Newt Gingrich's Weird 'Ground Zero Mosque' Criticism of Obama

August 16, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (18)

I read with little surprise yesterday the GOP criticism of President Obama's defense of the right of American citizens to build a Muslim community center in lower Manhattan (the so-called "ground zero mosque" controversy). John Boehner, for example, finds the decision to build a community center a few blocks from ground zero "deeply troubling"? Yawn. Then I got to Newt Gingrich's remarks, which were ...bizarre.

Gingrich, as quoted in Sunday's New York Times, said that Obama was "pandering to radical Islam." Pandering?

One dictionary definition of pandering is to pimp--to furnish clients for a prostitute. Another is to cater basely. This is generally the usage involved in political settings; pols are accused of pandering when they are transparently sucking up to powerful constituencies in the hopes of receiving some sort of reward. Mitt Romney switching from being a vocal supporter of abortion rights, for example, to being a vehement opponent just as he's deciding to run for president can be described as a pander to social conservatives in the hopes of securing the party's nomination. Sen. John McCain's hard swing back to the right on issues like immigration after being a voice of centrist reason seems to be a pander to primary voters in the hope retaining his senatorial office. One might even argue that Newt's weird warnings about sharia law and Islamic triumphalism are a form of presidential aspiration driven pandering.

[Check out our editorial cartoons on the "ground zero mosque" controversy.]

And while I disagree with the critics of the proposed Muslim community center, there are plenty of quasi-rational criticisms one can level against the president. New York GOP Rep. Peter King, who used to be more sensible, said that Obama has "caved in to political correctness," for example. I personally disagree and think King has caved in to cheap political calculations and demagoguery, but I can at least see the logic of the charge.

But Newt thinks that Obama is ... pandering to radical Islam? To what end? Because radical Muslims are a powerful force in American politics? Obama is hoping to stave off a radical Muslim-driven primary challenge?

Perhaps Newt's not running for president but is, rather, planning to become a political comedian. But if he was serious then he's less and less someone to be taken seriously.

Tags:
Pete King,
9/11,
Islam,
John McCain,
John Boehner,
Newt Gingrich,
Barack Obama,
Mitt Romney

Reader Comments Read all comments (18)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

For Cousin Vinny and those who agree with him: I came from a liberal Democratic New York City family. I have never voted for a Republican in my life, but I'm considering changing my ways. The reason is Islam. You can make sarcastic jokes and clever (but empty) remarks all you like. Muslims are different from any other political enemy. They can't be compared to other disagreeable or even dangerous groups. Imagine a mix of Nazism and religious fundamentalism with a sprinkling of primitive and brutal Third World tribal culture. That's as close as I can get to exposing the threat which is Islam. And how would I know? I was a Muslim convert who spent much time getting to know Muslims from many countries. I read the Quran, Hadith, and biographies of Muhammed. Muslim terrorists are good Muslims who emulate Muhammed. Muslims announce their intention to dominate the world and you want to fuss over local political parties! Islam is the enemy of democracy,freedom, individuality, choice and every liberal cause. Gays, women (especially feminists), pacifists, multiculturalists, Pagans, Jews, Buddhists, even anyone who enjoys a beer, likes the nightlife, loves their pet dog (Muhammed hated dogs, so Muslims inherited his revulsion for man's best friend): Muslims are not your friends and they don't like your freedom. Sure, they'll use you and may pretend to tolerate differences, but in the end they will side with Islam. Check out Muslim countries and see what kind of human rights records they have. Do you think you'll be building a New Age meditation center, holding a gay pride parade, or wearing a bikini at your favorite pool or beach if the Muslim community has its way? The need to wake up and push back is urgent.

Bettie exMuslimconvert of WA 12:45PM September 12, 2010

It is a fool who ignores the obvious. We Americans ARE naive. We pride ourselves on looking for the best in people and assume that the rest of the world shares OUR beliefs of goodness and fairness. Oh that I wish it were so. However, for those of you who have never ventured beyond these borders to the East then yours is not stupidity it is only ignorance. You have seen our own Americans (citizens and military alike) tortured and beheaded to advance their cause and yet you still chose to believe that there is no REAL threat. My only hope is that your awaking does not come too late. That you and your famillies never have to suffer from your persistance at "hoping" others share your beliefs in common decency. We use to STAND for something in this country, now we FALL for anything. Life is very cheap in some foreign countries and when small children are used as human bombs to advance a cause it seems obvious to me that we are naive to the ways of those who would do us and our country harm. I do not believe EVERY Muslim is a radical, I do believe that there is a radical group and they are not be held in check by those that are not. As we should know, the silence of mankind against that which is evil will soon come to haunt us all. Not that I am in any way equating this movement to that of 1930's Germany, but the Germans remained silient to their situation and were later incredulous to discover the death camps. In speaking with Americans who lived through WWII who were reading accounts of the atrocities found themselves in disbelief. They just could not believe that people could be that cruel and yet they were and by the grace of God, and the actions of those with the courage to face what was really going on, we were able to stop it from spreading further. Do not assume that everyone is evil and do not assume everyone is good. Open your eyes and your mind. You know there are people in America that would steal things out of your home and so you lock your doors as a measure to prevent it from happening. Don't believe me or anyone without first objectively studing and then determine for yourself. This is a great country and others before us fought battles to preserve it. We must also fight if we wish to continue its existance.

Greg of GA 7:49PM August 25, 2010

Have you ever noticed how the republicans constantly scream that the constitution is being trampled on by whomever opposes them at the moment. But, if it gets inthe way of their agenda the constitution be damned. What is amusing is , like so many of their contradictory staements and actions, they are completey oblivious. The republicans have become a cult of stupidity.

Cult of stupidity of CO 6:40PM August 18, 2010

Robert Schlesinger

Robert Schlesinger

Robert Schlesinger is managing editor for opinion at U.S. News and World Report, overseeing all opinion editorial content. He is the author of "White House Ghosts: Presidents and Their Speechwriters." E-mail him at rschlesinger@usnews.com. Follow him on Twitter: @rschles.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement