How Bees, Ants, and Other Animals Ace Group Decision-Making

Reader Comments

Back to article

ZWIYUE

Xqykkpdf of IA 1:54AM July 14, 2009

This Susan charachature has issues when she makes a concerted effort to inject "hers and his" to her observation.

This leads to another observation of "colonies." All males, males and females, or just females. Or should I have said Al females, females and males, or only females??

I have worked in many manufacturing plants over the years where many adults spend more of the waking hours with each other than with their families.

It is not so much how they interact or interfere with each other at the tasks at hand (hence just doing bee things)but more of seeing how they behave with the idle time within the groups.

Watch how problems like their immediate job, families and outside purchases are discussed and what is resolved or determined.

It is absolutely fascinating and I am no behavior scientist!

These groups come together to feed this "queen" from various communities. How they manage to get their "bee duties" done is a science in itself.

Watch how outside interferences influence the mood of the hive. If a new Walmart or "queen" is looking to build nearby then all of a sudden you have small groups buzzing about what is right or wrong about it and how it will affect them.Then they tend to gang up against the need for the Walmart but will end up shopping there in the end. They stay with the "queen."

Take an internal influence like "the company" telling them how things are going to change, good or bad, and the hive begins to buzz into little groups looking for sympathetic alliances.

If a union is in place they seek solice to attack their own "queen." If no union is in place then some will leave the "queen" if it is not what they want in the end.

So a centralized plan (union membership) does work better even if the "queen" would like to eliminate the collective alliance in this case. "She" is still taken care of in the end.

rd1160 of GA 1:16PM May 20, 2009

I think we are going to see exactly what happens in the next 3 and a half years. Seems we have nothing but insects running things in Washington DC these days.

What they are doing to our nation is really "bugging" me!

Tom in San Diego of CA 12:03AM May 18, 2009

Do bees and ant colonies have freeloaders? You know, is there a big chunk that slough off work because they know the workers will feed them anyway? Do they stand in little unemployment lines, or work anyway, because they're driven to do it?

Point being - humans are not a hive of insects. We have different motives and rewards. While each may be interesting to study in its own right, they are not even remotely comparable (even if it's kind of a fun analogy).

Try taking a few million chimpanzees, throwing them into the same few square miles of territory and see what happens. Humans have done pretty well, considering we're not built to live in colonies of millions.

Rich of CO 6:28PM May 15, 2009

Apparently this supports the idea that trying to "centrally plan" social interactivity just doesn't work.

Great new discovery -- I bet the communist nations wich they had know this early on.

Maybe the US will learn this in another decade.

njguardian of NJ 10:08AM May 14, 2009

of bees, but in America with "hundreds of thousands of interactions" (not voted on in national elections or decreed by a "queen"), we got (among other things)

liquor and cold beer sold at most of the gas pumps and porn saturating the country literally at light speed inside a couple of decades.

When do WE get "colony collapse disorder", that malady affecting many bee hives?

Muser of NM 12:54PM May 13, 2009

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Back to article

National Science Foundation

NSF

Science of Spatial Learning

Center seeks to transform teaching practices.

Studying Carbon in Rivers

Researcher explores physical, chemical and biological interactions.

Challenge: Quantum Computers

CAREER awardee focuses on what they can and cannot do.

advertisement

Science Discoveries

Science Discoveries

iTunes icon RSS icon

advertisement