American Tensions With India on Global Warming Put Hillary Clinton Back in News

July 20, 2009 RSS Feed Print

By Bonnie Erbe, Thomas Jefferson Street blog.

So Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's first major trip abroad in her new post has finally shone the spotlight on her, and shifted it away from her always-camera-ready commander in chief. But is this a good thing? Last week the Web world was agog over suspicions that President Obama was purposely stealing center stage from his very popular secretary of state—as his own public approval ratings were beginning to tumble. But in the middle of her Indian tour, ripples in the normally smooth U.S.-Indian relationship began to appear over climate change:

But the clash between developed and developing countries over climate change intruded on the high-profile photo opportunity midway through Clinton's three-day tour of India. Indian Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh complained about U.S. pressure to cut a worldwide deal, and Clinton countered that the Obama administration's push for a binding agreement would not sacrifice India's economic growth.

So maybe staying out of the limelight has been a good thing for the secretary?

While major media outlets focused on the tussle over climate change, I was more interested in her remarks on U.S.-Indian relations and food security. She praised India for making progress in establishing food security.

Remember when American parents told their children to clean their plates because children were starving in India? Starvation in India is no longer the problem it once was. And Secretary of State Clinton made it sound as if India could become the food production capital of the world. But that doesn't mean starvation is gone forever. Far from it. The BBC reported earlier this month on severe water shortages in Mumbai.

There's a drought in Mumbai and nearby. But in India's so-called Bread Basket, Punjab, water tables have been dropping precipitously for years as farmers drill ever deeper to meet agricultural water needs. Many acres of prime farm land have turned to dust due to overuse of fertilizer, and eco-experts predict food shortages may soon revisit India in a big way.

Tags:
India,
State Department,
Hillary Clinton,
foreign policy

Reader Comments Read all comments (15)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Give back to your environment by sharing journey with others.

http://travelshareindia.blogspot.com/

Curly of WA 6:08PM October 20, 2011

Egad! 'The Hilly' has "dumm-it" again!

She is SO thoroughly AWKWARD! It's the only conSIStent character-trait I've observed since her 1st dummmie remark, "I don't bake cookies," got her CREAMED all over the country(!); CERTAINLY by all those very proud Arkansas 'Mom-n-Gramma-Bakin'-Homemakers!' One foolishly hoped, THEN, that Klunkin' Hillary would've "gotta BIG picture" & learned a little "decorum!" (Alas, NO!)

I think a permanent 'Broken Ankle' AND 'Broken Elbow' have FOREVER occupied the right side of her mindless brain! Her 'faux pas' are legendary! AND embarrassing! The only 'race' in which she "ompetes" is for the "1st Place Ribbon" amoung the stupidist choices made by her desparate "boss," so far!

How very tiresome has become "Klunkin' Hillary's" predictable slop, no matter WHERE she happens to "splash-down!"

As she continues to ratchet up her gaffs & UN-professional conduct all over the planet, the MERCY nature of her cabinet 'appointment' has not only become CLEER but it NOW glistens like a sweaty wrestler on a losin' STREAK!

"PeeYuu" on the Klunkin' Hill! [And I DO mean that in every available PUN!)

<3 th'Net!

Neti` Jay of CA 2:36AM July 23, 2009

The Indian drought brings to mind California's current predicament. Its agriculture feeds the world, its economy is the fifth (seventh by now?) largest in the world, and the water wars remind one of the frontier wars fought over water.

Poor Hilary didn't even get a sympathy bump for her arm; she was upstaged again by Ms. Sotomayor's ankle. Guess she's getting used to being one-upped by now.

Jill of CA 6:54PM July 22, 2009

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Get God Out of the Gay Marriage Debate

The government shouldn't tell churches who they should marry, but neither should churches tell the government which marriages it can recognize.

Concordia Ship Disaster

The Costa Concordia luxury cruise ship keeled over after it ran aground off the coast of Italy.

advertisement