Lincoln Reacts to Glenn Beck and His Tea Party Visitors

August 30, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (25)

Who were those people disturbing a body's summer morning peace? Why were they on the marble steps of my front porch, deluging me from every direction? My friends, in all my years on this chair in this temple of democracy, this rambling talk of 'restoring honor,' leaves me of all people--speechless!

It felt like a heap of Confederate sons and daughters coming to take revenge on me for winning the war. But their leader was a counterfeit fellow, nothing next to General Robert E. Lee or even the little giant, Stephen Douglas. As a captive audience, I had to receive this throng with the same wise expression on my face.  But truly I was dying inside.

First my friends--the absence of ceremonial courtesies, words of good will, to the president was insolent at best.  As I am the master of politics, the original man of the people, so I know a hostile house. However, my foe Senator Douglas held my hat when I was sworn in as president of the United States. Today the undercurrent of displeasure toward the president gave me a shiver.

And I ask, are these people unfamiliar with the sacred separation of Church and State? We are not a Christian nation; please tell those people that Thomas Jefferson also recoiled with horror over at *his* memorial at the blaring religious references.  To be honest, God should only be mentioned sparingly in speeches, like the address I gave on a great battlefield. Don't bring God into my temple--this is not a house of worship. 

This glib fellow appropriated everything he could take with his hands and then some. The Washington Monument, for example--is made of a different stone after the Civil War years. Everybody schooled with an elementary knowledge of the nation's capital knows that. My poor Virginian friend Washington was subjected to a rant suggesting that "nobody" knew this fact--which was cast as divine revelation. Somehow the counterfeit compared this event to Woodstock, which I am reliably told was carnival of the first order.

Give me Bruce Springsteen, Pete Seeger, Barack Obama any day--let them sing American ballads like "This is Your Land." That's the kind of company I enjoy. The Marine Band may play to its heart's content, I might add.

The most splendid things have happened here on my watch. This is the outdoor theater of American democracy. The voice of Marian Anderson, the contralto who could make slain dreams wake, shattered the glass house the Daughters of the American Revolution had built, trying to keep her from performing in 1939 (because of her race.) Mrs. Roosevelt put paid to that prejudice.

No words can capture the glory of the “I Have a Dream” speech uttered here in 1963, on an August day like this, a triumphal vision of peace by the Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. (He was a real reverend, with a Ph.D., unlike my weekend visitor.)  King soared as the most stirring speaker Abe Lincoln has ever heard, lifting up voices and hearts to sing from the South to the North, the East to the West.

After that, now this?

Tags:
Abraham Lincoln,
Glenn Beck,
Martin Luther King Jr.

Reader Comments Read all comments (25)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Jamie, seriously. Do your homework. Lincoln was no more a 'man of the people' than other would be tyrants. He was a statist who shredded the Constitution, imprisoned those who spoke against him (and all in the north no less), and thought blacks something less than human. In fact, the man was signatory to the movement that sought to send them to the Caribbean if not all the way back to Africa. Please read "In The Course of Human Events" by C Addams. Well researched analysis of the events of the 1850s and 1860s concerning Lincoln and Seward.

The Emancipation Proclamation freed no one and most assuredly not the slaves of the north (he didn't want to deprive northerners of their property without due process.). That was left to the 13th amendment. Also, had the federal government sold land in the Great Plains at a fair market value and not given massive concessions to 'friends' to build the railroads, slavery could have been ended in the US with economic adjustments for slave owners as had been done in England. You'll agree everyone north and south "benefited" from slavery at some point. At the very least, some 350,000 northern soldiers' lives would not have been lost (I'm sure you care not a whit for Southern losses- 300,000 soldiers and some 50,000 civilians). Of course, neither John D Rockefeller nor JP Morgan would have made such vast fortunes to further their 'robber baron' activities or Gilded Age abuses such as the Credit Mobilier scandal.

Pat B of NY - seriously? You are a Christian who celebrates other approaches to God? Salvation is not an ice cream flavor, dear. An authentic Christian knows the only way to God is through Christ. Either you believe that or you don't. If Christ was honest and Christianity is truth, then the other ways are routes to hell. Period. If Christ was a liar and Christianity is not truth, then why bother? You can't have it both ways - unless you really don't believe in any of it so religion is just another source of amusement or a conversation piece.

Christianity is the basis of western civilization. There are other threads of Roman organization, the Greek notion of citizen soldier/participant and the English notion of self-governance and common law, but at the core - there is the mercy and grace of Jesus Christ.

I look at other systems of governance void of the Judeo-Christian ethics and sense of covenant relationships and see only tyranny and death. The Godless collectivism of Marx, the nihilism of Darwin mixed together with the arrogance of the Fabians created the horrors of the 20th century.

Lincoln's war ushered in Hamilton's vision for America. Jefferson and America lost.

AJ Mauldin of TN 11:43PM September 04, 2010

Interesting opinion. Really? You criticize him for what exactly? For not being one of those "people who again celebrate our plurality of thought and devotion, and promote what unites us and not use the language of what divides us?" Tell me Pat B of NY, what gives you the inkling that Beck is not what you espouse? His ratings beat the pants off everyone, his viewership is in tens of millions, his message resonates with a majority of people America and his followers are Democrat, Republican, Independent, Black, White, Brown, Yellow, etc.

Seems to me he should top your list as someone with plurality of thought and devotion who is actually uniting people. It's readily apparent to me and millions of other Americans that HE is the only one that is actually bringing hope and change to America. If you are still a disbeliever then watch what happens in during the mid-term elections in November.

david of ID 3:31AM August 31, 2010

Ms. Stiehm, in her usual innovative way, has again alerted us to be aware of these expressions of so-called Americanism. It seems that the grass roots movement only has a limited view of what is America. I, too, am a Christian, but I glory in the many ways that people seek God, and I am saddened by how my beloved country is being torn apart by those that would divide us. Yes, I was there when "I Have a Dream" became our country's wake-up call. Poor, pathetic, Glenn Beck is a mouse when compared with the giants of yesterday and those who are emerging today. It is true that America is going through a rough patch nowadays. Mistakes have been made. But this period which I call America's Transition Period,is going to pass. It will take people who again celebrate our plurality of thought and devotion, and promote what unites us and not use the language of what divides us. We are all in this together America!

Pat B. of NY 2:45AM August 31, 2010

Jamie Stiehm

Jamie Stiehm

Jamie Stiehm is a weekly Creators Syndicate columnist. Her op-eds on politics, culture, and history have appeared in newspapers across the nation, including The New York Times and The Washington Post. She previously worked as a reporter at the Baltimore Sun and The Hill. Jamie's first journalism job was as an assignment editor at the CBS News bureau in London.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Political Enemies: Good vs. Perfect

In politics the perfect is often the enemy of the good.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement