Chevrolet Malibu
Getting there |
  |
By Richard J. Newman
|
NITS: The cupholder insert stuck to my soda bottle and kept coming out, a petty annoyance, but also a good way to lose a cheap but hard-to-replace little part.
G-FORCES: The optional 200-horsepower V-6 on the test vehicle was responsive and quiet, though not as potent as the top-tier 240-horsepower V-6 available on the Honda Accord. The four-speed transmission is smooth but not as silky as the five-speed automatics on other cars in this class. The Malibu's handling is a high point. It has a strong bearing on curves and is comfortable on the highway.
GIZMOLOGY: Radio and climate controls are large and easy-to-locate, with a nice digital display that also includes info on trip length, mileage, and other vehicle functions. A nice touch is a front passenger seat that folds completely flat, to help store long items like boards or skis when the rear seat is also folded down.
KID MARKS: The rear seat has plenty of space for kids to maneuver around, with only one drawback: Cupholders are close to the floor, on the back of the driver's armrest, where they are beyond the reach of smaller children.
HOT OR NOT: Not. The Malibu's styling is halfway between sleek and boxy, giving it a please-everybody kind of anonymity. The good news for Chevrolet is that most other mass-market sedans are pretty bland too.
CRASH COURSE: The '04 Malibu hasn't yet been crash-tested by the government or by private testing organizations.
ENVIROMETER: The Malibu rates 7 out of 10 on the epa's emissions/air pollution scale. Mileage ranges from 23 mpg city to 34 mpg highway. Details: http://www.epa.gov/autoemissions/ E-CHEVROLET-Malibu-04.htm
PRICE POINTS: Base prices range from $18,995 to $23,495. Price as tested: $25,720.
MORE INFO: http://www.chevrolet.com/malibu/
|
Model year tested: 2004
Just wait. That's what General Motors has been saying to critics, pointing out over and over for more than a decade that the No.1 automaker's passenger cars just don't measure up to those made by the Japanese and the Europeans. During the '90s, GM admits, it neglected its mainstream cars while focusing on SUVs. Then the Cadillac luxury division got all the attention. The next step GM has been touting: Rolling out a stable of coupes and sedans able to chase pacesetters like the Toyota Camry and the Honda Accord.
Judging by the '04 Malibu, the wait may be ending. While not flashy, the Malibu has the solid feel and just-right tuning that has been out of synch in GM cars for years. GM does some things very well, like build crisp engines and smooth transmissions. But too often those attributes are overshadowed by sloppy handling or dated, flimsy interiors. In the Malibu, it all comes together. On the road the Malibu is sure-footed and confident, with tight handling on curves (for a family sedan) and taut steering that is a vast improvement over the wiggly, jiggly feel of other GM sedans. The optional 200-horsepower V-6 engine is spry and smooth and capable of hustling you through just about any driving situation. (The base engine is a more modest 145-hp inline-four-cylinder.) Overall, the Malibu's mechanicals produce a driving experience that is pleasant and effortless. It's simply an enjoyable car to drive.
An even bigger story may be the interior. Armrests and cupholders are all in the right place, and they have a solid feel that suggests you'd hold up well on a long trip in this car. In place of traditionally cheap-feeling dials and controls, there is a well-designed dash centered around a digital display showing radio, climate, and vehicle information. Cool touches like the little tabs on the A/C vents that allow you to flip them closed make the interior more interesting than the efficient but bland layouts on competitors like the Camry. There's even an option for sensuous perforated-suede seats, about the last thing you'd expect to find on a Chevy sedan. That's an extravagance few buyers of a middle-market car would ever order, but the fact that it's available shows that GM is raising its standards.
So is the Malibu an Accord- or Camry slayer? It's certainly worth a look, and maybe more given that GM is pricing the Malibu $2,000 or more below its more proven competitors, when similarly equipped. The unanswerable question at the moment is whether the Malibu will hold up as well as the Camry and Accord, benchmarks for quality that are among the most reliable cars on the road. That's an elusive standard to meet, and it could take years for GM's quality to edge up to where Honda and Toyota are today. But the Malibu feels like it could be the first step or two on that climb.
In the market for a new car? Use our auto search for more information.
Is there a car you would like us to review? Send your suggestion to test-track@usnews.com.
Return to the auto page to view more reviews.
|