Dr. Laura Schlessinger is an Elitist, a Hypocrite, and Flat Out Wrong

April 10, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (168)

By Bonnie Erbe, Thomas Jefferson Street blog.

Conservative mouthpiece Dr. Laura Schlessinger has a new book out called In Praise of Stay-At-Home Moms.

She wrote about it in the Wall Street Journal online this week, glorifying her own ability to pursue a successful career and raise her child simultaneously, apparently never resorting to outside daycare. She also didn't miss the opportunity to slam what she calls überfeminists:

During 2007 a spate of überfeminist authors laid guilt on women who didn't abandon their children to "other care," lest they do the universe and their children actual harm (no, I'm not kidding nor exaggerating) by staying home with them. All the morning television talk shows glorified, in a largely one-sided manner, of course, that necessary course of action to avoid a woman wasting herself in the mire of her children's needs and her husband's desires.

I'd like to point out two things about Dr. Schlessinger's situation that makes her come off as more than somewhat of an elitist, and a hypocrite. First, she was not a stay-at-home mom. She apparently took care of her child part-time, very part-time. Second, she says women can do it all if they make sacrifices. Easy for her to say making a six- if not seven-figure salary (I don't know what she earns nor do I care, but she's clearly very well paid for her efforts.) She should tell that to a shift worker in a factory or a cashier at Wal-Mart—the women don't have any control over their schedules, nor do they have the resources Dr. Laura had and has.

On Facebook? You can keep up with Thomas Jefferson Street blog postings through Facebook's Networked Blogs.

Tags:
feminism,
working women

Reader Comments Read all comments (168)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I wish I could live on her "fantasy world" of a perfect life. My first question to Dr Laura would be: Who is going to pay the bills, specially for people who has elderly parents to keep? Tell me how many stay at home moms give attention to the child 24x7. Really? Maybe the TV does half of that. Because if you are home and does not have a made, is your house going to become a trash can? Can she really think about other more legitimate reasons why mom MUST go back to work besides her affirmation of "KEEPING CAREERS?" Does a mom who work at a retail store, as a house keeping, and other jobs that do not require graduation is really looking for CAREER or maybe simply need to put food on the table if he is a single mom, or husband unemployed or disabled? I used to love your other books Dr LAURA, but yours EXTREMELY GENERALIZATION and CONSERVATIVE statements does not fit the reality that exists at least NOT on planet earth for the majority of families.

Sabrina of FL 9:37AM January 10, 2013

Like the comment below says she does not have a psycology degree,anyone could get on a radio show and give advice like this. She's not licensed to give help like this. Why do people listen to her? She's just a vile,judgemental bitch who see's this as an opportunity to judge others. BTW she's a huge hypocrit,everything she preaches against he's done herself. I like were she judges Ashley Dupre for being a whore but she has photos of herself spread eagle flashing her goods. This woman shouldn't be judging a hooker or anyone,at least Ashley doesn'try to be anything but that. This pig Laura is a nasty vile bitch

Maria of MT 1:59AM August 22, 2012

About a year ago I posted a comment here on Dr. Schlessinger. I was a practicing psychologist, (not licensed), and Licensed Clinical Social Worker. I am now retired.

As I listened to this "charlatan", a word I use carefully, I decided to check out her credentials. Today, in the LA Times, (8/232/10) a doctor has written a letter stating he can't understand the "popularity of Schlesinger." The doctor goes on to say that "Any doctor of psychology...."

Here is my point again. I looked up "Dr." Laura's bio. She doesn't have a doctorate in psychology. (I do). Her doctorate is in physiology, hardly a field that qualifies here as giving professional psychological advice. Furthermore, although she attended a family therapy program at USC, (where I also received my MSW), SHE DOES NOT HAVE LISTED IN HER BIO A LICENSE IN ANY BEHAVIORAL FIELD. Why do we continue to listen to her? If she can mislead a medical doctor who must listen to her, she NO DOUBT MISLEADS ANYONE WHO CALLS HER UP ON THE RADIO.

Lastly, if you want my advice, having practiced and supervised therapists since 1975, she gives the worst advice in the world. She is denigrating and humiliating to callers, and I heard her tell a listen, "What do you expect, you killed your baby." This in response to a listener who admitted to an abortion.

Dr. Laura, I guess, can be called an entertainer. However, what I didn't do a year ago, and wish I did, was to report her to the California Board of Behavioral Sciences to report possible fraud in the advice she gives.

My own belief--she is quite disgusting.

Ralph of CA 11:32AM August 23, 2010

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Political Enemies: Good vs. Perfect

In politics the perfect is often the enemy of the good.

advertisement