• Comment (10)

Leave a Light on for 'Earth Hour'

March 8, 2012 RSS Feed Print

The modern environmental movement believes that mankind's activities need to be regulated by government. Increasingly, they attack the engines of productivity in the name of "health" and "safety," arguing that what man must do to survive and prosper is bad for the planet. Its agenda is largely antitechnology, antiprogress, and if fully implemented, will lead to a reduced standard of living in the developed world.

It decries human achievement rather than celebrating it. And those who believe this way are once again calling on people to turn off their lights in observance of "Earth Hour."

[See a collection of political cartoons on energy policy.]

The proponents of "Earth Hour," the Competitive Enterprise Institute says, want people to register their support for the planet by spending an hour sitting in the dark. The institute is taking another route, asking people to "Leave your lights on to express your appreciation for the inventions and innovations that make today the best time to be alive and the recognition that future solutions require individual freedom not government coercion."

They're calling it "Human Achievement Hour" or "HAH," and they want people to observe it by spending the hour "from 8:30 pm to 9:30 pm on March 31 enjoying the benefits of capitalism and human innovation: Gather with friends in the warmth of a heated home, watch television, take a hot shower, drink a beer, call a loved one on the phone, or listen to music."

[Check out the U.S. News energy blog.]

"HAH is an annual event meant to recognize and celebrate the fact that this is the greatest time to be alive," the institute said in a release, "and that the reason we have come is that people have been free to use their minds and the resources in their environment to experiment, create, and innovate. Participants in HAH recognize the necessity to protect the individual persons from government coercion, so that we may continue innovating and improving our lives and the world around us."

They have a point. The Luddite thinking that portrays technology as evil has firmly taken root in Western culture. It ignores the ways in which technology has led to an improvement in global living standards, healthier people, better resource utilization, and longer lives. To simply say that technology is bad, which is the implicit premise behind such crusades as the one to combat so-called global warming—remember it was former Vice President Al Gore who called the development of the internal combustion engine the worst thing to ever happen to mankind—is to doom all of mankind to an eventual return to the state of nature where, as Thomas Hobbes wrote, all life is "nasty, brutish and short."

Tags:
energy,
environment,
politics

Reader Comments Read all comments (10)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

It's no longer about the environment, it's about the graft.

forrest of WA 12:19PM March 23, 2013

This is hillarious ! Environmentalists are looking for safer and greener technologies while the capitalist wants to continue using outdated dirty technology just to make a couple of bucks in profit ? Who is the Luddite here ?

You say it will lower the standard of living, but with massive flooding going on many people will NOT have a standard of living due to global warming.

Consider the vested interests ! They don't want you to celebrate earth hour because they want you to continue to BUY and consume. Then again, it is this kind of thinking that turned America into a giant shopping mall and food filled with hormones and pink slime.

Oh and for the deniers who claim this is a cycle- here: http://climate.nasa.gov/images/evidence_CO2.jpg

PS: Can't wait until we run out of oil and coal ! Should be fun watching civilization crash and burn !

PPS: The state of nature is not an absence of technology, it is the absence of a social contract - pure anarchy in a way. I don't think the author had any idea what he was writing.

Eddie of NY 7:21PM March 30, 2012

"The Luddite thinking that portrays technology as evil has firmly taken root in Western culture." - Nope, but perhaps it has in Mr. Roff's mind. He's tried his best to twist Al Gore's words into support for that statement despite the fact that Gore really just wants to replace the internal combustion engine with cleaner, environmentally-friendly technologies.

Barry Rafkind of MA 11:15PM March 10, 2012

Peter Roff

Peter Roff

Peter Roff is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report. Formerly a senior political writer for United Press International, he’s now affiliated with several public policy organizations including Let Freedom Ring, and Frontiers of Freedom. His writing has appeared in National Review, Fox News’ opinion section, The Daily Caller, Politico and elsewhere. Follow him on Twitter @PeterRoff.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Political Enemies: Good vs. Perfect

In politics the perfect is often the enemy of the good.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement