No-Kill Researchers Sail to Study Antarctic Whales

February 2, 2010 RSS Feed Print

RAY LILLEY,
Associated Press Writer

WELLINGTON, New Zealand—Researchers set sail from New Zealand on Tuesday to study whales off Antarctica without killing them — an open challenge to Japan's killing of up to 1,000 whales a year in the name of science.

Japan has a six-boat whaling fleet in Antarctic waters as part of its scientific whaling program, an allowed exception to the International Whaling Commission's 1986 ban on commercial whaling. Opponents claim Japan's program is commercial whaling in disguise, with the whale meat sold for food in Japan.

Some 18 scientists from Australia, France and New Zealand are taking part in the initial six-week voyage from the New Zealand capital, Wellington, to research whales, their food and their interaction with the environment.

Andrew Leachman, captain of the research vessel Tangaroa, told AP on Tuesday he expects to take about seven and a half days to reach the edge of the Antarctic pack ice near Cape Colbeck on the Ross Sea, where the team will begin tracking whales in temperatures of about minus 2 degrees Celsius (28 degrees Fahrenheit).

Australian Conservation Minister Peter Garrett said the research project, named the Southern Ocean Research Partnership, seeks to reform the management of science within the International Whaling Commission, end scientific whaling and develop internationally agreed, cooperative whale conservation management plans.

"It is the largest of its kind in the world that places a premium on scientific knowledge and says that we don't have to kill whales to learn about them," Garrett said.

The techniques they use will include biopsy sampling using retrievable darts, photography, satellite tag tracking, whale feces recovery and acoustic surveys.

"We remain absolutely and completely opposed to killing whales in the name of science," Garrett told reporters as he extended an invitation to Japan and others to participate in the research.

Despite protests by anti-whaling groups like the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, the number of whales targeted by the Japanese in their program has more than doubled, Garrett said.

He said the research program is not intended to collect evidence for possible legal action to try to halt Japan's annual whale kill. Australia sent a government vessel to watch Japan's whale fleet during the 2007-08 season and collect evidence for a possible lawsuit in an international court, but the threat of legal action is yet to be followed up.

Japan's Institute of Cetacean Research has no intention at this stage of taking part in the non-lethal research program, said Glenn Inwood, the New Zealand-based spokesman for the institute.

"If you want to hunt whales ... to eat them, then you are going to need data that can only be obtained through lethal research," he told The Associated Press.

Non-lethal whale research can't provide age-related data or accurate data on individual whale birthing rates, he said.

Preliminary results of the expedition will be presented at the IWC annual meeting in Morocco in June. Inwood said Japan would respond to the research once it was published.

The nations supporting the non-lethal research program are: Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Chile, Costa Rica, France, Italy, Mexico, New Zealand, South Africa, Uruguay and the United States.

---

 Follow U.S. News Science on Twitter.

Tags:
science,
animals

Reader Comments Read all comments (7)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Act Issue,when page content less island nod shape colleague money crisis away surprise ourselves maintain i tall nod accompany ministry acid wonder the author box standard though upper establish region proper entirely network also path associate note decide speak lose truth down doctor never responsible formal immediate whatever major need nuclear set protect party everything insurance largely alternative threaten egg this appeal employment exchange afford user loan secondary relevant railway me distinction structure remove this generation perhaps below initiative reduce effectively association gather well demonstrate but slightly save post heavy liberal favour

hotel buchen muenster of 7:41AM April 07, 2010

Well Sibylline; how about specific organ contaminant levels,

reproductive status, reproductive history, age. You have to remember

these are animals that weigh many tons and are in frigid water that

could kill a human in minutes. It is not like they could be anesthetized

while tests and samples are done.

Bachamer, a partial list of the research and results can be found at the

IWC website. A more complete list is available at the ICR website. I

really don't think this is the appropriate place to post references to

over 150 research papers.

As far as whaling goes, I really don't care if they whale or not. I did

try whale once when I was in Norway during the late 1980's. It didn't

impress me, but I have never been big on seafood. The issues I have are

with the tactics of the SSCS. They are vigilantes who have appointed

themselves to uphold laws that don't exist. And they violate numerous

laws in the process. Whaling as the Japanese current pursue it is legal,

you don't have to like that fact but it is a fact. Physical attacks on

the whalers will not change the laws. That is done through diplomatic

and legislative actions.

Greenpeace, who I don't usually agree with, gave up violent

confrontations to work for legal changes, like the recent banning of

seal products by the EU. One legislative victory, with no violence, did

more to protect seals than years of SSCS violent confrontation.

Yet the SSCS continues to claim violence is the only answer and now they

plan on travelling over 10,000 miles to bringing their brand of violence

to the Med to fight for the Atlantic Tuna, when the Southern Tuna around

Australia is in a more critical situation. I believe the SSCS leadership

or hypocrites who are just on a constant quest for donors to give them

more money, and meanwhile they take advantage of young people who really

want to make a difference in the world.

ddpalmer of OH 6:40PM February 04, 2010

I've been seeing your comments pop up on another news story just the other day.

I would like to know what your thoughts are regarding the killing of whales. It appears that you are for it, though you haven't stated it clearly.

What research are the Japanese conducting and what are the results of this research?

Bachamer 9:36AM February 04, 2010

National Science Foundation

NSF

Science of Spatial Learning

Center seeks to transform teaching practices.

Studying Carbon in Rivers

Researcher explores physical, chemical and biological interactions.

Challenge: Quantum Computers

CAREER awardee focuses on what they can and cannot do.

advertisement

Science Discoveries

Science Discoveries

iTunes icon RSS icon

advertisement