More Reasons Not to Build a Casino at Gettysburg

September 24, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (6)

I have written in this space about saving Gettysburg from becoming a third-rate Reno or Atlantic City. A developer wants the Pennsylvania gaming commission to give him a license to operate a casino on the fringes of the hallowed battlefield, and historians and local residents are marching to stop him.

Gov. Ed Rendell has joined the opposition. And so have Ken Burns and David McCullough and several actors, like Matthew Broderick and Sam Waterston. Some 300 historians, including James McPherson, Garry Wills, and the inestimable Edwin Bearss, have signed a letter asking the commission to block the casino.

The opponents of casino gambling have put together a moving two-minute film, in which several of these celebrated citizens read Abraham Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address. I recommend it to you, regardless of how you feel about slot machines and cocktail waitresses. Watching Paul Bucha, who was awarded the Medal of Honor for conspicuous bravery in Vietnam, take a turn at reading from Lincoln’s speech got my eyes misty.

The same cast also made a nine-minute video that I wrote about a couple of weeks back. It is now available, along with the Gettysburg Address clip, at the Web site of the Civil War Preservation Trust. The longer film talks with greater specificity about the issue of gambling at Gettysburg.

(For American, Civil War, and military history buffs, the Trust Web site is a joy unto itself. I can waste half a morning reading stories and playing with the maps there.)

A similar casino proposal has been stopped before. The danger is during hard economic times, the promise of jobs might carry the day.

It is pure folly. People go to Gettysburg for history and solemn reflection and (as anyone who has walked the battlefield knows) fresh air and exercise.

Granted, I am a patriotic extremist. I would have the Defense Department spend about $10 million a year over the 150th anniversary commemoration of the Civil War, until all the endangered battlefield land in the United States is safe from development.

But for you economic libertarians out there, my side wins the free market argument too. If Gettysburg becomes a cheesy honky-tonk, tourists and tour groups and school kids will stay away, and the casino--with its parasitic business plan--will fail.

Talk about killing the goose that lays the golden egg. Without that gem of a battlefield, who goes to Gettysburg? What gambler wants to hang around a small town in central Pennsylvania when Atlantic City is so nearby, or for a few hundred bucks you could be on the Strip in Vegas?

I love Las Vegas. But what happens in Vegas should stay in Vegas.

Tags:
Pennsylvania,
Ed Rendell,
Civil War,
Abraham Lincoln,
Las Vegas,
unemployment,
gambling

Reader Comments Read all comments (6)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I agree totally with Tanya Wagner above. I can also relate to the ghost town imagry, however, we have a zillion dollar name here: not likely to occur if we, pardon the pun, play the cards right! The conversations of WHAT to do vs just saying no have abounded since DAY 1. Jobs are very important; even if you remove the bias' against gambling from the moral standpoint, we would STILL be lopsided economically through further dependence on disposable dollars, entertainment dollars which in these times is a pretty flaky. Worse, the target demographic for this type of casino happens to fit our entire countywide 21 and over population and I'd submit the population of the majority of the bordering Maryland Counties. The gambling industry does present opportunity for people to do harm to themselves and those dependent upon them or close to them. I believe we can develop this area gently and profitably with non-tourism related employment and tax collection opportunities. Let us make better what we have! A couple of million would provide the Eisenhower Inn and Conference Center with needed infrastructure replacements, a revamp of amenities and get them well on their way to being a remarkable, beautiful, competitive and profitable family and couples business/corporate resort...without a casino. Without making Gettysburg a place that some people will revile because that's where daddy or mommy blew the mortgage payment after a few cocktails and a whim. I want jobs for Adams County and Cumberland Township....but not at the expense of the potential lot by lot destruction of our little neighborhood - the area formerly known as the Village of Greenmount. Commercialize gently for the long term.. no high density mish mash ticky tacky. Kind of a gateway community premise on all roads leading to this battlefield and lovely town known as Gettysburg with a balance of beneficial and responsible businesses that work in harmony with residential and agricultural life. I can see physical structures with architectural designs and materials/land use that enhance the natural beauty and rural feel of the area with harm to none. Profit, opportunity and intrisic benefit for all and dignity for our battlefield. We can break molds here, together, and set the example for other towns/areas high profile or anywhere USA. I live here, a 1/2 block away from the entrance - this is my home, dinky and handhewn as it is but its ours. I don't own a mansion or a yacht...my home isn't protected by NPS land like Mr. Levans. I'll be working until I take the final dirt nap. I speak out not just for the battlefield but for regular folks who get pounded out like burgers in the face of aggressive development: sell out or be squeezed out - give up and shut up.

Stephanie Mendenhall of PA 9:13AM September 29, 2010

You people scare me, movie stars, yea they have a retirement plan to live on. Let people come see the history cause that is all gettysburg is going to be if there is no growth it is going to turn into a ghost town. What are you people afraid of? Why is it so hard for you people to understand what is needed there, oh I know cause you don't live there, thats why !!! You dont have to be a resident of Pa, what the hell is that, so who cares about the human beings that live there, you people discuss me......a bunch of people that probably have been to gettysburg once in their lives and feel they can speak on behalf of everyone. If you want to do and respect the land do something about the dirt thats already there,oh I forgot that wont make national TV......

pat of PA 11:31PM September 28, 2010

Excellent writing. Could there be a worse place for a casino? O Yes- Pearl Harbor OR Lexington Green would be about as bad. There are sacred places to a society. And these places are not for gambling and the ancillary activities that accompany this - such as alcohol fueled drivers and "escort services". Gettysburg is special and must be preserved. Read my article at www.vvmf.org.

Jan Craig Scruggs, Esq., President,

Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund

Washington DC

PurpleHeart of MD 1:39PM September 25, 2010

John A. Farrell

John A. Farrell

John Aloysius Farrell is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report. An award-winning Washington reporter, he has written for The Boston Globe and The Denver Post and is the author of Tip O’Neill and the Democratic Century and an upcoming biography of the great American defense attorney, Clarence Darrow.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

Latest Videos

advertisement