Democrats Don't Have the Votes to Pass Healthcare Reform

November 6, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (17)

By Doug Heye, Thomas Jefferson Street blog

We've been talking about the White House's healthcare proposal for how long now? Well, pretty much all year.

Democratic leaders promised a vote before the August recess. That deadline not only wasn't reached, it led to Democrats being savaged at local town halls that were covered live on national television. Then we were told a vote would occur in September. No dice. October? Ditto.

Now the World Series has passed (Way to go, Yankees!) and we're told a vote will be held on Saturday, a rare occurrence of Congress working on a weekend.

President Barack Obama is scheduled to visit with congressional Democrats tomorrow to urge support of the $1.2 trillion measure. That signals one thing: They don't have the votes.

Speaker Nancy Pelosi essentially confirmed as much yesterday. When asked by a reporter if Democrats had the 218 votes necessary to pass the bill, Pelosi replied, "We will." Another way of answering that question: "We don't."

And with House Minority Whip Eric Cantor declaring the bill would have no Republican votes, that means Democratic arm-twisting will be that much more severe. There's a problem, though. Delay after delay have not only pushed a vote after Labor Day and Halloween; they've also made sure a vote (if there is to be one) is after Tuesday's elections that sent a shiver up and down the spine of conservative, moderate, and, most important, vulnerable Democrats not eager to defy their constituents.

There are 85 congressional Democrats who represent districts that gave majorities to either George W. Bush or John McCain. After Tuesday's results, these members are less likely to support a healthcare overhaul with a public option, robust or not.

In Virginia alone, Bob McDonnell carried four congressional districts held by Democrats (Glenn Nye, Tom Perriello, Rick Boucher, and Gerald Connolly) with anywhere from 56-68 percentage points. Pelosi and House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer may get some of these votes, but they can't depend on them.

In fact, Hoyer has already begun to walk back expectations of the vote happening Saturday as promised. He's now saying he "expects" the vote to be held Saturday, but has said it could be held anywhere from Sunday to Tuesday, if necessary.

That means it probably will be necessary. House Democratic leaders will not bring a vote to the floor if they do not have the votes. In the meantime, keep an eye on congressional Democrats—and twisted arms.

Tags:
health care reform,
health care,
Democratic Party

Reader Comments Read all comments (17)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

After World War II, we voted to leave the war taxes in place. We used these taxes for the benefit of the American people (you know the one--of the people, by the people, for the people.) We used these taxes to put a car in every persons home, a chicken in every pot, etc. We built dams for water, sewer systems for health, roads for travel, parks for recreation, created social security, etc. It was great! Some of this is still OK.

Today, they are still taking ALL these taxes and a LOT more, but "government" is now telling us we are going to have to pay for what we need, ourselves.

The only thing which has changed is priorities; with all the jobs going overseas, we now need health care for our citizens. Are we paying for it? YES! Are some (and especially Joe Lieberman) attempting to deceive us and use OUR MONEY for THEIR PURPOSES? YES?

Wake up to reality; the crooks are in your wallet, again!

Regards,

JS

John Smith of CA 11:07AM November 09, 2009

You did a wonderful job of discrediting yourself Mr. Heye. In the future we can skip your opinions.Sara, we're with you!

Phil of FL 10:36AM November 09, 2009

Sara of OH

"Healthcare reform passed the House of Representatives because the majority of Americans are demanding it. Let's get on with it in the Senate, too."

That may your opinion but where did you get "majority of Americans are demanding it." ??? By wishful thiking ??? I know of no polls that gives that conclusion.

"Health Care Reform

42% Support Health Care Reform After Release of Pelosi's Version"

Monday, November 02, 2009

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/current_events/healthcare/september_2009/health_care_reform

Looking forward to your proof

Bill Hedges of MO 11:25PM November 08, 2009

Doug Heye

Doug Heye

A veteran of political campaigns throughout the country since 1990, Doug Heye has served in leading communications positions in the House of Representatives and United States Senate, as well as serving in the George W. Bush administration. Most recently he was the communications director for the Republican National Committee. He is currently a Washington-based GOP communications strategist.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

JFK's Virtuoso Turn at the Bully Pulpit

Kennedy presented a radical idea: Peaceful coexistence.

Mary Kate Cary

A Democracy in Crisis

Can the country long survive an ever-growing government?

Latest Videos

advertisement