Iraq and Afghanistan Strategy Debates Need to Remember the Troops

October 26, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (9)

By Peter Roff, Thomas Jefferson Street blog

DALLAS—The debate over the continued U.S. military presence in Iraq and Afghanistan is reduced too often to arguments about numbers and throw weights and force projections and politics. And, almost secondarily and from the level of about five miles up, the troops—what they need and what they deserve.

Saturday night I got to see some of them, up close and personal, at an event called Sky Ball, in an airport hangar here. I would challenge any reporter or journalist or blogger to do the same and then remain unaffected by what they saw and what they heard there.

Sponsored jointly by American Airlines and the Forth Worth Airpower Foundation, Sky Ball raises money to provide financial assistance to military families in the North Texas area. The sponsors say the support, which comes in many forms, allows them to give financial aid to deployed families and to hold departure and welcome-home receptions for troops on their way in and on their way out of combat postings. Sky Ball also supports welfare and relief projects for military units in the North Texas area and delivers care packages and other gifts to soldiers wounded in battle and recuperating at military hospitals.

All of this, sadly, is needed because of the way manpower requirements of the all-volunteer U.S. military intersect with life here at home. And, fortunately, the fact that these things happen results from the hard work of committed volunteers who understand that we are all in this together, that the welfare of the U.S. military isn't just the government's responsibility.

There are those who might say the better solution, the better way to manage the problems that occur when these two aspects of life intersect, is to end the conflicts, pull out, bring the troops home, and forget about what America stands for. It's something of a guess on my part but I'm betting there wasn't a person at Sky Ball who would accept that as a workable solution: not the decorated veterans, not the war widows, not the active duty personnel or the folks who were wounded in battle, not even the young man at my table who lost both legs and an arm in Iraq after an improvised explosive device detonated as his humvee went by.

As a nation we can argue about what the troops need. Better food, more ammunition, more armor for their vehicles, better healthcare when they get home, even an end to the conflicts themselves—the list is endless. From where I sat, after visiting with some of the folks at Sky Ball VII, what our troops need, more than anything else, is our respect and our gratitude. They need to know that the job they are doing on our behalf, on this country's behalf, matters. That we understand that they volunteered to place their lives and their limbs on the line for us and for freedom, that we haven't forgotten that fact and that we don't ignore it. That it is a part of our national consciousness, each and every day.

If they know that, if they believe that, then they can meet their mission objectives with confidence because, if we believe that, we here at home will do right by them, today and always.

Tags:
national security terrorism and the military,
War in Afghanistan (2001-),
Iraq war (2003-2011),
military

Reader Comments Read all comments (9)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Tila Tequila, never known for her shyness or sobriety or an excess of clothing, had a naked, ranting meltdown Wednesday night on her UStream channel, and today the video has been taken down. And Tila's lawyer told TMZ.com today that he's trying to get help for the star of MTV's "A Shot at Love With Tila Tequila."

Hey there everyone aparently the star Tila Tequila went crazy after her boyfriend who is aparently a football star assulted her and yelled at her for being bisexual. She then got naked and went on her UStream and chatted for a few hours about how he was a drug addict and beat her. You can download the whole session with chat included right here http://tinyurl.com/yzjyx5x

pseupierb of AL 6:10PM November 20, 2009

You have got to be the biggest Sh!!head I have ever read a comment from. As a Navy man I do not hate you, I acctually feel sorry for you..... You have no idea at the things we can get used to over there.... It all has to do with how much you can take and where you have been..... I find it hard to sleep at night sometimes... But I love this job

May God have mercy on you,

If it is right that he should do so.

Lt. J. Giles

United States Navy

SWCC

SBT-22

Always thinking of TX 10:24AM November 04, 2009

Thank you Peter Roff, for shedding some light into this issue, not many people are aware of what our troops are going through. A number in a news report can never be the same as seeing the men and women in person. It is critical that we contribute as much as we can to help those who risk their lives for us. Especially in today’s age, we must not forget, although that is sometimes difficult since the media doesn’t reserve much time for the conflict, a news report here, and a new one there. Not enough. That perhaps contributes to us forgetting, for how can we remember if we are reminded rarely?

Another problem I feel is that we are not united, we are one nation yes, but we are divided based on our opinions, I couldn’t help but notice how divided we are when I read the first comment in this column:

“It's really hard to have respect to those who choose to partake in an illegal, immoral, pre-emtive war”.

Perhaps this war is wrong, but perhaps it is right, perhaps this war is necessary, perhaps it is not. All that does not matter. I have to disagree with the above person, whether this war is wrong or right doesn’t change the fact that we should give all our support as a nation, the fact that some doubt the reasons for why we are at war doesn’t change anything,lives are still being lost. Our troops need to know we have their back. Imagine how you would feel if you came home, the place you protected, to find that people find you unworthy of respect.

I fear that we as a nation choose to not be attentive enough, that we as a nation choose the easier road and dwell in other life problems, that we as a nation choose to divide into different opinions about the war, that we as a nation choose to forget.

A random guy of GA 11:17AM November 03, 2009

Peter Roff

Peter Roff

Peter Roff is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report. Formerly a senior political writer for United Press International, he’s now affiliated with several public policy organizations including Let Freedom Ring, and Frontiers of Freedom. His writing has appeared in National Review, Fox News’ opinion section, The Daily Caller, Politico and elsewhere. Follow him on Twitter @PeterRoff.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement