• Comment (14)

The Sexist, Servile Nostalgia of Pan Am and The Playboy Club

September 21, 2011 RSS Feed Print

Grudging credit must be paid to television network programming executives, who unwittingly have figured out how to address that pesky problem of high unemployment.

Ladies, step off.

[See a collection of political cartoons on the economy.]

Go home. Leave your jobs. Why would you want them? You get paid less, on average, than men anyway. Haven't you gotten the message yet? Those jobs belong to men, and if you leave the workforce, there will be more jobs available to the men of the house. Imagine how much the unemployment rate would drop if half the labor force got out of the game. Problem solved.

Mind you, there are a few jobs available to a select number of lithe, lovely women—at least according to television programming executives. And spots are, of course, serving men.

[Read: Betty Ford Was a Feminist Icon Just By Being Herself]

Following on the retro success of Mad Men, which is well-done, even if it romanticizes a time when martini-drinking men ran the show and women in tight sweaters took dictation, network television has given us two anti-female doozies: The Playboy Club and Pan Am. In the first, we see women squeeze themselves into tight satin bunny suits, serving drinks to men and girlishly blushing when one of the men (well, males, anyway, with the psycho-sexual development of an adolescent) hits on her. And how horrible it must be for the married and romantically involved bunnies—or rather, for their husbands and boyfriends, who have no problem going to the tacky club but don't want their own wives being pawed by other men who go to the tacky club. How did one patron manage to avoid such a terrible fate with the woman in his life? "I married her," he responded—then, "I made her pregnant and ugly." If that line is meant to make us all recoil in post-feminist shock, it doesn't work. It's offensive, and worse, it's just really, really bad writing.

Women who might want to wear a bit more clothing while serving men can be seen on Pan Am, a show about stewardesses. Not flight attendants, mind you—not the women (and now men) who are well-trained in safety procedures, keep their cool when there's turbulence or drunk passengers, and get paid appallingly little for it. No, these are women in tight skirts and heels who undergo "girdle checks" by superiors. These are not women who remind us of the very brave flight attendants who died in 9/11, or those who take charge during an in-flight crisis. No, they are, again, women whose job it is to serve men.

[Read: Rick Perry's Abysmal Record on Women's Health]

The economy is terrible, and in an extended period of bad times, it's common for people to wax nostalgic about an earlier era. And maybe it was simpler when women were less competitive in the labor force. But women are not willing to go back to a time when the only jobs available to them were as servants. We want more job options. Maybe even television programming executives.

 

Tags:
feminism,
working women,
television

Reader Comments Read all comments (14)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Proud2beareceptionist: I used to have a "pink collar" job. Hated it. Hated every single minute of it. The lousy pay - the lousy same boring day in an out...ugh (This is only my opinion of the office type job - not my opinion of the people who do work those jobs). So, I ventured out and got a "blue collar" job. And now I have a steady, secure career. I have chosen to live my life alone - well, for the most part anyway. I love not having to depend on someone else for my happiness - some of us are just built this way. I have never been happier or more satisfied in my entire life. But, here's the deal. I respect what you do for a living and the lifestyle that you live. I know that what you do is extremely important and if no one did it - well, we'd be in a bit of trouble. But, in return I'd like the same respect from you - rather than being called a what was that "a dried up bitch". ...and please remember that what I do for a living is just as important and necessary as what you do for a living. Thanks so much for the support.

BwordwithaCareer of CA 6:43PM January 15, 2012

The earlier comments were dead on. Mad Men is an excellent show - I love Joan Harris, she's smart and efficient and is the kind of woman that can get behind a man and help him get far - if she CHOOSES to do so. The writer obviously has a problem with nature. Well enjoy your feminine freedom, Miss Frigidaire.

Jay of CA 10:27PM October 17, 2011

One more thing: I wonder when you see a MALE flight attendant, do you still see the job as sexist and servile or is only 'servile' when the women are doing it? Seems to me women need to be more supportive of other women regardless of what career they choose, if any outside the home career at all. That is one of the reason feminism has failed. They never cared about the real working woman vs executives, and they alienated SAHMs by telling them they were sitting home doing nothing and that what they were doing wasn't 'meaningful.' Who needs to be insulted like that?

Proud2BAReceptionist of OR 1:08AM September 29, 2011

Susan Milligan

Susan Milligan

Susan Milligan is a political and foreign affairs writer and contributed to a biography of the late Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, "Last Lion: The Fall and Rise of Ted Kennedy." Follow her on Twitter @MilliganSusan.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement