Why Are Conservatives Ignoring Iran Protests?

January 5, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (10)

By Mary Kate Cary, Thomas Jefferson Street blog

Last June, it was riveting to watch the people of Iran protesting sham election results in the streets of Tehran. Over the holidays—Sunday, December 27 was the height of the uprising—it seemed the tide started to turn. The crisis seemed to turn both darker and more hopeful at the same time. Opposition leader Mousavi's nephew was murdered, his wife was arrested, and he understandably began to discuss his own death. The best photo of the day was taken by AFP of a lone protestor facing a mob of heavily-armed riot police with only a stone in his hand, a shot which was eerily reminiscent of that famous one from Tiananmen Square of a similar lone protestor standing in front of a phalanx of tanks.

The best—and about the only—place I've seen round-the-clock tweets and YouTube feeds from Iran is on Andrew Sullivan's blog. In the midst of last weekend's coverage, Sullivan made a good point: why are conservatives ignoring this story? It's somewhat understandable that President Obama has stayed relatively quiet, as he did in June, so as not to give Ayatollah Khamenei the ability to say that the Great Satan is on the side of the people. But why would conservatives not be cheering on the brave men and women who are facing down his regime and the police who are refusing to fire into crowds of innocent citizens? It seems like only a matter of time before the security forces completely lose their nerve and the government collapses. Why not be on the side of freedom for these men and women who are clearly fighting tyranny? Isn't that what conservatives have always stood for? Why not say so and be on the right side of history?

What's really fascinating is the role of Iranian women over the last year. Neda Soltan became an international icon after being shot on the street in Tehran--but there are many, many more women like her willing to give their lives for freedom. One Iranian womens' rights leader, Shirin Ebadi, wrote recently in the London Guardian: "Women are at the forefront of this struggle, well aware that they will obtain equality only within a truly democratic political order." Their resistance to repression could be a turning point for women within their society and within Islam as a whole. We should all be rooting for them.

Tags:
conservatives,
Iran

Reader Comments Read all comments (10)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

It would appear Mary Kate Cary hasn't been paying attention these past seven months if she is under the illusion conservatives have been ignoring the Iranian protesters.

The Wall Street Journal has had more consistent front page, above the fold coverage of the Green Movement in Iran than any other newspaper in the US and the UK. I know this for a fact because I have been photographing front pages/magazine covers for #iranelection on Twitter.

I recall a day after major Iranian protests, WSJ had a front page pic and article, but too bad for the Greens that the Yankees won The World Series the night before, because NYT devoted their front page to baseball that day. 

Fair enough, it is a New York paper, and there is a good NYT blog called, "The Lede." But not a day goes by that Iran isn't covered in the pages of The Wall Street Journal.

But let's discuss all the other liberal media who have failed the Iranian protesters.

Time magazine teased the Iranian protesters by putting them on their website as one of the choices for Person of the Year, yet ignored their votes and them by refusing to include them among the finalists. How many times has Time featured the Iranian protesters on their front cover in the last seven months? Once by my count. 

Newsweek magazine has completely ignored picturing the Iranian protesters on their front cover. Not only that, Newsweek recently had a front cover entitled, "The Green Revolution," that had nothing to do with our friends in Iran. I couldn't even bear to tell them about that knife in the back.

US News and World Report has not featured a picture of Iranian protesters on their front cover. The Economist had one front cover, right after the contested June election. The magazine, The Week, has featured Iran twice on it's front cover. The New Yorker magazine, once.

I have photographed the front pages of The Star-Ledger (New Jersey), The Los Angeles Times, The Miami Herald, The Wall Street Journal (Europe), Financial Times (UK), The Times (UK), and The Guardian (UK).  As far as I can tell, The Times (UK) and The Guardian (UK) have been the most consistent with front page, above the fold coverage of Iranian protesters in this set of publications.

But none of them match The Wall Street Journal for front page pictures, headlines and coverage, by my observation. And I have been paying attention, because I am in and out of airports multiple times a week and specifically look for #iranelection coverage to photograph and post on Twitter.

No doubt I missed some of the coverage. But as a news junkie, I would bet I didn't miss much.

So, Ms. Cary, if you want to complain about the lack of #iranelection coverage, I suggest you start with your own editors. Stones and glass houses and all. 

   

Sent from my iPhone

Connie USA of OH 11:11AM January 09, 2010

Obama's silence coupled with his persistent attempts to cut a deal with cutthroat dictators of ran is inexcusable as is the silence of most of the Western world. There have been occasional comments in support of the demonstrators from bloggers on the Left and the Right, while the Wall Street Journal has run a few editorials and op-eds in support of the demonstrators but overall the West has been much to silent.I guess standing up for human rights in unfashionable in the White House (remember not a word in defense of the Dali Lama) to the blogosphere.

AHR of NY 11:42AM January 08, 2010

Just like appeasment worked on Hitler? It doesn't bother you that North Korea saber rattles and the US taxpayer coughs up millions to pacify them? It doesn't bother you that tin horn dictators threaten and world powers bend over backwards to placate? Don't you remember how talking to the bully on the playground and trying to make him your friend did nothing? He still took your lunch money but worse, you showed what a coward you are.

Look, it did/doesn't work on the microcosm what makes you think it will work onthe macro level especially since history is repleat with historical examples.

Do us a favor and spare the trite "can't we all just get along" horses--t.

David of ID 1:32AM January 07, 2010

Mary Kate Cary

Mary Kate Cary

Mary Kate Cary is a former White House speechwriter for President George H.W. Bush. She currently writes speeches for political and business leaders.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement