Thinking Harder

How Hibernating Bears Beat Bone Loss

By Ben Harder

Posted: January 10, 2008

The science of hibernation, which I've written about here and here, has fascinated me for some time. How do animals go dormant—hibernation is actually not a form of sleep—for months at a time and not waste away in the process?

If I had to perform virtually no bodily functions for the entire winter, I would die of thirst, or starve, or burst my bladder long before spring arrived. Even if I could put my basic metabolic needs aside for the season, my muscles and bones would dissipate from disuse. Come March, I'd be too weak to get up, never mind see my shadow.

Hibernating animals, however, tap into some impressive physiological abilities that humans have long since lost. Scientists and medical researchers are trying to figure out how animals do it. They hypothesize that if we humans could revive our capacity to hibernate, perhaps with the aid of pharmaceutical treatments, we could improve our odds of surviving heart attacks and strokes, car accidents and war wounds, and other sorts of threats to life and limb.

An interesting story in yesterday's Wall Street Journal reminded me how much I still don't know about this field of science. The writer, Ivan Oransky, described how researcher Seth Donahue determined that bears make a special hormone that helps them build new bone material during hibernation. The new bone replaces material that they are losing. Striking a balance between bone generation and bone loss is what enables us generally to maintain bone strength, even though the actual molecules in our skeletons are continually coming and going. Donahue's research could help combat osteoporosis, which is what occurs when bone loss outpaces bone generation—and is also what would happen to me if I attempted to hibernate without having that bear hormone.

The story notes that bears have to be anesthetized before blood samples can be drawn from them. "But how do you get a hormone sample from a bear...? Very carefully," Oransky writes. Otherwise, a bear "might awaken, distorting the results and putting the researchers at risk."

That brought to my mind a memorable lecture that I heard a couple of years ago at a scientific conference in Virginia Beach, Va. Hank Harlow, a professor of zoology and physiology at the University of Wyoming in Laramie, spoke about how bears manage to survive hibernation. Like Donahue, Harlow took care when harvesting tissue samples from hibernating bears. One misstep, he said, and the bear could rouse itself with startling speed, roaring out of the den in hot pursuit of any researcher quick-footed enough to flee. That bears can "wake up" so fast from hibernation is a physiological feat in its own right—months of immobility would cause a person's muscles to atrophy to the point that he or she couldn't get up unassisted. That's why Harlow said scientific study of bears could aid another type of patient: people who are bedridden for months at a stretch.

Human hibernation

That's a great question, Fred. There's no direct proof I know of that our ancestors could hibernate, but there's strong circumstantial evidence that the first mammal--which was a distant ancestor of ours, of course--could: Physiologists who study hibernation have pointed out to me that diverse kinds of mammals, including at least one primate, are able to hibernate. That suggests our lineage lost the ability somewhere along their evolutionary path.

Interestingly, some experts speculate that we haven't completely lost the capacity to lower metabolism during periods of cold, which is a hallmark of hibernation. There are anecdotal reports of young children falling into icy waters and being pulled out alive long after an adult in the same situation would have perished. Are kids somehow able to ratchet down metabolism when their lives depend on it? If so, it could provide a window into how the adult body could be coaxed into hibernation.

Ben Harder of DC @ Jan 31, 2008 12:46:21 PM

How Hibernating Bears Beat Bone Loss

"Hibernating animals, however, tap into some impressive physiological abilities that humans have long since lost."

Ben have you seen any scientific proof that we humans ever had the ability to hibernate? It sounds like a nice hypothesis by science though; I wonder if there have been any studies to induce an ailment in a bear and then treat the bear during hibernation?

Fred Main of OH @ Jan 30, 2008 10:13:56 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Thinking Harder

This blog is the public workshop of U.S. News writer and editor Ben Harder. In articles published in the magazine, he has covered a range of sciences, including medicine, human behavior, prehistory, and evolution. Here, he can explore those and other scientific fields more fully and more informally than is possible in print. He'll share whatever seems noteworthy or potentially useful, and he invites readers to do the same.

WTOP Audio
On Feb. 24, 2008, Ben discussed the link between artificial light and cancer on WTOP radio. Listen to the interview at WTOP News. He again talked about light pollution on WTOP on March 22, exploring its environmental effects.

advertisement

National Science Foundation

NSF

Wolves, Moose and Soil Nutrients: The Unexpected Connection

Researchers were startled to discover "hot spots" of forest fertility.

Predicting Who Will Survive Skin Cancer

Using new techniques, researchers may now be able to predict the survivability of skin cancer.

Record Highs Far Outpace Lows Across U.S.

Daily record high temperatures occurred twice as often as record lows over the past decade.

Science Discoveries

Science Discoveries

iTunes icon RSS icon

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!