Jeanne Shaheen or No, We’re Not in a Post-Gender Political World

November 20, 2008 RSS Feed Print

By Bonnie Erbe, Thomas Jefferson Street blog.

Have we arrived at the point where we are gender-blind as well as race-neutral in American politics? This morning I had the pleasure of interviewing Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire who earlier this month unseated incumbent Sen. John Sununu (R-NH) whom she ran against and lost to six years ago.

Although I Googled her name and accomplishments, I could find no mention of the fact she's the first woman in U.S. history to be elected senator and governor—a major barrier broken, but overshadowed nonetheless by the euphoria surrounding President-elect Barack Obama's White House win.

In any event, I interviewed her for my PBS program, To the Contrary, and asked her about the historicity of her victory. She said:

"Well, I think we need to see more women running, more women involved in politics, and I certainly think we saw that in this election year. And the more we see of that, the more it's going to change things in the future. My hope is—and I have three daughters—is that we get to the point where whether you're a man or a woman is not the issue. It's how you stand on what you're trying to do. What your experience and accomplishments have been and what you want to do on the issues and what I think really matters."

Senator-elect Shaheen is the expert, but I beg to differ. Are we living in a post-gender world? Absolutely not! Women will comprise 17 percent of the U.S. Senate next year—a paucity compared with their majority of the U.S. population. Same in the U.S. House.

But shortly thereafter Sen.-elect Shaheen did agree that women make a difference when they're elected to office:

"Our experiences are different. The critical the thing is that I didn't get elected as a woman. I got elected as someone who was going to work to change things for the people of New Hampshire. And I think that's what I think we're all working toward this session."

That's great and we all look forward to a gender-blind political climate. But the fact is, Senator-elect Shaheen won with 60 percent of the women's vote, and Senator Sununu lost with 53 percent of men's votes.

So if women had not supported her as resoundingly as they did, she would not be reporting to duty in Washington, D.C. next year.

  • Click here to read more by Bonnie Erbe.
  • Click here to read more from t he Thomas Jefferson Street blog.
Tags:
Jeanne Shaheen,
Senate,
politics

Reader Comments Read all comments (5)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I`m interested there`s a lot of articles on casino gambling. There are different methods, tactics, strategies, algorithms of counting, calculations and so on.

But these items are only heap of ads and i don`t want to analyze them `cause i don`t have any basic knowledge. It`s ineffective. Estimation i think will be wrong.

Is there anyone here who is interested in such topic?

I`d appreciate someone`s explaining to me is there any systems or strategies, what are they (what approaches or concepts lay in basis) and in which casinos could they be applied to?

Thanx a lot.

baron of AL 2:31PM January 15, 2009

As a Montanan living in a state with seven American Indian reservations, I truly ask if we are beyond any prejudice--or is it that African-Americans have learned to "Play the game"? We elected a man who was raised in Singapore--one of the most multicultural cities of the world and Hawaii--one of our most culturally diverse states. What does this man know of racism? We elected him based on the idea that a Harvard Law degree and a charismatic personality were better qualifications than years of service to our government and an influential role in the few positive things to happen in the past few years. Is this a post-anything world?

American Indians have no where near the role they should have in even our state government, let alone the national government. With the number of women with years of experience in the various sectors of our nation, there should be at least a couple women on the short list for every single Cabinet post up there--including Defense and Treasury--in spite of one incredibly arrogant male who thought that women should be permanently banned from these positions. We just saw an election where arguments ran from racist (we vote for Obama because he is black) to ageist (McCain is 72 and that is too old to be President), elitist ( how can a woman from Alaska be smart enough to be a valuable VP? and besides she has 5 kids and a pregnant teen-ager! How white trash of her!) to sexist ( Palin isn't a real feminist because she doesn't believe the way women should believe) We aren't any better than those who opposed John Kennedy because he was Catholic--or Mitt Romney because he is Mormon.

Maybe another 50 years might get us somewhere--but I'm not hopeful now, because the very people who are patting themselves on the back about electing an African-American President are blind to the biased arguments they used to justify voting for him.

"The greatest obstacle to discovery is not ignorance – it is the ILLUSION of knowledge.

Daniel Boorstin

MontanaMountainWoman of MT 8:44PM November 20, 2008

Great commentary--indeed, an antidote for the sickeningly "gender-neutral" pseudo-agendas of those fortunate female politicians who managed to get elected. And yet, U.S. is #71 --yes, you read it right!--#71 on the List of countries posting women's political representational impact. U.S. is #71--behind Sudan (#65) and Zimbawe and Libya and Cuba...need I go on. Just for this guy above who has doubts and wants to label us "Jesse Jacksons", Rwanda has achieved Equal Representation of women politicos. Yes, 50% of their politicians are WOMEN. And you sir or madam who criticized Bonnie's 'say it like it is' commentary, are ignorant of the reality that makes 51% of a country's population beg for its right share of rights and privileges.

One last thought for the obamyopics and Bushies out there whose camouflaged misogyny masquerades as 'deep thought' and gender-neutral insights.

Listen to John Lennon's l970 song--and see how it still holds true today....It was controversial then, and it still is not only controversial but hightly relevant--to our collective shame!

"Woman is the Nigro of the World"--lyrics by John Lenon/Ono

sakel of NY 8:11PM November 20, 2008

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Obama's Mixed-Bag Week

The Obama camp can celebrate Dick Lugar defeat, but should worry about the Scott Walker recall.

Concordia Ship Disaster

The Costa Concordia luxury cruise ship keeled over after it ran aground off the coast of Italy.

advertisement