No War on Christmas--Or on Christians

December 21, 2010 RSS Feed Print

Ross Douthat re-introduces the concept of the embattled Christian at Christmas-time in the Times on Monday. In an effort to distinguish himself from his righter-wing “War on Christmas” brethren, he actually broadens the blame game. Christians are embattled not just by the liberal media and cultural elite, but also:

Their piety is overshadowed by materialist ticky-tack. Their great feast is compromised by Christmukkwanzaa multiculturalism. And the once-a-year churchgoers crowding the pews beside them are a reminder of how many Americans regard religion as just another form of midwinter entertainment.

So, if you are guilty of materialism, celebrating a different holiday, or not going to church frequently enough, raise your hand. You offend, fiend!

While Douthat goes on to recommend some books as gifts for the pious, these too are in the Christians-as-minority-under-siege genre. Bah humbug.

I just returned an hour ago from Disney’s Epcot Center, the height of materialist ticky-tack multiculturalism. Douthat would be pleased to hear that, for a minority under siege, Christians seemed to be doing pretty well there, judging from the sloganed t-shirts, the Christmas trees and Christmas carols (yes, the religious variety as well as the secular) and the gospel choir singing at center stage. I understand from my event guide that there were some Hanukkah and Kwanzaa songs and stories somewhere, but trust me--they weren’t easy to find. They were, dare I say, somewhat marginalized.

[Read the U.S. News debate: Are the holidays too secular?]

I suppose the Disney staff and park guests might not count--maybe they weren’t pious enough. I didn’t ask the carolers or the gospel choir or the Christian t-shirt wearers or the tree how often they had gone to church or if they really (I mean really) believed. But I can tell you this much: if you were a pious Christian at Disney today and you felt oppressed, your expectations defy reason.

Isn’t it enough to embrace the holiday spirit, to spend time with family, to enjoy the music and the hope of the season? It’s been a tough year. Republicans have already played the majority-victim card on behalf of whites, straights, even capitalists. Do they have to pull it out for Christians too?

Tags:
New York Times,
religion,
holidays

Reader Comments Read all comments (4)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Christmas wasn't even celebrated by the early Christian congregation and was first recognized as a pagan/"Christian" holiday around 333 C.E., 300 years after the Christian congregation was formed on Pentecost 33 C.E. If the early Christians didn't even celebrate this (although they celebrated the memorial of Christ's death on Nisan 14 every year, and we should do likewise), why should we honor this man-made tradition?

Fran of NV 2:09AM February 19, 2011

With “Merry Christmas” disappearing from shops, Nativity scenes and carols banned from the public square, “Savior”, “God” and “ holy” being removed from school "Holiday” programs, and Christmas Tree diluted to the more inclusive, “Holiday Tree”, there's no doubt that Christmas is under fire from the p.c. crowd.

Maybe we need a visit from Marley's Ghost - I just hope the job isn't permanent.

When Dickens wrote, “A Christmas Carol”, Scrooge took timeless form as a lonely, greedy, anti-social, sacrilegious, tightwad. He wouldn’t give a farthing to feed the poor or help a family with a crippled child. He thought Christmas just a lot of humbug.

Our current crop of Ebeneezers not only see Christmas as humbug, but as divisive, culturally insensitive and intolerant humbug. Progressive humanists and relativists, who, like Scrooge, often see things that aren’t really there and ignore others that are.

For instance, they see a Constitution that excludes Christmas carols or displays on public property, but includes the right to kill the innocent, unborn. They fret and litigate over the most trivial environmental pollutants, but care nothing about the degrading pollution that pours out of the glowing tube and into the hearts and minds of our children. They worship the environment, but never it’s creator. The condition of their body is paramount, but they think nothing of the condition of their soul. They revel in the glitzy facade of our society and notice not the stench of moral decay beneath.

And, like miser Scrooge, well heeled secularists have amassed the "stuff" of life - rather than the essence of living.

To these modern “humbuggers” God has become irrelevant. His absolute morality and eternal truth inconvenient and threatening to their agenda. They would like to see God consigned to the history's dustbin or at least, confined to the margins of society - shut away in the same dark closet where we once kept immorality and pornography before the “entertainment industry” beamed it into our homes, schools and universities.

To them, Christmas has become an uncomfortable reminder - a specter from Dickens’ - pointing an empty sleeve to what is to come should they not mend their ways. And, unlike Scrooge, who merely turned away and squirmed beneath his bedding, wishing the ghosts gone, they seek relief from their fears through litigation, denial and judicial whimsy.

As the bell tolls midnight one imagines them muttering, “God is simply a subjective personal deity, different morality and values for each of us. God is merely whatever I perceive him to be. No, no, this specter of God - He can’t be real... little things effect the senses, a slight disorder of the stomach, an undigested bit of beef, a blot of mustard, a crumb of cheese, a fragment of underdone potato. I’ll just pull these covers over my head and call the American Civil Liberties Union - they’ll make Him go away.”

Merry Christmas to all and to all a Good Night!

R.L. SCHAEFER of CA 1:51PM December 21, 2010

You can always avoid seeing something by looking the other way, I suppose. Interesting that right next to your blog entry on Google News, was this entry, documenting how a bank in Oklahoma was threatened by (Federal) bank regulators with "referral to the Justice Department" unless they removed all references to Christ and Christmas from their website and bank buildings.

http://www.gouverneurtimes.com/gt-op-eds-article/25368-understanding-the-lefts-intolerance-for-intolerance.html

Of course, after "public outcry", the brave uber-regulators backed down:

http://www.koco.com/r/26174152/detail.html

I realize that to some people facts and reality have no place in politics, especially on the Left, but come on.

OffendedMan of AZ 10:46AM December 21, 2010

Kevin Huffman

Kevin Huffman

Kevin Huffman was the winner of the Washington Post’s inaugural America’s Next Great Pundit competition. He is the executive vice president of public affairs at Teach for America and, writes on the Washington Post’s PostPartisan site and at www.offthehuff.org. He can be reached at Huffman.kevin@gmail.com, and you can follow him on Twitter @huffpundit.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

The GOP Finally Finds Its Soul Mate

The rise of Rick Santorum coincides with the return of culture war.

Mary Kate Cary

Obama’s War on Religion

The uproar over the Obamacare contraception mandate is about more than just birth control and Catholics

Latest Video

advertisement