What Shirley Sherrod Was Really Saying

July 22, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (22)

I’ve been watching the Shirley Sherrod controversy unfold this week--she’s the former USDA official who was fired and then was offered her job back because of remarks she made at an NCAACP convention that were taken out of context, first on a blog and then on television. So I went online and got the transcript of her entire speech. Here’s a fascinating excerpt, a part that we did not hear about this week, about the death of her father at the hands of the KKK in South Georgia in 1965:

I told how I looked forward and I dreamt so much about moving north and from the farm, especially in the South, and I knew that after--on the night of my father's death, I felt I had to do something. I had to do something in answer to what had happened.

My father wasn't the first black person to be killed. He was a leader in the community. He wasn't the first to be killed by white men in the county. But I couldn't just let his death go without doing something in answer to what happened. I made the commitment on the night of my father's death, at the age of 17, that I would not leave the South, that I would stay in the South and devote my life to working for change. And I've been true to that commitment all of these 45 years ...

But two weeks after I went to school at Fort Valley, they called and told me that a bunch of white men had gathered outside of our home and burned the cross one night. Now, in the house was my mother, my four sisters, and my brother, who was born June 6--and this was September. That was all in that house that night. Well, my mother and one of my sisters went out on the porch. My mama had a gun. Another sister--you know some of this stuff, it's like movies, some of the stuff that happened through the years--I won't go into everything. I'll just tell you about this. One of my sisters got on the phone 'cause we had organized the movements starting June of '65, shortly, not long after my father's death.

That's how I met my husband. He wasn't from the North … He's from up south in Virginia. But anyway, my brother and my sisters got on the phone--they called other black men in the county. And it wasn't long before they had surrounded these white men. And they had to keep one young man from actually using his gun on one of them. You probably would have read about it had that happened that night. But they actually allowed those men to leave. ...

But I won't go into some of the other stuff that happened that night, but do know that my mother and my sister were out on the porch with a gun, and my mother said, "I see you and I know who you are." She recognized some of them. She'll tell you that she became the first black elected official in Baker County just 11 years later, and she is still serving you all. She's chair of the board of education and she's been serving almost 34 years ...

But when I ... made the commitment years ago ... I prayed about it that night and as our house filled with people I was back in one of the bedrooms praying and asking God to show me what I could do. I didn't have--the path wasn't laid out that night. I just made the decision that I would stay and work. And--And over the years things just happened.

Her speech is long; at times it veers into a stream-of-consciousness monologue, but it’s a window into the deep South over the last 40 years and one family’s commitment to changing it. She eventually got a college degree and a job with the Agriculture Department--even though, she said, “We think agriculture is a bad word--we think it's working in the fields” and goes on to cite the low number of African-American employees at USDA. There is the now-famous part where she talks about struggling with her own feelings toward a white farmer, and her realization that poverty and need should come before race. The end of the speech is a call for reconciliation and moving forward, and a wish that the NAACP audience had included white faces as well. Sherrod appeared today on MSNBC and talked about the specifics of what happened this week, but then talked about her past and why, if she can overcome her own feelings of prejudice, then the rest of us can, too. 

We owe it to Ms. Sherrod to read her entire speech and to listen to what she had to say. In fact, if more people had done that in the first place, this never would have happened. Before the next crazy controversy erupts on cable TV and in the blogosphere, take a moment to learn what she was trying to say.

Ms. Sherrod ended her speech to the NAACP with a quote: "Life is a grindstone, but whether it grinds us down or polishes us up depends on us.” I don’t think she’s going to let it grind her down. And she said that before all this had happened this week.

Tags:
NAACP,
USDA,
race

Reader Comments Read all comments (22)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

"If I was Shirley in one of those calls before getting fired I would have mentioned mistake being made. Seems logical to me." -Bill Hedges.

What a stupid remark!! Obviously, she did give her side of the story before being fired. Her boss at the USDA needed proof of her story's accuracy before rehiring her. Much was at stake. Of course, once this proof materialized, she was offered her job back. Now she's suing Andrew Breitbart and rightly so!! And stop braying like a donkey about FOX "doing nothing wrong." They've been race baiting since before Obama was even elected. The coverage of the story, in which they jumped to conclusions before even getting Sherrod's side of the story, was disgraceful. They used the story because it fit their racist narrative of the Obama Administration. They used the story to cause racial hysteria as with all their race related stories. And by the way, none of the voters reported the Black Panthers for voter intimidation because the incident took place in one of Philidelphia's all black districts. Fear was not a factor in this issue. These mostly Black voters ignored them and didn't care about their presence at the polls.

TomW. When was the last time a white person was subject to the same circumstances as Sherrod was with the Breitbart's edited video. Were that to happen to them I'm sure they'd be reinstated too.

steve of IL 7:00PM July 30, 2010

The RIGHT “defame Shirley Sherrod ”.

How do you figure that. You was not specific !

If I was Shirley in one of those calls before getting fired I would have mentioned mistake being made. Seems logical to me.

That person who doctored the tape is only guilty person I know of. You have conspiracy information ? Heard nothing of it. Fox did play the doctored tape, then corrected story when found out was doctored.

Heard there may be ‘race calling’ new media writers list against right. Rangel has more problems. CNN in search of someone to discuss Shirley’s deal.

But The RIGHT “defame Shirley Sherrod ” not getting that.

I say let it all hang not your limited request.

Bill Hedges of MO 12:14PM July 23, 2010

This is all BS. If it was a white guy, he would be gone for good guilty or not, no matter how he tried to explain himself. End of story.

TomW of WA 12:13PM July 23, 2010

Mary Kate Cary

Mary Kate Cary

Mary Kate Cary is a former White House speechwriter for President George H.W. Bush. She currently writes speeches for political and business leaders.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

JFK's Virtuoso Turn at the Bully Pulpit

Kennedy presented a radical idea: Peaceful coexistence.

Mary Kate Cary

A Democracy in Crisis

Can the country long survive an ever-growing government?

Latest Videos

advertisement