• Comment (12)

The Incoherence of the 'Occupy Wall Street' Movement

November 17, 2011 RSS Feed Print

My brother lives near the Stock Exchange and ground zero of the “Occupy Wall Street” movement. He sends along this note about today’s “day of action”:

Irony abounds today as the “occupiers” try to “shut down” Wall Street. Two signs, side by side, sum up the ignorance and incoherence on display. The first reads “All Private Industry is Theft”. Presumably its owner favors state owned industry,  also known as Communism,  over private enterprise.  The second, “Tear Down This Wall (St)”. An apparent play on words referencing  President Reagan’s famous demand that Mr. Gorbachev liberate East Germany from Communist oppression by  removing its most infamous symbol. Which is it guys? Later today the “occupiers” plan to storm the NY subway system presumably because that’s where greedy billionaire bankers like to hang out and spend their ill gotten bonuses. I would call this a circus but even circuses are more than just a collection of clowns.

To be clear my brother is no more of a conservative than I am. The “Occupy” movement draws attention to some important issues, like the very real and growing problem of income inequality, and it gives progressive voice to the anger people feel about the wealthy and powerful helping the wealthy and powerful while Main Street struggles.

[Check out political cartoons about the "Occupy" movement.]

But the thing about protesting against 1 percent of the population is that mass actions end up have deleterious effects on the 99 percent. In the case of lower Manhattan, it’s having a negative effect on a neighborhood still trying to recover from 9/11.

As Susan Milligan notes, getting tossed out of Zuccotti Park is a good thing for the movement. It’s time they become more organized, focused, and politically active, stop occupying locations and start occupying the ballot box.

 

Tags:
Wall Street,
Occupy Wall Street,
politics

Reader Comments Read all comments (12)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

THREE LIMBS GNAWED OFF AND LEFTY DEM SHILL ROBERT SCHLESINGER IS STILL CAUGHT IN THE OWS LEGHOLD TRAP...

Keep gnawing Scheisslinger, only one limb left to chew off.

Then Scheisslinger with two peg legs and two peg arms would only need a parrot on his shoulder to be the ultimate lefty dems' pirate's pirate -- AAAAAARGH!!!

OWS was supposed to be the lefty dems' countervailing response to the limited-gov't/foreign-entanglement-avoiding Tea Party.

Just like Obama was supposed to be better than Bush when it came to perpetual warfare/perpetual debt.

Outside of the lefty dem shill world of Scheisslinger, Susan Milligan -- and now Scheisslinger's brother -- the actual coherent 'incoherence' of the OWS anarchy short bus is how it so closely parallels Obama being no better than Bush when it comes to perpetual debt and perpetual warfare, the latest example of which is Obama the Great's move to station 2500 Marines in Australia.

Bush's Iraq morphed into Obama's Afghanistan, which sprouted a bud to Obama's Libya, which now spread to Obama's Australia.

The valid non-anarchist element of support for OWS groks that there is a major problem with wealth and income disparity, but can't seem to connect the dots between those two things -- effects -- and the ongoing Bushobama perpetual debt/perpetual warfare cycle -- cause.

And that PD/PW cycle hit the ground running in 1913 via the Fed, the income tax, then not so surprisingly WWI. Then not so surprisingly, WWII. Then Korea. Then Vietnam. Then Bush the Elder's first Gulf War. Then Bush the Younger's Iraq war. Then Obama's Afghanistan war.

So if anyone sharing the ideals of both the Tea Party *****AND***** OWS want to do something positive about the situation we all face -- WISE UP ALREADY AND GET WITH IT:

Ron Paul 2012.

-------

PS Run this question around in your head a couple times:

Do you think such extreme wealth and income disparity could exist in an economy NOT predicated on perpetual warfare/perpetual debt???

Something VERY rotten has to exist at the fundamental economic core level for the current 1/99 situation. And that very rotten thing is NOT the lack of a new tax on the rich.

dom youngross of OH 12:13AM November 18, 2011

mel of KY

Coperate money has always been involved. barry received more money than anyone from Wall street in 20 years, oil cooperations including Gulf's polluter BP. Don't pull the wool over your own eyes.

You seem to think lower tax rate equate into something BAD. IF MORE revenue from them is BAD then it is BAD:

“According to the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the Bush tax cuts actually shifted the total tax burden farther toward the rich so that in 2000-2004, total income tax paid by the top 40% of income-earners grew by 4.6% to 99.1% of the total.”

http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/03/lying_about_bushs_tax_cuts.html

This is accomplish through investing and creating jobs. barry was for...

Bill Gate went from lower 99% and went to top .1 %.

Bill hedges of MO 4:37PM November 17, 2011

Way to simplify the situation: "Stop occupying locations and start occupying the ballot box." Yes, if only we all would get motivated to vote (never mind there was record turn out in the last presidential election). Nevermind, that electoral politics is now flooded with corporate money and will never be the same.

As for the incoherence of the message? It seems plenty clear to me: our country has been robbed by the 1%. They are making record profits while paying the lowest tax rate they've paid in decades -- while at the same time Congress is trying to slash medicare and social security and other safety nets we can "no longer afford."

Whether or not capitalism can survive this theft is yet to be determined. Unregulated capitalism leads to a gap between rich and poor, consolidation of wealth among monopolies, destruction of the environment, and war.

Bravo for the Occupy movement for not being silent.

mel of KY 2:58PM November 17, 2011

Robert Schlesinger

Robert Schlesinger

Robert Schlesinger is managing editor for opinion at U.S. News and World Report, overseeing all opinion editorial content. He is the author of "White House Ghosts: Presidents and Their Speechwriters." E-mail him at rschlesinger@usnews.com. Follow him on Twitter: @rschles.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement