Cold War: Moscow's Mayor in a Flurry Over Snowfall

October 17, 2009 RSS Feed Print

BEN JUDAH,
Associated Press Writer

MOSCOW—Moscow's mercurial mayor, famous for seeding clouds to prevent rain during parades, is escalating his war on weather with plans to slash this year's snowfall by one-fifth in the Russian capital.

Mayor Yuri Luzhkov's office will marshal the Russian air force and air defense systems to intercept advancing storm fronts and hit them with dry ice and silver iodine particles, city officials reportedly said this week.

The idea is to reduce the amount of snow that clogs Moscow's frigid streets and costs the city millions to manage.

Instead, the snow would be dumped on poor villages and satellite towns far from Moscow city limits — which Luzhkov reportedly suggested would help crops in surrounding regions.

The initiative could cost 180 million rubles ($6 million; €4 million), but the city hopes to save 300 million rubles ($10 million; €6.7 million) in snow removal, Moscow public works chief Andrei Tsybin said Wednesday, according to the state-run ITAR-Tass news agency and other Russian media. City officials declined to comment Friday on details of the plan.

Moscow has been hard hit by the recession, and city officials suggested the anti-snow effort — to run from mid-November to March — would help Moscow bring its budget under control.

"If it works out, Chicago or Montreal may want to copy us," said Kremlin-linked lawmaker Sergei Markov, who like Luzhkov belongs to the dominant United Russia party.

Philip Brown, cloud physics research manager at the British national weather service, suggested the idea is relatively untested.

"A lot of work has been done with cloud seeding in terms of trying to enhance rainfall, but I'm not aware of any studies in the scientific literature that have been done for the purpose of snow limiting," he said.

Moscow — which sees snowfalls of more than 60 centimeters (24 inches) — keeps a mammoth system in place to deal with it, including more than 50,000 street sweepers, more than 5,800 trucks and 27 snow-melting incinerators. The city also sprays chemicals and grit over streets to aid traffic, and according to one of Moscow's many urban legends, dogs occasionally die after licking slush off their paws.

But there has been opposition to the anti-snow plan from environmentalists and officials from the province that rings Moscow.

"We'll need extra money for removing the snow. Where will we get it from?" Pavel Lyzhkov, a provincial public works official, told the newspaper Izvestia. He also questioned the environmental effects, saying cloud-seeding operations over the summer had turned cucumbers yellow.

A World Wildlife Fund worker was concerned the effort might end up killing animals. "This technology is still in it's infancy — it should be handled with care," Alexei Kokorin said.

Greenpeace Russia activist Alexey Kisilev predicted serious environmental damage, noting the "huge outdated aircraft" to be used in the effort would "produce lots of greenhouse gases."

"I seriously doubt an effective environmental review would ever allow Luzhkov to undertake such plans," Kisilev said, but added that he thought it unlikely the city would conduct such a review.

One political analyst called the plan a populist measure designed to strengthen the eroding political position of Luzkhov, who has been mayor of Russia's capital since 1992.

"I feel Luzhkov is on his way out as mayor of Moscow," analyst Nikolai Petrov said.

Boris Nemtsov, an opposition leader and former regional governor, also denounced Luzhkov's struggle against the snow.

"He is an old man and does not understand you cannot change a millennia-old climate," said Nemtsov, head of the group Solidarity. "This plan will kill Moscow's trees. They need snow to survive the winter. Luzhkov is simply dangerous to the people of Moscow."

Tags:
weather,
Russia,
science

Reader Comments Read all comments (2)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

The centre of Moscow is overloaded by commercial offices and jammed by cars. Additional difficulties in winter are caused by snow, ice-covered ground and brown slash coming from thawing snow and salt mixtures strewn in the streets to lower the freezing point. It helps to cut down the cost of clearing the roads by snow-removal, which is associated with noise, fuel consumption and air pollution. Street cleaning is complicated by notorious inability of the Traffic Police (GIBDD) to maintain order, particularly in regard to the parking, to remove the cars standing around in the city centre weeks or months on end, often violating the Traffic Code. An example: massive parking of the commuters' and other cars, day and night, before the apartment house Klimentovski per. 6 (near metro Novokuznetskaya) in spite of the "No Entry" signs. The best way out of the traffic gridlock in the capital, apart from the bicentric concept proposed for the General Layout of Moscow, must be elevation of the vehicle tax, which is comparatively very low in Russia. Necessity of the tax elevation becomes increasingly evident during the last decade because of the growing number of big cross-country vehicles used in the city from considerations of prestige S. Jargin (Moscow).

S. Jargin 2:38PM December 09, 2009

i like your speech about that there will no know snow in winter

zach of CO 5:54PM December 07, 2009

National Science Foundation

NSF

Science of Spatial Learning

Center seeks to transform teaching practices.

Studying Carbon in Rivers

Researcher explores physical, chemical and biological interactions.

Challenge: Quantum Computers

CAREER awardee focuses on what they can and cannot do.

advertisement

Science Discoveries

Science Discoveries

iTunes icon RSS icon

advertisement