Time for Democrats to Cut Snowe Loose on Healthcare Reform

October 1, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (24)

By Jamie Stiehm, Thomas Jefferson Street blog

Don't let the nation wait on the Lady from Maine anymore—to borrow a phrase for the late great Senator Margaret Chase Smith.

Delightful as Maine Senator Olympia Snowe is, as moderate a Republican as she may be, Democratic senators—and the president—have tarried too long trying to please and persuade her to be on their team when it comes to universal healthcare reform. They should stop courting her now and act like confident team players who don't need one senator to cross party lines. On Capitol Hill, it's clear the lady from Maine has frozen out the Democrats.

Democrats now have nothing to show for their efforts with Snowe except goose eggs. Neither Snowe nor any other Senate Republican has moved forward to break the impasse over a public option. Democratic Sen. Max Baucus, chairman of the Finance Committee, frittered away weeks of precious time with Snowe this summer and she never melted. Similarly, Baucus reached out to Iowa Republican Sen. Charles Grassley, who dashed Democratic suitors once let loose in the cornfields of his home state. "Pull the plug on Grandma" turned out to be the thanks they got from Grassley.

Baucus isn't the only one to blame for this futile strategy of courting one, two, a few Senate Republican votes for healthcare. He had to have some blessing from on high. At any rate, Harry Reid, the Senate Majority Leader, went along with the chairman's prerogative. President Obama and Vice President Joseph Biden, both Senate graduates, felt they could rub some shoulders, shine their light, and work their will.

Even if Senate Democrats do pick up a vote from Snowe, she doesn't bring anyone with her from her side. She's not even that close to Susan Collins, her fellow Republican from Maine. Her fellow Senate Republicans respect her, but they don't follow her legislative lead.

Last, I can promise you the American people don't care much about Olympia Snowe's vote, as long as a healthcare bill is passed into law. They really don't care if it's "bipartisan" or not—as long as the deal is done. Lawmakers have such a complex about winning a few votes from across the aisle that they sometimes squander the momentum they need for victory.

And all the pundit palaver about 60 votes to win? That means a real live filibuster, ladies and gentlemen—cots and everything. Let's just see if the Senate Republicans are in the mood to stay up all night speaking on the floor against healthcare reform. Let's see if they care to stand up and be counted. If so, that is exactly when we might see Snowe melt.

Tags:
Olympia Snowe,
healthcare,
healthcare reform

Reader Comments Read all comments (24)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Big government has not and never will work. Big government steals our $ everyday in the form of taxes, taxes and more taxes. All you have to do Mr. Brock is look at the waste and mismanagement of Medicare, the US Post Office, Social Security, FDIC, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Be careful what you wish for when you hate big business. It's the private sector that creates jobs and competition. If the government would just let capitalism work, badly run businesses will fail. Government needs to but out. And if you want a case in point just look at GM and Chrysler in a year and you will see how our government squandered away our hard earned $.

Big businesses and small businesses create jobs in America! Hard work should be rewarded and poorly run businesses should fail.

Just look at Exxon. They provide millions of very needed jobs in America and they provide income to millions of retired Americans who invest in it. They allow us to drive cars, heat our homes, and are continuing to look for oil of our own to the limit that our energy dependent nation is allowing them to.

Margaret Copeland of MI 10:21PM October 07, 2009

National Health Care Proposal

This proposal was submitted by me to President Obama and the Senate Finance Committee on Sept. 28, 2009. It is my intent to further examine, study, this proposal. Further details, including tier group breakdown will be suggested. Any and all comments will be appreciated.

Total concept of proposal.

The basic concept is to provide health care to every citizen, placing his cost within his ability to pay, and provide an insurance coverage for this care through payroll withholding and other earnings. Remove most of the financial responsibility from the federal government and provide a high efficiency throughout the organization.

The present Medicare Program does work. A National Health Care Program built on the same format, using health care providers; should also work very well. Competition is, and always will be, the key to efficiency. As this program gets underway, with competition between health care organizations, efficient operation of clinics and improved health for all, overall cost reduction should improve greatly. The government should continually work to improve the NHC Program through close monitoring of clinics and health organizations through a Review Board made up of federal, state, insurance and health officers.

Paying for the National Health Care Program

This is the most asked question and the most important need; to provide an answer that works. Right now health care providers are working with government monies provided to them from Medicare. They are finding ways to offer various health programs to seniors and operate at a profit. These providers can offer this same service for the reformed National Health Care Program. There is one big difference in my proposal; the Federal Government will not provide the money.

The general public should always have insurance to provide for the uncertainties in life. Auto insurance and home owner insurance fall in this category. The health of all of us, our family, our children, no question, is an uncertainty and therefore we should have coverage to protect the health of our family and ourselves. There are laws that make insurance compulsory for some things. Health care should be one of them. At present, our government is attempting to keep up with the health needs of seniors and others with low income – and is under great stress. The financing to provide insurance to cover our entire population for health is very great and should be handled through payroll withholding and other earnings; not from our government. It is now time to make this change. The worker should not make payments. Collect the money directly from the source where it is generated. The government will act only as a clearing house for the accumulation of monies.

Every company and organization that issues wages for services will hold back a fixed percentage from worker as requested by the Federal Government. This will show up on pay

Leonard J. Grimm of MO 2:54PM October 04, 2009

Jon of wherever, such a cowardly comment to wish bad on others. Coward!!!!!!!!your post should be removed as should you!!!

Hung of NY 12:05PM October 04, 2009

Jamie Stiehm

Jamie Stiehm

Jamie Stiehm is a weekly Creators Syndicate columnist. Her op-eds on politics, culture, and history have appeared in newspapers across the nation, including The New York Times and The Washington Post. She previously worked as a reporter at the Baltimore Sun and The Hill. Jamie's first journalism job was as an assignment editor at the CBS News bureau in London.

advertisement

Robert Schlesinger

Political Enemies: Good vs. Perfect

In politics the perfect is often the enemy of the good.

Mary Kate Cary

Washington’s Toxic Stew

President Obama's burgeoning problems affect more than this week’s three scandals.

Latest Videos

advertisement