Home > Opinion > Bonnie Erbe > Abortion Foe's Planned Parenthood YouTube Trap Is Dishonest and Pointless

Abortion Foe's Planned Parenthood YouTube Trap Is Dishonest and Pointless

Reader Comments
Back to blog

I know this is an old post, but had to say something...
Okay, even if information against Planned Parenthood was obtained illegally, does it make what they did right? Seriously, I'm not understanding how on earth it's okay for a 13 year old to have an abortion! Really anyone for that matter, but a 13 year old child! What's wrong with people?
I call it pro-2nd-choice as a choice was made to consent to sex and pro-abortionists want another choice to kill! Who's there to defend the baby? Why can't life be encouraged before termination is even talked about?

Me of AZ 2:38AM February 23, 2011

"Since antiabortion foes will never succeed in banning abortion (they got as close as they will ever get with eight years of George Bush in the White House, and he left office as the worst president in American history) why don't they just go away?"
I guess the answer to your question is that they believe it is a moral issue and that unborn babies are actually human beings. I know you don't agree with that, but I suspect that if you thought some portion of the population was engaged in wholesale slaughter of innocent little puppies you would be up in arms. Just substitute unborn babies for puppies and you'll get the picture.

DavidPun of MD 10:56AM June 16, 2010

Abortion is MURDER. Plain and simple. Why don't you "pro-choicers" aka pro baby killers GO AWAY???!!!!

Erica Stone of HI 1:52PM December 22, 2009

There is really no point in arguing with the killing lobby. That they strive to cover up rape and return them to their abusers so they can make more money from the next abortions should come as no surprise to anyone. If they are OK with infanticide, what's a little rape or racism??
These 2 videos should say that needs to be said:
http://abortionno.org/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cYaTywSDmls
Dr. Mengele lives on here and now through people like this - and it makes me laugh to think that they dream about human rights will just "go away."
Good luck with that one, Bonnie!

Erin of VA 5:24PM October 21, 2009

How do you know that "antiabortion foes will never succeed in banning abortion?"
For the first time in history, the majority of Americans (51%) are pro-choice while a significantly lower number are not (42%). (Source: http://www.gallup.com/poll/118399/more-americans-pro-life-than-pro-choice-first-time.aspx)
I think it's possible that Roe v. Wade could stand forever, but giving that we live in somewhat of a democracy and the majority favors the pro-life movement today, how can you be so certain that the reverse will never be true?

Wes Siler of VA 11:03AM September 16, 2009

production kyoto techniques pattern non low

dorcivilla of AZ 12:29PM July 05, 2009

activity depletion estimate extreme net heat

vernetowne of CT 12:23PM July 05, 2009

Ms. Erbe asks three questions- I would like to focus on the third one. Here is what she asks.
"I have three questions for prosecutors who are now considering investigations into the Planned Parenthood operations in some of the six states where Rose posed as something she was not:
3. Since antiabortion foes will never succeed in banning abortion (they got as close as they will ever get with eight years of George Bush in the White House, and he left office as the worst president in American history) why don't they just go away?"
Abortion is Murder. That is why they won't go away. This is the greatest injustice and genocide. 3-4 million children per year, and its either 40-50 million who have been killed since abortion was made legal. That is why the question won't go away. Murder still is not illegal in the world. I suggest Ms. Erbe looks at the images of aborted children, as well as a video of an abortion, and realize that this is human life.
If we have laws to protect turtle and eagle eggs, human life needs protection as well.
As our declaration states All men have a right to LIFE.

Carl of NJ 4:28PM June 26, 2009

The takeaway from the comments here is that two wrongs DO make a right.

Robb Ury of CA 11:12AM June 24, 2009

I think Ms. Rose name should be changed to Liar Rose. Honestly, how can anyone believe these hokey videos? It is plain that they are highly edited to be extremely biased. The only ones who believe this baloney are those who are rabidly anti-choice and that is because they want to believe this tripe.
Not one of you anti-abortion people have the remotest clue how shutting down PP would be a public health nightmare. In these times, more and more women AND men have nowhere to turn for basic health care, except for PP. They've lost their jobs and health care. So you want to defund PP out of existence? Tell that to the countless thousands whose health care comes soley from PP because they have nowhere else to go.
Don't you realize that the majority of people seen by PP go in for screenings and birth control and pre-natal advice. And yes, PP does abortions, but so what? If a woman doesn't believe in abortion, she isn't going to get one. If she wants one, watch out, because you self righteous types won't be able to stop her, whether it's from PP or elsewhere.
The people who want to shut down PP based some on a self righteous twit's dubious view of morality are just plain ignorant.
If Ms Rose is so concerned about child sex abuse and protecting minors, I highly recommend she start with the Catholic church, which she has joined. She'll find a gold mine of sex abuse cases there.

mary of CA 8:21PM June 20, 2009