Is Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker Right About the Unions?

Gov. Scott Walker's proposal would limit public union workers' collective bargaining rights

February 17, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (195)

School is out in Madison, Wis., today, where teachers and other union members are protesting Gov. Scott Walker’s proposed changes to the state’s labor law. The bill, which cleared the legislature’s budget committee late last night with only Republican support, would effectively limit union workers’ collective salary bargaining rights. Walker introduced it as an effort to close the state’s $3.6 billion budget gap. He said the move will prevent up to 6,000 layoffs for state employees. “We don’t have a lot of options here, folks,” Republican Rep. Alberta Darling said, according to Madison’s Channel 3000 News. “It’s not like we’re choosing to do this. We are broke.”

[Read the U.S. News debate: Should public unions keep collective bargaining rights?]

The state Senate is expected to pass the bill, which will then move to the Republican-controlled Assembly. Thousands of protesters have flocked to the State Capitol this week in response, arguing that limiting union bargaining rights strips members of representation. Wisconsin Education Association Council President Mary Bell last night called for all citizens of the state to join the protests in Madison Thursday and Friday. “We are here tonight in the spirit of Martin Luther King calling on our union members and all Wisconsinites to look tonight into their hearts and to listen to their conscience to decide what kind of Wisconsin we want to call our home,” she said to the crowd of protesters. “What happens to the rights of some today endangers the rights of others to come.”

U.S. News blogger Leslie Marshall also thinks Walker is being unreasonable. She writes:

The argument put forth by Walker is that he has to get his budget in line. But Walker is lying. Statistically, whether it be Wisconsin, Ohio, Nevada, or New Jersey, union workers make on the average 6 percent less than their private sector counterparts. Also statistically, if you look at the budget of Wisconsin, the biggest savings have nothing to do with state workers or collective bargaining; by Walker’s own admission, he could save $165 million just restructuring the current debt. And we know this isn’t about money or savings to the state of Wisconsin or its citizens, it’s politics.

What do you think? Is Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s proposal to limit union bargaining the right move to balance the state's budget? Take the poll and post your thoughts below.

Is Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s proposal to limit union bargaining the right move to balance the state's budget?

View Results

Previously: In which city do you feel the least safe?

Tags:
Wisconsin,
state budgets,
Republican Party,
politics

Reader Comments Read all comments (195)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Are any of us that stupid? you have actual idiots working for a union, no one can ever fire them, regardless of how incompetent and lacking of skills they truly are.

They can't read or write but they have a union job - therefore they will never be fired, does not matter how lazy they are, or how "DAH" they are- the unions are still trying to run our country!! How sad, wake up AMERICA!! Flush your toilets!!

Maybe we too can collect some doo's too!! YA THINK?

Syndi Kubasik of WI 1:07PM March 04, 2013

Most all we ever hear about is how the poor teachers this or the poor union snow plow drivers that or the poor union state workers are so trodden upon and how all these poor helpless good hard working people are being taken advantage of by the big bad REPUBLICAN Gov. Walker. I'm sick of it. Let's hear from the hundreds of thousands of home owners and property tax payers and renters who's rent is increased to pay these property taxes who are going broke and having to leave there homes because they can no longer afford to pay the taxes- or who must pay these taxes so they now can't afford the other things we all want to buy and enjoy-- let's hear from all the hundreds of thousands of good tax paying citizens who are forced under penalty of forfeiture or death, (try not paying taxes to the nth degree and see what happens), let's hear what they have to say about being forced to pay bloated union "benefits" for those who choose to retire at full pay at 50 years old. OH MY F-ing GOD. No one ever said you were required to work for the Gov't. You may quit at any time. You may not quit paying taxes

Lou Longmire of MN 5:57PM January 22, 2012

Well, it's been nearly a year since Walker took office. The ONLY districts that have laid off teachers were in districts that signed new contracts before the budget tools were enabled. Matter of fact, all but ONE district in the entire state has saved money and has a surplus now, and most have moved to lower class sizes, hire more teachers, and look at a fair way to pay teachers MORE based on performance. All for a 5-8% contribution to their previously-free health care and 5% of their pension, which they get back anyways. They can still retire at 50 and get full pension until both partners are deceased (or go back to work and double-dip, pay $0 for heathcare and pension as they are "retired", cheap loophole that prevents new teachers from getting a job! Why are teachers AGAINST jobs?). The Union hated this because they OWNED the insurance company that was raping the state on charges. THATS where a lot of the balanced budget money came from, not the $40 a month the teachers are paying now in health care costs that were free for 56 years.

Not only that, the budget is balanced, Walker even paid back the illegal theft from the Highway Fund that governor Doyle (D) raided, and also paid back the 1/3 billion he "borrowed" from Minnesota. Dont forget Doyle ran on a "No Vegas-style gaming in Indian casinos in Wisconsin" platform, then after elected, took a $75000 donation and let the Potawatomi tribe get a LIFETIME DEAL to never pay the state a CENT after a few years. Did Doyle just HATE having money paid into the state coffers unless it came from an "evil corporation"? Doyle also started the bogus 'double taxation' (combined reporting). We almost lost HARLEY from that!

Dont forget, you Union thugs (I'm union too, IBEW local 663 Milwaukee, I dont follow zombie-like madness and rabid irrationalism), Walker does everything for the taxpayer, which INCLUDES YOU. Did your property taxes go up 10% this year like mine did EVERY year under Doyle? Mine are going DOWN (in percentage, not because of depressed value). He is under LAW to BALANCE THE BUDGET...so what else was he supposed to do? Crap gold bricks in the amount of 4 billion dollars? Wisconsin would have been Greece if this was allowed any longer.

Stop lying about the collective bargaining as if the Unions would have negotiated. THEY REFUSED OVER AND OVER. You also wanted to vote in an unqualified state supreme court justice ONLY to get Walker's law annulled.

The ONLY reason you people are trying for a recall is because you CANT accept the fact you LOST an election, and you refuse to deal with the law.

Go ahead and try. You won't win. Dont come crying "UNFAIR" when we start doing the same things to YOU (well, we wont use death threats like you whack-jobs do, we arent crazy like you) like recall anyone with a (D) after their name if they get elected. We still wont cheat at the polls, though....but maybe we SHOULD...it's the only way you'll support a real voter ID law

T Sagert of WI 11:12PM November 13, 2011

advertisement

Latest Videos

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

President Obama's Code Pink Heckler Medea Benjamin Was Plain Rude

It's become acceptable for people to interrupt the president while he is delivering a formal speech on a deadly serious topic.

Obama Commerce Nominee Penny Pritzker’s Tax Problem

Obama’s Commerce Department nominee has some Romney-esque tax issues.

Oklahoma Tornado Reminds Us of the Value of Teachers

The Oklahoma tornado reminds us of all the roles teachers take on.

IRS, AP and James Rosen Scandals Strike at the First Amendment

The Obama scandals paint a picture of an administration at odds with the First Amendment.

Anthony Weiner Is Too Liberal to Be New York City Mayor

New York City doesn't need another Democratic mayor.

Organizations Masquerading as Tax-Exempt is the Real IRS Scandal

The real scandal at the IRS is electioneering groups getting tax-exempt status.

E.W. Jackson Proves the Tea Party Learned Nothing

By nominating E.W. Jackson, Virginia Republicans hope extremism will save them.

IRS, AP and Benghazi Are Not Obama Scandals

The word "scandal" doesn't appropriately describe anything going on in Washington these days.

advertisement