Michael Barone

Is Panetta 'an Awful Pick' or Does His Selection Make Sense?

January 7, 2009 RSS Feed Print

By Michael Barone, Thomas Jefferson Street blog

I wrote yesterday about Barack Obama's surprising choice of Leon Panetta to head the CIA. Here are two contrasting opinions on the nomination, both from writers I respect: David Ignatius is pleasantly surprised; Ralph Peters is outraged by "an awful pick." Interestingly, both see Panetta as in some sense a political choice. Ignatius thinks Panetta can advance the agency's case (or the case of its career professionals) politically. Peters says he's an appointee who can convince the left that "intelligence will be emasculated."

  • Read more about the CIA.
Tags:
Leon Panetta,
CIA

Reader Comments Read all comments (10)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

slow 1980 revolution estimates range gas

waylanbeck of IN 12:29PM July 05, 2009

I think we have to look at the nomination of Panetta to the head post at the CIA in combination with Obama's choice of Admiral Dennis Blair as the Director of National Intelligence.

Panetta has the management skills and, hopefully, the business savvy, to keep the CIA's information systems and technology upgrades moving in the right direction. I also agree that an outsider is potentially advantageous to ensuring that information is able to reach the highest levels without filter.

At the same time, for those who worry about the emasculation of the Agency, with Admiral Blair at the helm of National Intelligence, you'll have cojones big enough for the entire IC to share.

I would be concerned about the appointments if, say, Blair were nominated for the CIA post and Panetta for the ODNI post. But as it is, I am hopeful that information sharing between agencies will continue to strengthen and modernize, and we will return ourselves to the most efficient and respected IC in the world.

S. Roberts of DC 4:28PM January 15, 2009

The CIA is one of the most important bastions of our homeland security. Why on earth did Obama select someone with absolutely no experience in intelligence work? Is Obama deliberately putting our country at risk? Why?

TOM of NM 4:26PM January 14, 2009

Michael Barone

Michael Barone

U.S. News Weekly

Subscribe Today

Order the new U.S. News Weekly digital magazine at a special low introductory price!

Michael Barone is a senior writer for U.S.News & World Report and principal coauthor of The Almanac of American Politics. He has written for many publications—including the Economist and the New York Times.

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

It’s Washington’s Birthday—Not Presidents' Day

It's time for Obama and Congress to give Presidents’ Day back to George Washington.

Cuba Is Reforming, But Not Nearly Enough

Cuban officials exaggerate the extent of reforms being enacted in the Castro brothers' Cuba.

Rick Santorum Will Spell Doom for Republicans in November

If it nominates Rick Santorum over MItt Romney, the GOP will lose the White House and elections at all other levels.

Obama's Energy Policy Isn't 'Crony Capitalism'

A majority of the energy companies who have received funds under Obama are thriving

Michigan Is a Must-Win ... For Rick Santorum

Winning in Michigan is at least as important to Santorum's campaign as it is to Romney's.

Why the Catholic Contraception Controversy Is So American

Politically speaking, the contraception controversy is a quirk of the way we pay for healthcare.

The Upside of the Racist Hoekstra Ad

In this era of nasty political rhetoric and advertising, the public will draw the line at something brazenly racist.

Barack Obama's Budget Is Even Worse Than It Looks

If Obama's budget for FY 2013 is adopted as written, the federal budget would never balance again.

Does BP CEO Tony Hayward Need R&R?

The CEO has gone AWOL amid the oil spill disaster.