Sarah Palin and the Wikipedia War Over Paul Revere

June 8, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (23)

Politicians and movement leaders have long understood one ironic truth: Repeat a misstatement with enough hubris and fierceness, and people will believe it. But the Internet has added a new danger level to that destructive theme.

Witness the push-back by defenders of Sarah Palin, a could-be presidential candidate who wrongly characterized Paul Revere’s Revolutionary War-era ride. Palin, on a family vacation-cum-"SarahPac" promotional tour, told reporters Revere was warning the British that the colonists would not give up their guns. She said Revere rang bells and shot his gun as a warning. Historians disagree (Revere was actually warning his comrades, not the enemy British soldiers), but Palin fans rushed to edit the online encyclopedia Wikipedia to rewrite history, seeking to turn Palin’s misstatement into historical fact. (Wikipedia has since locked the page on Revere while things calm down.)

[See 5 reasons Palin will win the 2012 GOP nod. and 5 reasons she won't.]

The concept isn’t entirely new—and as David Farenthold very smartly pointed out in the Washington Post this week—many politicians have fallen prey to Internet misinformation, repeating quotes from historical figures that were never uttered. And as many lawmakers and public figures have learned, it’s very difficult to undo bad information communicated by the web, since so many people continue to hit the "forward" button on mischaracterizations and outright lies repeated online. It’s one of the reasons members of Congress repeatedly have to tell people that no, in fact, they are not spared the burden of paying federal taxes or Social Security taxes. And no, they are not allowed to go to their flights without going through security first. But so many people would like to believe that—and so many continue to indignantly post such misinformation online—that the protestations are largely ineffectual. [See photos from Palin's bus tour.]

There are some basic truths about the Internet. It can be a great way to reconnect with people one has lost track of. But your Facebook friends are not really your friends. Try actually spending time with people you like. A quote is not necessarily a real quote just because someone wrote it online; look it up—perhaps in an actual book that has been edited and fact-checked by actual historians. And Wikipedia can be a terrific start to a research project, but it also is not necessarily reliable or complete. [See political cartoons about Palin.]

As Yogi Berra once famously said (we think), you can look it up.

Tags:
Revolutionary War,
Wikipedia,
politics,
2012 presidential election,
Sarah Palin

Reader Comments Read all comments (23)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Two wrongs don't make a right. Palin was wrong and anyone defending her distorted history is wrong, too. Get over it.

Man up and admit your mistakes , Travis Meyerson of NJ.

Actual historians all agree that Palin is wrong, she butchered the Paul Revere story and phony revisionists are not going to ever change the general view of Americans that Sarah Palin is dumb and the decision to pick her lost the election for John McCain. Its turning out that Palin is as big a flipflopper as McCain.

Steve Schmidt was right, "She doesn't know anything".

Stan of CO 7:46PM June 10, 2011

I am no big fan of Sarah Palin and I even cringed a bit when I first heard her description of Paul Revere's ride. It turns out that, according to actual historians, she was right. I have heard at least three experts on Paul Revere say that she essentially got her story right, and yet the hacks and partisans continue with the tired trope that Sarah Palin is an idiot. Any defense of her must be from brain-dead kool-aid drinkers.

If Sarah Palin is such an idiot, why is there such a fevered attempt to destroy her? If she is such a nobody, why is the media chasing her bus around New England. I have never planned to vote for her for anything, but I am starting to wonder why everyone is so scared of her.

There must be a consensus that constantly harping about Sarah Palin's intelligence will eventually stick in the mainstream. You are acting out exactly what you accuse the "rubes" on the right of doing.

Travis Meyerson of NJ 2:29PM June 09, 2011

Barry earned his Nobel Peace Prize. Want more about the smooth operator besides Rose garden beer party ? Ok, here is his first 100 day worth. :

100 DAYS, 100 MISTAKES

"JOE SCARBOROUGH, GLENN BECK AND OTHERS ON OBAMA'S SHORT, ERROR-PRONE TIME IN OFFICE"

1. "Obama criticized pork barrel spending in the form of 'earmarks,' urging changes in the way that Congress adopts the spending proposals. Then he signed a spending bill that contains nearly 9,000 of them, some that members of his own staff shoved in last year when they were still members of Congress. 'Let there be no doubt, this piece of legislation must mark an end to the old way of doing business, and the beginning of a new era of responsibility and accountability,' Obama said." -- McClatchy, 3/11

2. "There is no doubt that we've been living beyond our means and we're going to have to make some adjustments." -- Obama during the campaign.

3. This year's budget deficit: $1.5 trillion.

4. Asks his Cabinet to cut costs in their departments by $100 million -- a whopping .0027%!

5. "The White House says the president is unaware of the tea parties." -- ABC News, 4/15

6. "Mr. Obama is an accomplished orator but is becoming known in America as the 'teleprompt president' over his reliance on the machine when he gives a speech." -- Sky News, 3/18

7." In early February, the 2010 census was moved out of the Department of Commerce and into the White House, politicizing how federal aid is distributed and electoral districts are drawn."

8. "Obama taps Nancy Killefer for a new administration job, First Chief Performance Officer -- to police government spending. But it surfaces that Killefer had performance issues of her own -- a tax lien was slapped on her DC home in 2005 for failure to pay unemployment compensation tax on household help. She withdrew."

9." Turkey tried to block the appointment of Anders Fogh Rasmussen as new NATO secretary general because he didn't properly punish the Danish cartoonist who caricatured Mohammed. France's Nicolas Sarkozy and Germany's Angela Merkel were outraged; Obama said he supported Turkey's induction into the European Union."

10. . . ." and he never mentioned the Armenian genocide."

11. "The picture of Obama and Hugo Chavez shaking hands."

12. "Hugo Chavez gave him the anti-American screed "The Open Veins of Latin America." Obama didn't remark upon it. At least it wasn't DVDs."

13. "Nicaragua's Daniel Ortega went on a 50-minute anti-American rant, calling Obama "president of an empire." Obama didn't leave the room. "I thought it was 50 minutes long. That's what I thought," he said.

14. "Executives at AIG get $165 million in bonuses, despite receiving an $173 billion taxpayer bailout."

http://www.nypost.com/p/news/opinion/opedcolumnists/item_iqmvJLSvDfvUIxgNkYBrjM

Bill Hedges of MO 6:02AM June 09, 2011

Susan Milligan

Susan Milligan

Susan Milligan is a political and foreign affairs writer and contributed to a biography of the late Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, "Last Lion: The Fall and Rise of Ted Kennedy." Follow her on Twitter @MilliganSusan.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement