Eric Cantor Is a Hypocrite on Disaster Relief Spending

With their objections to federal disaster aid, conservatives are playing politics and delaying help.


Buried in this Saturday’s Washington Post Metro section was a short piece about the request from conservative Virginia Republican Gov. Robert McDonnell for $39 million in federal disaster relief for his state.

This was an initial request for 22 localities in Virginia hard hit by Hurricane Irene. According to the article, other local governments can request more aid and, in addition, McDonnell also asked for Hazard Mitigation Assistance for all Virginia localities.

This comes from a governor who, along with his Republican congressional counterpart Eric Cantor, rails against Washington and "government spending."  [See a collection of political cartoons on the budget and deficit.]

What makes this quite interesting is the position taken by Cantor last week on Federal Emergency Management funding for disasters. We have had a record 66 natural disasters this year and Hurricane Irene was one of the 10 most costly ever.

Cantor, whose district was hit hard by the earthquake and the hurricane, has said that any spending for FEMA should be tied to cuts elsewhere, dollar for dollar, "Just like any family would operate when it's struck with disaster," says Cantor. Funny, that is not how he felt back in 2004 when he appealed for money for his district after another hurricane and voted against the amendment by Republican Rep. Jeb Hensarling of Texas to do require offsets.

Did Eric Cantor ask for dollar for dollar cuts to pay for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? Did he ask for dollar for dollar cuts to pay for the Bush tax cuts for the millionaires and billionaires? Did he ask for dollar for dollar cuts to pay for increases to homeland security? How about border agents? [Read 10 Things You Didn’t Know About the Bush Tax Cuts.]

Another very conservative congressman from Virginia, Leonard Lance, totally disagrees with Cantor. Help is needed now. Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey, no friend of government spending, talks as though Eric Cantor has lost his marbles: "Our people are suffering now, and they need support now. And they [Congress] can all go down there and get back to work and figure out budget cuts later."

It is time for a host of protesters to go to Cantor’s district office and call him on his absurdity. Does he believe we should help the victims of these disasters? Is that what government has done for over 200 years? Does he just want to play politics and delay help? Does he represent the people of Virginia? Does he care about the others who have been the victims of tornadoes and floods across this country?

It reminds me of a Senate debate where a certain Republican from Idaho was complaining about a bill that included funding for rat control in New York City.

"In Idaho, we take care of our own rats," to which the New York senator replied, "In New York, we take care of our own forest fires."

That about sums it up.

  • Read: 12 States and Territories with the Most Disaster Declarations in 2011
  • Vote: Should the U.S. Get Rid of FEMA, as Ron Paul Suggests?
  • Read Susan Milligan: Should Government Have Saved Idiots From Hurricane Irene?