.
Riis's photos, published in Scribner's Magazine
and in his book How the Other Half Lives, shocked
the bourgeoisie and its politicians into action.
Crime-ridden lodging houses folded, lights were
mounted in tenement hallways, and the city was
linked to a clean water supply. The clumsy amateur photographerRiis set two buildings on fire and nearly blinded himself in another accidentestablished the camera as a means to rally society's conscience. In a crusade against child labor 20 years later,
a science teacher named Lewis Hine drew on Riis's
strategy of shooting photos of the downtrodden.
Occasionally posing as an insurance salesman,
Hine captured crippled victims of mill accidents
and boys blackened by coal mine soot for the National Child Labor Committee. His 5,000 shots of young workers helped pit politicians against the practice of child labor. But while Riis's lens usually
looked down at his subjects, Hine set his camera
closer to the ground, ennobling the people he photographed. "Riis's images are so powerful because they are so ugly," says David Jacobs, a University of Houston art professor. "Hine's subjects are still
victims, but they're given a presence and a stature
as individuals."
In the '30s, Hine's shooting style evolved further
within the Photo League, a group of young New
Yorkers charged by creed with a "duty of recording
a true image of the world." League photographers
panned the overt social prescriptions of Hine and
Riis. They "questioned whether you had to show
somebody who was down and out in order to elicit
sympathy," says Brian Wallis, chief curator at the International
Center for Photography in New York. While the league's work
didn't directly spark reforms, it set a social realist coursewhat
members called "straight photography"for a new generation.
The league's membership shriveled after it was tagged as a
possible Communist front in 1949, but its model for confronting
reality resurfaced in the 1960s. While Southern blacks had been
organizing for years to stamp out segregation and win voting
rights, the civil rights movement didn't explode until May 1963,
when emotionally powerful photographs of demonstrators in
Birmingham, Ala., facing dogs and fire hoses, circulated around
the world. "I wanted to show the appalling violence of dogs biting people because of the color of their skin," says Charles Moore,
who shot the Birmingham demonstrations for Life magazine.
"In the minds of Americans, it was a turning point."
Later in the decade, the Vietnam Warin which journalists
and photographers were given extraordinary free reinprovided a stream of intimate, gruesome portraits that hadn't accompanied earlier military campaigns. "Americans couldn't recognize their own image of themselves in a photo of a young girl being bombed with napalm," says Anne Tucker, curator of photographs at the Museum of Fine Arts in Houston. "Those photographs had a great deal to do with the swing in public opinion about what was going on." After Vietnam, the U.S. military largely restricted wartime news media to press pools.
But photographers gained ground in other areas. "Photographers today are focused more on critical political issues that are
harder to get at than war, famine, or genocide," says Wallis of the
ICP. New York photographer Donna Ferrato began pointing her
lens at domestic violence 20 years ago, when she witnessed a husband attacking his wifeand captured it on film. "Back then the
attitude was that if the woman is being beat, she probably likes it,
or else she would leave," says 52-year-old Ferrato. "I was convinced
no one would know what a battered woman went through until
people could see her face." Ferrato couldn't find a publication that
would carry her photos until 1986, when the Philadelphia Inquirer devoted two issues of its Sunday magazine to domestic
violence. Since then, her work has appeared in many magazines
and books. "By putting a face on the issue," she says, "I got people
interested." Jacob Riis, doubtless, would agree.
|