Atheists, Christianity, Bush, Religion, and Why God Is Not Dead

April 30, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (65)

By Bonnie Erbe, Thomas Jefferson Street blog.

Atheists, come out of the closet. You won't be struck by lightning. I promise. I've been an "out of the closet atheist" for years now, and God (and her followers) have yet to cause me to perish. The New York Times has finally picked up on the trend and published the following this week, which I believe was the Times 's take on a front-page article in the National Journal earlier this year:

Polls show that the ranks of atheists are growing. The American Religious Identification Survey, a major study released last month, found that those who claimed "no religion" were the only demographic group that grew in all 50 states in the last 18 years.

Nationally, the "nones" in the population nearly doubled, to 15 percent in 2008 from 8 percent in 1990. In South Carolina, they more than tripled, to 10 percent from 3 percent. Not all the "nones" are necessarily committed atheists or agnostics, but they make up a pool of potential supporters.

While I hope atheism continues to expand, something tells me I've seen this movie before. I still remember the 1966 Time magazine cover that asked, "Is God Dead?":

Princeton Theologian Paul Ramsey observes that "ours is the first attempt in recorded history to build a culture upon the premise that God is dead." In the traditional citadels of Christendom, grey Gothic cathedrals stand empty, mute witnesses to a rejected faith. From the scrofulous hobos of Samuel Beckett to Antonioni's tired-blooded aristocrats, the anti-heroes of modern art endlessly suggest that waiting for God is futile, since life is without meaning.

During W's presidency, I often scratched my head and asked, after the liberating '60s and '70s, how did we ever go "back to the future" and end up in the political clutches of the religious Right? The fact is, '60s and '70s atheism was a bit too uninformed about the psychological and social benefits of churchgoing. Religion answers the unanswerable. It creates powerful and important social networks among churchgoers. Unless and until atheists, agnostics, and other nonbelievers can somehow replace those benefits, or form their own version of same, religion will continue to be a powerful cultural force.

Tags:
Christianity,
George W. Bush,
religion

Reader Comments Read all comments (65)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

i have a strong belive that god is not dead beacause he was the one who create us and he is the one that can take us back to his kingdom.God loves you so much that why he gave his only begotten son should not perish but have everlasting live.

madonna of UT 12:30AM May 24, 2010

What's up one, I'm brand-new to the forum and honourable wanted to say hey. hi love manoeuvre to know unexplored pepole and share in stuff with them

father a contented year

Ganiimpette of AL 5:17AM December 11, 2009

"Something so bad must have happened in your life that made you turn from GOD. Bonnie, where do you think you come from. If there is no GOD then what, who and where was the earth form?"

I think that this is covered in science? That the Earth was formed from particles in the universe. Besides, EVEN IF God created Earth, that DOES NOT mean that he is the Christian God, just that he exists, i.e. deitist god.

"I had a supervisor that was like yourself, unbelieving in GOD who died a horrific death. She too, felt like you do! She thought that she was also living a good life, but GOD shine on the just and the unjust."

I believe a lot of Christians, Catholics, Jews die horrible deaths. Most obvious: The Holocaust. Besides, don't LOADS of religious people die from cancer EVERY day?

"Woe unto you Bonnie! This life is not forever, we die Bonnie everyday. There is a part 2 to your being and I would hate to be in your shoes."

Are her shoes any different from yours? See above.

"GOD hear you and knows your heart Bonnie, He love you! You have to love yourself"

Isn't this the argument: God loves you! God loves you! God loves you! Therefore God exists. ??? And besides, just because someone ELSE loves you, you have to love yourself? (Don't get me wrong, I encourage people to love themselves, but not for this reason.)

"In all your happiness and wealth, you can not take one thing with you when you die, just your selfishness of your heart , here trying to mislead people into damnation. Shame on you woman!"

Why is it, that in a modern society, we can discuss issues like abortion and gay rights, but we can't discuss religion? Is this then the American "free speech"?

"GOD do not owe you nothing, you are bless and don't even know it."

Same emotional blackmail argument as above.

"Seek GOD with all your heart before it is to late! Ask HIM to come into your life and that heart of your's. HE is in control of everything. Lean on GOD and not your own understanding."

That is if God exists, which you haven't even started to prove. Besides, how different is a world with God compared to a world WITHOUT God? Science explains a lot. Besides, if God controls everything, what's the point of science? Also, if you "lean on God and not your own understanding", isn't that against everything everyone is trying to do to modernise society?

" Do not die in you sins."

Sins as defined by who? As Alan has mentioned, God did a lot of things that we would consider sins today.

I have attempted to address all the points in the comment. Please correct me if I am wrong.

Aethist 3:23AM October 19, 2009

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

An End to the NRA’s Angry Swagger

Polls show that overwhelming majorities of Americans, and even of NRA members, favor universal background checks.

advertisement