Can the Rebels in Libya Be Trusted?

The fall of Tripoli proves to be more complicated than originally reported.

August 23, 2011 RSS Feed Print

After months of stalemate, revolutionary forces seemed to have made a crucial advance in their campaign against Libyan dictator Muammar Qadhafi. Over the weekend, the rebels pushed into the capital city of Tripoli, Qadhafi's final stronghold, and were have said to have taken over nearly 90 percent of the city. Said President Obama in a statement from Martha's Vineyard Monday: "This much is clear: The Qaddafi regime is coming to an end, and the future of Libya is in the hands of its people." [Read: Obama's Win in Libya]

However, only hours later, doubts emerged about the rebels' victory over the Qadhafi regime. Seif al-Islam el-Qadhafi, one of the dictator's sons that rebels had claimed to have captured, showed up at the Rixos Hotel where foreign journalists were staying. He took reporters on a drive to show them the parts of cities still under regime control, boasting that the rebels had been lured into a trap, that the his father remained in Tripoli, and that they were "going to break the backbone of the rebels." With his appearance as well as the escape of his brother Muhammad from house arrest, questions arose to whether rebels were exaggerating their control of the city. [See photos of unrest in Libya.]

Fighting continues in Tripoli. If and when rebels do assume full control, other concerns linger. First is the power vacuum that will be created once the Qadhafi regime falls. Argues Susan Milligan, "However awful a dictator may be, his presence usually brings a predictability and stability to the country." With tribal divisions already showing in the rebel forces, these cracks can widen to allow for Islamic extremist, often affiliated with terrorist groups, to assume leadership. Furthermore are concerns over weapons of mass destruction falling into dangerous hands. Tuesday morning Sen. John McCain called on the United States to "secure the weapons depots" in Libya and indeed the Pentagon reports that it is monitoring chemical sites. On the other side of the spectrum is the worry that United States might slip into another costly nation-building debacle like Iraq or Afghanistan. [See a roundup of editorial cartoons about the mideast uprisings.]

What do you think? Are the rebel forces in Libya to be trusted? Take the poll and comment below.

Can the rebels in Libya be trusted?

View Results

Previously: What Now for Muammar Qadhafi?

Tags:
Muammar Qadhafi,
Mideast peace,
John McCain,
Libya

Reader Comments Read all comments (5)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Are they supposed to be trusted to succumb, or are they supposed to kill?

I haven't been able to over analyze this article...but it seems that if they keep posting up like they are unstoppable , they'll be stopped. I haven't even mentioned that Americans are paying attention for no apparent reason, except to maybe gather some sort of ANGLE on immigrants in America that deal with they're own issues of ABSTINENCE, DRUG USE, or sexual crimes and passionate dreams.

Oh boy o boy. COMPASSION? THE ONLY REASON TO DE focus on our own situation is to show that our own time and situation isn't being helped...and there seems to be a definite pricetag that equates onto the respectable and comfortable life...and its them on our OPERATOR and BANK CARD telephone lines...so is that supposed to be interesting? WOW..a LIBYAN! AND the hoes, and winos?

danton of FL 3:15PM August 23, 2011

Is this a trick question or what?

Militant, orthodox Islam is sworn to kill or convert all non Muslims. These are hate filled zealots - they will never give up.

Western Civilization (the Church) fought to keep Islam from conquering all of Europe for over 1000 years. Tens of thousands of Catholic knights died from the Holy Land to Vienna to stop them. But now, through "multi-culturalism", high birth rates, terrorist attacks and apathetic Western political correctness - Islam may well succeed in conquering the Western World - ushering in a modern Age of Darkness.

R.L. Schaefer of CA 2:27PM August 23, 2011

Can the rebels in Libya be trusted? By whom? And trusted for what? I cannot believe I see those silly articles flourishing in some media outlets. And I wonder why the editors allow their publication!

Firstly, the Arab Spring has been an internal revolution - and matter- in which the people decided to take their country back from cruel, corrupt, and brutal despots. Those revolutions did not need our stamp of approval. If they needed our stamp of approval, we wouldn't have allowed them to overthrow our puppet of 30-years, Hosni Mubarak of Egypt! Whether we trust them or not, therefore, is a question of arrogance, not one in which our approval means democracy and respect of human rights. Let's not forget that the CIA was

taking suspected Muslim militants in Egypt to be tortured. The Italian judge Joseph Spataro has still arrest warrants pending for 12 CIA agent who kidnapped the Egyptian cleric Abu Omar, and took him to Egypt where he was tortured on behalf of the CIA. He was proven to be innocent later!

I take it, therefore, that those who question whether the Libyan rebels can be trusted are those hard heads who would like to see a puppet regime -like Mubarak's- in Libya. But the Arab Spring revolutions in Middle East have been against despots - no matter if they were pro-American, like Mubarak, or anti-American like Gadhafi and Syria's Assad. Revolutions are by the people, and for the people, and not for the interests or the objectives of the foreign powers and their hegemonic pursuits.

Again: Can the rebels in Libya be trusted? It is none of our business! They didn't start their revolution aspiring to become our Middle East lackeys, nor mules of our policies. That is why the new Egyptian Military Council has forbidden the U.S. from sending in its experts and $ U.S. millions to help Egypt set up democratic institutions. The Egyptians suspect that the U.S. will try to spend $ billions in bribes to buy votes and help another puppet like Mubarak win the elections. The fall of Mubarak has turned the U.S. and Israeli policy in Middle East into a disarray, and the U.S. trustworthiness in the Arab world is

almost nonexistent!

Can the Libyan rebels or the Egyptians be trusted then? well, that is the wrong question! The correct question is: Can the Egyptians, the Libyans, the Yemenis, the Bahrainians, the Saudis, the Tunisians and the Moroccans trust the U.S.? And the answer is: NO! When it comes to Middle East, the hard truth has always been that the U.S. has practically become a puppet of Israel - and they are Arabs! And this undisputed fact cannot be changed by revolutions, because the Arab psyche and instincts are anti-American from birth. Nikos Retsos, retired professor

Nikos Retsos of IL 1:40PM August 23, 2011

advertisement

Debate Club

Was 2011 One of the Worst Years for the U.S. Government in American History?

Experts debate where 2011 ranks among Washington's worst years.

Latest Video

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

May Unemployment Rate Dooms Barack Obama

With unemployment now at 8.2 percent, Mitt Romney is poised to gain ground with voters.

Planned Parenthood Pulls a Komen on Mitt Romney

Planned Parenthood successfully targeted the Susan G. Komen Foundation and is now getting political by campaigning against Mitt Romney.

Bill Clinton Undercuts Barack Obama in Wisconsin

Former President Bill Clinton is campaigning for Democrats across the country, disregarding Obama's campaign strategies.

Barack Obama Doesn’t Get a Pass on Poland Gaffe

The president's error and half-hearted apology is a serious diplomatic mistake.

Mitt Romney's Ridiculous Unemployment Reaction

Romney's dramatic reaction to the May jobs report makes him look false and calculating.

What John Edwards Tells Us About the Legal Profession

The legal profession is experiencing a very serious breakdown of ethics.

What the GOP Should Do if Obamacare Falls

If Obamacare is struck down by the Supreme Court, the Democrats are responsible for proposing another plan.

Barack Obama and George Bush Show Congress How to Act Like Adults

Obama and Bush are capable of acting like adults. Why isn't Congress?

advertisement