President-Elect Barack Obama: an End to the GOP’s Southern Strategy

November 4, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (3)

President-elect Barack Obama's win is so cataclysmically historic one knows not where to begin. First, his victory signifies the death of the Old South and President Nixon's infamous "Southern Strategy," which the GOP has used successfully for almost four decades to win presidential elections:

When President Lyndon B. Johnson championed the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965, some Republican strategists saw a potential bonanza in the South. They thought their party could reap the votes of white people uneasy with Democrats, or downright hostile to them, for advancing the cause of black people.

Does it mean racism is dead in America? Not quite, but it's certainly on life support. It means what former Sen. George Allen and later McCain spokesperson Nancy Pfotenhauer referred to as the "real Virginia" (in which Virginia politics was dominated by the state's conservative southern region) has been replaced. This southern revolution is driven by the politics of liberal northerners from outside the state who have flocked in great numbers to the Washington, D.C., suburbs known as Northern Virginia and who now dominate state politics. The same is true all over the South, including North Carolina, where in Raleigh, the third-fastest-growing city in the United States (home to former archconservative Sen. Jesse Helms), Republicans find themselves outnumbered by northeasterners moving in in droves.

It also means Americans will finally have the chance to figure out what President-elect Obama means by his two campaign slogans: first, "Change We Can Believe In," later tweaked to read, "The Change We Need."

Sen. John McCain argued unsuccessfully that Obama's version of change meant a reversion to 1960s and '70s-style liberalism—or, in the phrase made famous by former President Ronald Reagan, "tax and spend" liberalism. Obama promised scores of new federal programs including an effort as large as FDR's public works program that pulled the country out of the Great Depression. He also promised not to raise taxes on 95 percent of American workers. It will be impossible for Obama to fulfill all those promises. So politics watchers will be scrutinizing him to see which ones he fulfills and which ones he breaks.

Meanwhile, the GOP needs to go back, lick its wounds, and reconfigure. My hunch is the Christian conservatives who've had a lock on the party's policies for the past eight years need to give up control to moderate Republicans. The GOP needs to revisit the "Big Tent" vision of the late Lee Atwater or be strangled by the current leaders who envision a return to the Old South. It's not happening.

  • Click here to read more by Bonnie Erbe.
  • Click here to read more about Campaign 2008.
Tags:
2008 presidential election,
campaigns,
elections,
Barack Obama

Reader Comments Read all comments (3)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Dear Jeff,

First of all, the only reason why you feel any sense of "ridicule" or "disrespect" in recent years, is because Republican George W. Bush was in office for two terms. What you call ridicule is nothing new in American politics. It's no different than the accusations about the Democratic Party Senator Strom Thurmond expressed in when he switched party affiliation in 1964. And it's certainly no different than the way Republicans treated Bill Clinton for eight years.

Secondly, you are right, so far, this is just one election. There are, however, many significant key factors that do point to a watershed. Aside from Obama himself, how does a Republican explain John McCain, a war hero and the most famous and liked politician of the Republican Party, lose- to anyone? There is no possible way McCain could have lost to anyone four years ago. It sounds to me like the voting trends of this country are changing. The same attributes that once guaranteed elections for the Republican Party are now the most overlooked qualities voters are considering when they cast their votes.

The North won!

Thanks,

Kyle

Kyle Knox of OR 7:49AM December 10, 2009

years alternative years partners stratosphere overwhelming result

joycelynns of CO 12:29PM July 05, 2009

Ms. Erbe,

I would like to say that this was just one election. I am quite sure that their are many Virginians, like myself, who take offense to your South is Dead editorial. I believe that some Virginia republicans turned their back on their party. Whether they voted for President-Elect Obama, or chose not to go to the polls, my only hope is that the leaders of our republican party took note.

I have always been of the opinion, that once the election has been decided, that we come together as Amercians and support our President. Too often in recent years, this office has faced far too much redicule and a certain disrespect. I will give President-Elect Obama, my utmost support and respect, but I will never abandon my conservative beliefs.

Likewise, I respect your opinion, but will never support your belief.

Long live the South!

Thank you

Jeff

Jeff Brown of VA 7:28PM November 05, 2008

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe

Bonnie Erbe is a contributing editor at U.S. News & World Report and hosts PBS's weekly news analysis program, To the Contrary with Bonnie Erbe. She also writes a weekly syndicated newspaper column for Scripps Howard News Service.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Political Enemies: Good vs. Perfect

In politics the perfect is often the enemy of the good.

advertisement