Ruling Healthcare Law Unconstitutional Is New Sputnik Moment

February 1, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (11)

The Florida court’s ruling against Obamacare could be America’s new “Sputnik Moment.” First a federal judge in Virginia courts ruled in December that the individual mandate was unconstitutional. But when a Florida judge ruled that the entire healthcare law was unconstitutional, the confirmation came for millions of Americans and thousands of small businesses who employ them that they were justified in believing it had all gone too far.

[See a slide show of 10 ways the GOP can take down Obamacare.]

Politicians usually don’t know when they overreach until it happens. The Obama administration is still trying to define the law, writing the thousands of regulations that will soon be imposed on our nation. Americans voted for a Republican majority in November as a message that this madness should stop. Spending money that America doesn’t have, placing more burdens on employers who create jobs and requiring individuals to have insurance is not what the voters thought would happen after the 2008 election. Corporations, businesses, and associations are receiving special waivers so they won’t have to suffer the economic consequences from healthcare mandates. Even the AARP received special exemptions for the work it did to promote passage of the healthcare plan through Congress.

[Check out a roundup of political cartoons on healthcare.]

After Democrats lost the majority and President Obama shook up his staff, we thought he understood what America wanted from its elected officials. But we only had to wait a couple of months to see that the president hasn’t received the message. Before Obama delivered his State of the Union, I was providing commentary on C-SPAN’s pre-show, describing the pomp and circumstance around the affair. This was the Oscars of Washington. And at such a critical time in our nation’s history, he was expected to live up to delivering substantial positive changes.

[Read the U.S. News debate: Should the healthcare law be repealed?]

Like many political strategists, I pontificated that the president would politically move to the center on cutting spending and regulations, and emphasizing job creation. Instead, we heard more of the same tired spending rhetoric masked in creative language like spending on “investments.” He masked more energy regulations and a cap-and-trade scheme by talking of “clean energy.” Obama spoke of America being a place of innovation and that this was our Sputnik moment.

[See editorial cartoons about Obama.]

But our Sputnik moment isn’t something that America must create once again. Maybe it’s a moment when we stop the direction that we are dangerously headed towards. It could be an awakening by the other side that Obamacare must not only be changed, but be entirely eliminated. It could be the opportunity to tear up the government credit cards that House Speaker John Boehner says must be done. Many of us were disappointed that the State of the Union Address wasn’t the first step towards this, but now the Florida ruling against Obamacare could be the game changer.

Tags:
State of the Union,
Democratic Party,
energy,
energy policy and climate change,
Congress,
Republican Party,
John Boehner,
healthcare,
healthcare reform,
unemployment,
Barack Obama,
politics

Reader Comments Read all comments (11)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Does a member of congress get free healthcare from the government, or do they pick there own provider?

Kevin of MO 12:33AM April 26, 2011

The fact that this piece of garbage opinion appears on the US News website is telling. Founded opinion is one thing, clear partisanship another. And this article is the latter.

Jay in OH - I hate to break it to you, but the actual idiots are those of you on the right who don't understand the true consequences of not acting now to begin to reform the healthcare system. Is the bill perfect? No. But it is a beginning. Are you ignorant to the fact that healthcare as a percentage of GDP is growing at an alarming rate that threatens to bankrupt this country? Probably not because you really don't have anything substantive to say.

Andrea "Aware" - I'm afraid you are far less informed than you may think. As someone who not only works in healthcare but also has a basic understanding of economics (which you clearly do not have), I can tell you that the "public health" system in Florida is not sufficient to treat those who are not insured, underinsured, unemployed, etc. As Wilma clearly outlined, there are people falling through the cracks who are not freeloaders or wards of the state but tax-paying citizens who are vulnerable because of the ridiculous state of healthcare in the richest country in the world.

You say that your "medical staff" know that the bill is a "unscrupulous" - as if they are somehow educated in the economics of healthcare on a large scale because they work in medicine. If they had a degree in public health - maybe. Simply working in billing in a hospital does not qualify one to analyze complicated healthcare bills. Additionally, the AMA, ANA and dozens of other organizations representing the vast majority of physicians, nurses, etc. have come out in support of the bill and the ideas behind it. Proclaiming that you are somehow an expert because you are a nurse is dishonest at best. This bill is our best chance at meaningfully reforming a badly broken system with incredibly poor outcomes - some of the worst in the developed world - coupled with incredibly high costs - the highest in the developed world. What exactly would you suggest in your infinite wisdom Jay and Andrea? The status quo? That's just assanine and contrarian for the sake of politics - typical of the current Right-Wing.

Ben of TN 10:40PM February 02, 2011

I do not understand your comment.

The Federal Judge, Robert Vinson, ruled obamacare unconstitutional. Therefore, there is no obamacare in Florida.

Please explain what you mean...

Mary Igloo of AL 4:41PM February 01, 2011

Ron Bonjean

Ron Bonjean

Ron Bonjean is a partner with Singer Bonjean Strategies and the owner of the The Bonjean Company, both full service public affairs firms. He was chief of staff for the Senate Republican Conference under Sen. Jon Kyl of Arizona and the top spokesman for House Speaker Dennis Hastert of Illinois, Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott of Mississippi, U.S. Commerce Secretary Don Evans, and other House members. Contact him at ron@singerbonjean.com and follow him on Twitter @RonBonjean.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Political Enemies: Good vs. Perfect

In politics the perfect is often the enemy of the good.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement