Do Sarah Palin's Muslim Comments Make Her Unpresidential?

Questioning the politics of the Alaska ex-governor's comments on the "ground zero mosque."


Speaking strongly against the construction of a Muslim community center near the World Trade Center site, Sarah Palin said, “Doesn’t it stab you in the heart, as it does ours throughout the heartland?” Thomas Jefferson Street blogger John Farrell says that it does not. He argues that Palin's histrionics and her appeals to emotion, rather than logic, are reasons that she should never become president of the United States. "Sarah Palin cannot make the distinction between feeling good and thinking smart," Farrell writes. "She must never be president." He also takes issue with her "politics of grievance," which paints all Muslims as hateful extremists and guarantees that we lose the war against al Qaeda, Farrell asserts. [See 10 reasons why Palin would be a bad president.]

What do you think? Do Sarah Palin's comments on the "ground zero mosque" show she shouldn't  be president? Or is she showing the right kind of leadership on a controversial topic? Take our poll and post your thoughts below.

This poll is now closed, but the debate continues in the comments section.

Previously: Should Defense Secretary Robert Gates Retire in 2011?