Michael Nutter: Citizenship Is More than Paying Taxes and Voting

Public service is a critical component of participation in the political system

October 29, 2010 RSS Feed Print

Often, the most visible public service is performed by those who have run for and been elected to political office. In good times, they sometimes get some of the credit. In bad times, they receive most of the blame. That's the lot of a public servant. So why do it? U.S. News asked four current and former public servants. Here's what Michael Nutter, mayor of Philadelphia, had to say:

We live in a time when growing fear about our uncertain future has pushed the political system, from small towns and big cities to our nation's capital, into frequent bouts of gridlock.

As a 24/7 news cycle has quickened with social media, the level of political discourse has become increasingly mean-spirited and personal. Recently, for example, a former elected official made personal, racially divisive comments about me. Is it any wonder that many people flee from the political system in disgust?

I believe in the critical importance of participating in the political system—from voting to standing for election. It's both rewarding and necessary that men and women of good will and clear thinking engage in honest, open debate.

To succeed in big-city politics requires a powerful, motivating vision of a better world, a plan to get there, a willingness to meet constituents on their terms, and a tough political skin.

My pathway to a profession in public service extends straight back to my childhood in a rowhouse on a close-knit block in West Philadelphia. When it snowed, my parents told me to keep shoveling past my house right on down to the corner. If I saw someone carrying their groceries home, I ran to help. I always gave up my seat on the bus to an elderly person, and while I experienced the excitement of learning at an elite high school as a scholarship student, I often returned to my neighborhood elementary school to tutor young kids.

From the home-grown value of volunteering in my neighborhood grew a love of my city. Philadelphians are a gritty, tough people who will help you when you're down. They built a grand city that suffered severe disinvestment in the last century. I wanted to be part of the team that built the new Philadelphia with broadening opportunities and a growing middle class.

We are on our way, despite a national recession that caused unemployment to rise to double digits here. Frederick Douglass, the great American statesman of freedom, once said, "If there is no struggle, there is no progress." In Philadelphia, we've progressed through struggle. We fought for and achieved major ethics reforms in government and a smoking ban in workplaces. In our first try, we came up short on a plan to tax sugar-sweetened beverages to fund an innovative anti-obesity program to cope with an epidemic that impacts children and adults. It's an important initiative and we won't give up on it.

A range of evidence convinces me that cities like Philadelphia will have a bright future in an era of reduced carbon emissions. We have a highly efficient transportation system and a plan to dramatically cut energy use in our buildings throughout the city.

But continuing our progress toward this safer, greener city will require the kind of political leadership that honestly addresses and strongly encourages residents and businesses to volunteer their services in a time of strained city budgets. I recently launched a strategy for promoting service. With support from the Rockefeller Foundation and the Cities of Service, of which Philadelphia is a member, we are attracting adults to programs that will help us cut our high school dropout rate in half and double the percentage of college graduates.

Citizenship is certainly about observing the law, paying taxes (what FDR once called the dues we pay for the privilege of membership in an organized society), and making choices in elections.

It's also about coming together with neighbors on your block and cleaning up, walking a shift for a town watch organization, and mentoring a child who must prepare for post-secondary training.

Politics in Philadelphia is a contact sport. But if you're equipped with a strong vision of a better future, plans to get there, and support from citizens who care, then the campaign for change is like a walk in our Fairmount Park, one of urban America's largest and most beautiful parks.

Tags:
Philadelphia,
community service,
unemployment,
Franklin Delano Roosevelt,
energy policy and climate change

Reader Comments Read all comments (1)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Like Mayor Nutter I was raised with a strong sense of community values. When I bought my first house in Philadelphia, my first act was to clean up the feral cat population by trapping, testing, inoculating, neutering, thus creating a healthier street.

I was happy and busy fixing up my new house, turning it into a library, art studio and space to dance. I had an entire house to fill with my creative activities, friends and life. My grown daughters were excited and planning to enjoy home with mom.

I was a California transplant and knew nothing of Philadelphia politics and had never heard of a brownfield. My happiness was soon thrown into the toxic cauldron of Philadelphia’s dark side.

A vacant lot wrapped around my house. The opposite border was the train. I was told they were going to build. I had no problem with that. My brother was a union foreman in construction. I expected construction to be done in an orderly lawful way with attractive green space.

Then I saw the plans for the project. The impact on my home was obvious and alarming, but soon I decided to just live with it. Then demolition crews came without permits or dust control and started knocking down brick coal bins and cement. My house started to bend and crack. It jumped. A neighbor said it was like a California earthquake.

I repeatedly called the city. No help. Leaders from the neighborhood groups, both lawyers to City Council Women failed to get License & Inspections to cite “demolition without permits.” They failed to implement regulations which are a citizen’s rights of protection. The “neighborhood” groups were too political and did not help me when I was down. One neighbor said, “ I feel sorry for her but that’s all I can do.”

I landed in ER on breathing apparatus. Doctors said to remove me from site. Philadelphia paid no attention. Doctors asked for the soil data due to my symptoms of chemical exposure. Others also smelled chemicals. A history of chemical dumping surfaced on this former industrial site. The city never responded to my displacement or medical needs.

The Water Department cited a long list of excavation failures: failure to protect on soil suspicious to be contaminated, clean stream act violations and more. However, no one in the city informed or protected the neighbors.

Years of visible fugitive dust, a deadly combination of cement and brick dust along with chemicals were ignored and denied by the city. The industrial history of the site was ignored by both Planning and Zoning. A city planner said there was nothing he could do due to politics. I wondered what kind of politics interfered with public health emergencies. Proper environmental procedure was ignored.

As a citizen, I did my duty in reporting these public health hazards. Years later my house is empty, the project still unfinished. I’m still under medical care. The city has yet to fulfill it’s duty and fix what it wrecked.

Margaret Motheral of PA 5:43PM October 30, 2010

advertisement

Debate Club

Was 2011 One of the Worst Years for the U.S. Government in American History?

Experts debate where 2011 ranks among Washington's worst years.

Latest Video

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

What the GOP Should Do if Obamacare Falls

If Obamacare is struck down by the Supreme Court, the Democrats are responsible for proposing another plan.

Barack Obama and George Bush Show Congress How to Act Like Adults

Obama and Bush are capable of acting like adults. Why isn't Congress?

Mitt Romney Should Put Up or Shut Up on Syria

The Republican candidate has proven he doesn't have the foreign policy credentials necessary to be president.

Mitt Romney's Colorado Disconnect

The presumptive GOP nominee seems unwilling or unable to talk about local issues in a swing state he desperately needs to win.

Donald Trump Makes Kim Kardashian Look Good

At least Kim Kardashian doesn't take herself seriously.

The Vietnam War Still Haunts Us

History rhymes once again, thanks so much.

'Transcripters' Make Birthers Look Smart

Now the fringe right wants the president's university grades to prove he wasn't a good student.

Obama Must Do More to Protect the Intellectual Property Industry

The Obama administration needs to protect the industry's creativity and innovation.

advertisement