Buzz Over Obama's Bow to the Emperor of Japan

November 17, 2009 RSS Feed Print

Conservatives are calling this "treasonous," and nothing could be more absurd ["Outrage Over Obama's Bow to Japanese Emperor Is Silly," usnews.com]. First of all, the Emperor of Japan is just a figurehead; he isn't a foreign head of state. By bowing low President Obama is showing his humility and respect for the entire nation of Japan, not for a particular government. Second of all, Japan is not the enemy of the United States, and it does no harm whatsoever for us to show respect to this long-time faithful ally. We have a well-deserved reputation for arrogance throughout the world and Obama's act of humility can only help us. The nationalists in this country need to stop being so insecure. Obama is mending fences, not showing weakness.

Comment by Bob of NE

Yes, a bow is a sign of respect, but it depends. A bow can be a sign of respect depending on the stature of the person being bowed to. The American president in his very low bow means he is being subservient to the Japanese emperor. He should have just bowed a little since he is of equal stature, being a head of state, but with his gesture, he acknowledged that the Japanese emperor is higher in stature. Either Obama is too naive and ignorant, or his aides did not give him the proper information, which seems to be the case in this inept administration. Also being too subservient when it is not called for can also be taken as an insult.

Comment by Matthew of NY

It is customary for businessmen in Japan to bow upon meeting their counterpart before going into negotiations. I much prefer a president who shows respect and diplomacy and accomplishes America's goals (in this case more balanced trade policy—helping our economy and jobs), rather than the Republican/Bush approach of threatening, demanding and bullying world leaders and bringing nothing but contempt for the U.S.

Comment by Michael Moriarty of CA

It's just sad to see so many people making mountains out of molehills. Of the things to get upset at the president about, his bowing to a foreign leader ranks at about the bottom of the list. Honestly, this sounds more like people looking for excuses to get mad than something to really worry about. People who are ranting about this can probably find much more productive uses of their time. Oh, and a little lesson for people who don't understand Asian culture—the more humble you make yourself appear, the more respect you get. So Obama's gesture was actually a very wise thing to do when dealing with an Asian leader, yet people insist on ranting and raving about it because he "demeaned" us. Maybe this is why Americans aren't respected much by people in the world?

Comment by Jamie of OK

The only criticism I have for President Obama's bow to the emperor of Japan was that it was much too low. The president's bow should have been higher than the Japanese emperor. In Japanese culture the height of the bow indicates position, importance and rank. In the United States-Japan alliance, the United States is clearly the senior partner. The president's bow should have been higher. I suspect the reasons for President Obama's low bow may either be due to a lack of understanding of Japanese culture or he could have been sending a message to Japan, i.e. although the United States is more powerful than Japan, we are also capable of humility and restraint.

Comment by Bill of CA

  • Check out our political cartoons.
  • Become a political insider: Subscribe to U.S. News Weekly, our digital magazine.

Reader Comments Read all comments (16)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

According to Mr Miyagi in the Karate Kid he says "look eye, always look eye" in reference to bowing. President Obama looked like he was bowing at a recital or something.

Kevin Kato of MI 10:27PM November 18, 2009

No one who has not lived in Japan can adequately interpret the meaning of Obama's bowing to the emperor. As an American who lived for three years among Japanese people, I can tell you that his bow was absolutely the right thing to do, and I'm proud that my president respected the protocol of the nation where he was a guest. Indeed, one should bow in this manner to any older person in Japan. (I think the emperor is older than Obama).

Criticism of this is a surprise, and will prompt me to write to Obama and thank him for representing our people in that gracious fashion while visiting Japan, a long-time ally of the U.S.

Margaret of MN 2:35PM November 18, 2009

Honestly how is this even an issue? The President is a visitor to a foreign country in which he has absolutely no power in therefore, whether he was the American, British, or even Russian head of State, a Japanese bow showed a form of respect to another equal leader in the world. Flip the coin and imagine Prime Minister Hatoyama, visiting the United States and shaking President Obama's hands? would that make him A weak prime minister? seeing that no leader of japan should EVER "shake hands with another head of state around the world?

keeping in mind hand shaking is not the standard greeting in Japanese culture

Rick of NY 12:00AM November 18, 2009

Letters and Comments

Welcome to the U.S. News Readers' Letters and Comments blog. Positive or negative, reader feedback provides added perspective to any story. New letters and comments will be posted here several times a week. Thank you for your submission.

advertisement

advertisement