Women Were Happier Working at Home? This Just Doesn't Feel Right

May 20, 2009 RSS Feed Print

By Bonnie Erbe, Thomas Jefferson Street blog.

A survey released Monday by the Bureau of Economic Research (and reported in today's NY Times) shows women were happier when fewer of them worked outside the home.

At least, that seems to be the gist of the survey's results. The Times poses the question whether this means, in turn, that men have done better by women's advancement in the workplace than have women?

I am not comfortable with that question, at least the way it is framed.

First, happiness is in and of itself a concept incapable of being precisely measured. Second, why pit men and women against each other in this way? It's silly. Men don't lose out when the women in their lives make economic gains. Sons, husbands and male partners benefit when female members of the household earn more money and have better jobs. End of discussion!

Check out our political cartoons.

Become a political insider: Subscribe to U.S. News Weekly, our new digital magazine.

Tags:
working women,
feminism

Reader Comments Read all comments (15)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

+1

soundtracks of AL 6:30AM July 17, 2009

In this generation where 1 out of 2 first time marriages end up in divorce, a women needs to work to protect herself. What will she do if her husband runs off with a younger women leaving her home with 3 kids? The courts today rarely give a women alimony. Many women only get child support which if you are lucky will pay for groceries. The single women is forced to do it all and it is a rare man that will step in to marry her unless she has a good income of her own. There really is no way to step back in time because in society today divorce is well accepted. The new younger women is not looked down upon and the 50+ older man with a new baby is completely accepted. There are more and more single older mothers every day struggling.

The best advice we can give our daughters is to put their career first before her husband and children. Relationships are rarely balanced. The person that was able to put their career first will move up the path leaving the other person who cared for the home and children well behind. Usually that is us women who were brought up to put everyone else first. Our daughters need to divorce that concept. Maybe that is what it will take before society becomes concern with the divorce rate and the struggling single older mothers. Once us women step out of the picture as the main caregivers, society

will wake up and appreciate motherhood again. But if we continue to do it all, and look the other way when we see other single mothers struggling financially the cycle will never change.

Very concerned of FL 12:50AM June 03, 2009

What if you are a single mother? What if you are a woman who can't have children? Do you just step aside and let the "fathers" earn double income? I don't think so. It's easy for younger women to assume that feminism is no good, but I remember the days when the worthless jerk in my office got a raise and I didn't "because he has a family."

Each individual woman should be able to decide what's right for her without society or some poll deciding it for her. There are usually alternatives, though single mothers don't have much of a choice unless they want to see their children starve or grow up on welfare. Often it's not about the second car or the big house -- it's about saving enough so your kids have a good education or even just the chance to live in a house with a yard in a safe neighborhood. Those 1950's images of Daddy as the sole bread winner was true only for a very brief time in American history.

Invenanet of AL 3:48PM June 01, 2009

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

No White Knight to Save Republicans

The GOP is stuck with Romney, Gingrich, Santorum, or Paul.

Concordia Ship Disaster

The Costa Concordia luxury cruise ship keeled over after it ran aground off the coast of Italy.

advertisement