Is Russia Falling Behind in Space Race?

Posted: November 20, 2009

The Soyuz TMA-3 vehicle launches from the Baikonur Cosmodrome in Kazakhstan October 18, 2003, carrying astronaut C. Michael Foale, Expedition 8 mission commander and NASA ISS science officer; cosmonaut Alexander Y. Kaleri, Soyuz commander and flight engineer; and European Space Agency (ESA) astronaut Pedro Duque of Spain to the International Space Station (ISS).Associated Press logo

VLADIMIR ISACHENKOV,
Associated Press Writer

MOSCOW—Russia lacks a viable program for developing a new spacecraft and risks losing its place as a leader in space travel, a veteran Russian cosmonaut said in an interview published Friday.

Efforts to build a successor to the 40-year old Soyuz spacecraft have dragged on with no end in sight, Mikhail Tyurin told the Novaya Gazeta newspaper.

Tyurin, a veteran of two missions to the International Space Station in 2001 and 2007, blamed the slow progress on a lack of clear goals and poor coordination.

"They have issued an order for a new spacecraft without having any concept," Tyurin said.

He said officials' talk of using the ship to fly to the International Space Station, and then the moon and Mars, are unfeasible. "One vehicle can't be both a steamroller and a Formula One racer," he said.

Russia's Federal Space Agency had no immediate comment.

Last month, its chief, Anatoly Perminov, proposed building a new nuclear-powered spaceship for prospective manned missions to Mars and other planets. He offered few specifics, and the proposal sounded more like a plea for funds than a specific project.

Tyurin said that work on the prospective ship has proceeded slowly, with engineers continuing to argue over such basic things as whether the new spacecraft should come back using parachutes, like the Soyuz, or land like a plane, similar to the U.S. shuttles.

Russia has used the Soyuz and Progress spacecraft, whose design dates back to the 1960s, to send crews and cargo to the International Space Station. It stands to take an even greater role in space exploration in the coming years.

NASA's plan to retire its shuttle fleet next year will force the United States and other nations to rely exclusively on the Russian spacecraft to ferry their astronauts to the station and back to Earth until NASA's new manned ship becomes available.

But Tyurin warned that the failure to develop new space technologies would relegate Russia to a secondary role in the near future.

"Very soon, no one will need the Russian space program," he said. "Our partners already have got all they could from us. They won't take us into the future."

Related article: Russian Space Chief Proposes Nuclear Spaceship

---

 Follow U.S. News Science on Twitter.

I agree

The Russian space program does indeed need a vision to keep itself alive and differentiated from others. Cooperation with Western programs is fine, but in any cooperation Russia is bound to be treated like a junior partner, due to its lack of funds and outmoded technology. It doesn't really matter what vision is, as long as they have the political will to stick to it all the way. How about a space elevator? A permanent base on the Moon? Robotic missions to Europa? There are so many possibilities other than the stereotypical manned mission to Mars.

Joe of AL @ Nov 20, 2009 14:14:58 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

National Science Foundation

NSF

Bugs Inspire Creation of Running Robots

Scientists hope to develop robots that can traverse tough terrains in dangerous situations.

Naked Mole Rats Provide Insights Into Oxygen Use

The mole rat is the only coldblooded mammal, and can survive long periods of oxygen deprivation.

Communicating Using Brain Waves and a Computer

New technology could allow the speech disabled to communicate with the outside world.

advertisement

Science Discoveries

Science Discoveries

iTunes icon RSS icon

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!