Should John Edwards Have Been Indicted for His Affair Coverup?

A federal grand jury says Edwards conspired to accept illegal campaign donations

June 3, 2011 RSS Feed Print

Two-time presidential hopeful John Edwards’s secret life has come back to haunt him once again. His extramarital affair (and love child) with videographer Rielle Hunter effectively ended his political career, but now he is also facing criminal charges. A federal grand jury indictment alleges Edwards conspired to accept unreported campaign contributions above the legal limits. “The purpose of the conspiracy was to protect and advance EDWARDS’ candidacy for President of the United States,” the indictment reads, “by secretly obtaining and using hundreds of thousands of dollars in contributions … well in excess of the Election Act’s limit, to conceal EDWARDS’ extramarital affair” and Hunter’s pregnancy. The indictment comes after a two-year investigation into the issue. [Read: Why Don't Men Like Schwarzenegger, Edwards Use Condoms?]

But U.S. News blogger Susan Milligan (who admires the maligned Elizabeth Edwards) believes an indictment goes too far. “John Edwards, many would agree, is quite a jerk. But is he a criminal?” she asks, suggesting it’s wrong to consider the coverup money a political campaign contribution. She adds:

By that logic, almost anything could be construed as a political donation—if someone offered to mow his lawn, is that an illegal in-kind contribution, since a well-manicured lawn makes someone look like an upstanding homeowner, and therefore a more attractive candidate? Haircuts, teeth-cleanings—is anything turned into a campaign event, just because it affects someone’s image in front of the electorate?

What do you think? Should John Edwards have been indicted? Take the poll and post your thoughts below.

Should John Edwards have been indicted?

View Results

Previously: Is the GOP 2012 field weak?

Tags:
John Edwards

Reader Comments Read all comments (18)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Another good man brought down by a floozy/gold-digger.

Edsopinion.com of CA 3:58PM June 04, 2011

Bill, I thought I had made it pretty clear that I was responding to the comments here from people who clearly want him punished for his personal behavior. I stated that I hope that the court ignores this and focuses instead on whether or not he broke the law.

You seem to have missed my point entirely...

SandraL of WA 4:10AM June 04, 2011

Has nothing to do with "infidelity" to his wife. JFK did not go to jail for cheating. Neither did Bill Clinton.

Charges against him is not "infidelity"...

_____

"At a glance: A breakdown of the 6 felony charges filed against John Edwards"

— "Conspiracy: Edwards faces one conspiracy count, with prosecutors arguing that he participated in a scheme to violate federal campaign finance laws by using $925,000 in private money from two wealthy benefactors to help keep his pregnant mistress and love child a secret. Prosecutors said Edwards knew details of the affair would destroy his candidacy and undermine his persona as a devoted family man."

.—" Illegal campaign contributions: Prosecutors filed four charges of illegal campaign contributions against Edwards, saying he was part of a conspiracy that willfully and knowingly accepted contributions that exceeded federal limits. The four charges are nearly identical, referencing contributions received in 2007 and 2008 from former campaign finance chairman Fred Baron and Rachel “Bunny” Mellon, the widow of banking heir Paul Mellon."

— "False statements: The indictment includes one count of false statements, saying that the conspiracy Edwards participated in knowingly allowed the filing of false and deceptive campaign finance reports that failed to disclose the illegal contributions from Baron and Mellon."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/at-a-glance-a-breakdown-of-the-6-felony-charges-filed-against-john-edwards/2011/06/03/AGPyDLIH_story.html

Bill Hedges of MO 3:24AM June 04, 2011

advertisement

Debate Club

Was 2011 One of the Worst Years for the U.S. Government in American History?

Experts debate where 2011 ranks among Washington's worst years.

Latest Video

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

May Unemployment Rate Dooms Barack Obama

With unemployment now at 8.2 percent, Mitt Romney is poised to gain ground with voters.

Planned Parenthood Pulls a Komen on Mitt Romney

Planned Parenthood successfully targeted the Susan G. Komen Foundation and is now getting political by campaigning against Mitt Romney.

Bill Clinton Undercuts Barack Obama in Wisconsin

Former President Bill Clinton is campaigning for Democrats across the country, disregarding Obama's campaign strategies.

Barack Obama Doesn’t Get a Pass on Poland Gaffe

The president's error and half-hearted apology is a serious diplomatic mistake.

Mitt Romney's Ridiculous Unemployment Reaction

Romney's dramatic reaction to the May jobs report makes him look false and calculating.

What John Edwards Tells Us About the Legal Profession

The legal profession is experiencing a very serious breakdown of ethics.

What the GOP Should Do if Obamacare Falls

If Obamacare is struck down by the Supreme Court, the Democrats are responsible for proposing another plan.

Barack Obama and George Bush Show Congress How to Act Like Adults

Obama and Bush are capable of acting like adults. Why isn't Congress?

advertisement