Healthcare Bill Will Pass With Public Option Despite Media Distortions

Reader Comments

Back to blog

Come on people -- finally the dems are cohesive enough to pass this health care bill with a public option. That's progress. If anyone can revamp the health care system it's this administration! We the people need to understand that the US Constitution was signed with a veil of secrecy...and it took four months of debate before finally it was signed and there were three who chose not to buy in. Compromise is what it took. Both sides had to give and take to move this nation forward. Another four years of Obama is on the horizons. The health care issue is of complete urgency --

Laurie Richards of WA 4:21AM October 28, 2009

service air industrial variability various

neelieuhl of CO 3:58AM October 07, 2009

I note that "White trash of Tx" has a lot ot say about people, not nearly so much about the actual facts of the plan. Health care is a complex topic, but this is illustration of a simple facet: if the facts are not on your side, make the people who disagree the issue. The facts are not on the side of liberals here. They thought, wrongly, that the problem in 1993 was in how bit was sold. Instead, it's a fundamental disagreement with putting government in charge. The only thing keeping this afloat is an incompetent GOP leadership that doesn't get this, either.

Freedom Advocate of IL 12:07PM September 30, 2009

and demonize the airwaves with 'death panel' rhetoric until they are all kicked out of office and run into the wilderness never to be found..If Republicans really believed their own rhetoric and thought that “Obamacare” was really a Disaster in the making…then they would just let the Dems pass it…

and when IT Failed and became wildly Unpopular with the Voters, then they could use IT to hit the Dems over the head with, and win back the congress.

Assuming the Congress does NOT pass the Baucus Insurance Profit Enhancement Plan… I think the opposite will be the case, and a Public Option to buy into a Medicare like Program WILL be wildly Popular.

Hell its only round one to me, Bonnie. Makes it more worth fighting for.

I would more likely believe that the sore-loser-palooza-nation thinks it is April 1st..than I could believe they can think they will ever see the surface for them tanking faster than the their poll numbers..

white trash of TX 8:20PM September 29, 2009

For your information, the "Democratic Women's Working Committee" aka "Cackling Hens" is a joke and certainly not a creditable source of information. Has disarray in the Democrat party left you water carriers grasping at straws?

David of ID 2:13PM September 28, 2009

This is an amazing thing? That the media influences how people will decide and how the issue is revealed to the public? Of course this is the norm. While we each have our own ideas on how this issue "health care reform" will be resolved, the bottom line that many of us want to know is how much it will cost us to finance this reform. Congress needs to come clean and tell the public that it is going to cost each of us whether we like it or not. But whether the media tells people the bright sides or the bad side of the issue, without the truth from Congress, we the people will never know exactly what the h... is going on here!

Ben Franklin of WA 1:19PM September 27, 2009

Lets say they pass a public option my guess it will be very expensive. You will be begging to go back to the good old USA.

domino of CA 1:08PM September 27, 2009

For decades Microsoft's Desktop Applications produced/Increased Productivity, Efficiency, and Cost Savings in the Work Place.

The Proper Deployment of Health Information Technology (HIT) Solutions and Training, can Produced/Increased Productivity, Efficiency, and Cost Savings of around 20-30% Annual U.S. Healthcare Expenditure. This Cost Savings can be Used to Cover the UNinsured.

We can start with a Nationwide Network consisting of a pure Packet-based, All Optical/IP, Multi-Service National Network Transport Infrastructure, using Ethernet throughout the National Networks. This National Network Infrastructure can Serve as Business Driver for: e-Healthcare, e-Commerce, e-Education, Energy Systems, Transportation Systems, Social Networking, Entertainment, etc.

Please See: www.gkquoquoi.blogspot.com for Summary NHIN Deployment Plan

Gadema Korboi Quoquoi

President & CEO

COMPULINE INTERNATIONAL, INC.

Gadema K. Quoquoi of NY 9:05AM September 26, 2009

1. As regards a make-believe scheme, the source of funding coming from a middle class is utterly against the commitment of Democratic party.

2. No cost-competitive advantage of the insurer-friendly scheme does not clear the grave concern about the unsustainable cost of overall health care program in the long run. Baucus scheme Doesn't Bend Cost Curve Enough, Experts Say.

The scheme proposes a "fake" alternative, nonprofit insurance cooperatives -- and it places so many "restrictions" on these cooperatives that, according to the Congressional Budget Office, they "seem unlikely to establish a significant market presence in many areas of the country."

3. Even with some benefit for primary practitioners, the baseless scheme does not come with fundamental payment reform, or a pay for value reimbursement formula. It means that the insurer-friendly scheme is not cleaning up the concerns over a quality issue and $9trillion of deficit over the next decade.

((Here is some of CBO analysis : While the costs of the financial bailouts and economic stimulus bills are staggering, they are only a fraction of the coming costs from Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. Over the next decade, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that each year Medicaid will expand by 7 percent, Medicare by 6 percent, and Social Security by 5 percent. These programs face a 75-year shortfall of $43 trillion--60 times greater than the gross cost of the $700 billion TARP financial bailout)).

4. For Medicare & Medicaid system to survive from the most wasteful structure on earth, enough savings by ways of fundamental changes need to be secured, in return, the savings thereof suffice to meet the goal of well-planned public option.

((Even with far less visits to docs, which average a half or a third of them in any other free states, Americans pay roughly twice as much per person right now)).

5. For the record, prior to nation-wide deployment of reform, The State Of "Yes We Can", Minnesota influenced by Mayo clinic spends "20 percent" less per patient than the national average and 31 percent less than in the highest cost state. It highlights that no substantial tax raise is needed at least for sure.

((The $583 billion of revenue package, and the astronomical savings of public option aside, "20%" of $923.5bn (the combined Medicare and Medicaid cost per year, as of July) represents around $184.7bn per year and 1.847trillion over the next decade, and this patient-centered value alone could be sufficient to meet the goal of public option)).

6. In brief, the long-awaited and most hopeful health care plan is to meet these criterias : Affordability, Quality, and A Check function against runaway premiums thereof.

Clearly enough, due largely to its lower overhead cost, purchasing power and fundamental payment reform, the well-planned public option would be doing moore than the fabricated scheme by THE INDUSTRY in these aforementioned regards.

Now is the moment to turn page to contemporary energy and financial upgrades glossed over in 8 years.

Thank You !

hsr0601 1:18AM September 26, 2009

The public option will fail simply because the threat of public healthcare has stalled the economic recovery. Businesses are waiting on the sidelines to see what will happen; and they are not hiring. The President failed to provide a convincing argument so don’t blame the media. Rhetoric and emotion are fine for campaign season, but real policy change requires real policy with answers to tough questions. Who is paying the bill? If we have the efficiencies to save hundreds of billions then implement them now! How can simply adding 5 million people to a public option create these efficiencies when we already have 60 million covered by the government? What about the other 30 million uninsured?

Maybe he should have appointed a Healthcare Reform Information Czar to manage the situation.

Jeff of VA 10:19PM September 25, 2009

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Back to blog

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

advertisement