Was Blocking the Arizona Immigration Law the Right Decision?

July 29, 2010 RSS Feed Print

Arizona's controversial anti-illegal immigration law, which went into effect on Thursday, hit a snag when a federal judge stripped the provision that would have allowed police to question a suspect's immigration status. Gov. Jan Brewer said she plans to appeal U.S. District Court Judge Susan Bolton's decision and is willing to take it to the U.S. Supreme Court. The judge's decision has altered the dynamics of the opposition to the law, as protesters Thursday took to the streets with mixed expressions of relief and outrage.

What do you think? Was the judge right to block the law's provisions? Take our poll and post your thoughts below.

Block the Arizona Law?

View Results

Previously: Are Democrats Becoming Too Liberal?

Tags:
Arizona,
Jan Brewer

Reader Comments Read all comments (4)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

why not hold the mexican gov. responsible. They pocket the money and let there people fend for themselves. They want there people to come here for free health care, education, etc. Im also for, if your not legal your babys are not legal. I work in a hospital and they come in to give birth. They don't speak english, have not seen a Dr. A NEW CITIZEN. We are the only country that does that. It was put in the constitution so the chirldren of the freed slaves could vote. Not for every baby born here.

paula of AZ 2:15PM August 04, 2010

This is just an attempt for the ACLU and mexcio to run our country.

Paul of AZ 2:26PM August 02, 2010

Congress Passed an Arizona-Like Immigration Law in 1996

http://politics.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/battle/2010/07/30/Congress-Passed-an-Arizona-Like-Immigration-Law-in-1996

Judge Bolton reminds me of the Beatles song" The Fool on the Hill". Only she would be the "Fool on the Bench".

Obviously mr holder still hasnt read any of those pesky laws. Will someone please buy him a law book?

We have attorney generals that dont read laws they testify about in Congress.

We have a judge in Az that cant afford a law clerk to research prior law and keep herself from looking like a "FOOL".

And soon we will have a Supreme Court justice that has never been a judge,ever?!? Judging the most important cases in the land.

Could this administration be a bigger trainwreck than it is? Could it be any worse if it tried to be? Hmm,maybe thats what they are doing.

terry neve of AZ 5:56AM August 01, 2010

advertisement

Debate Club

Was 2011 One of the Worst Years for the U.S. Government in American History?

Experts debate where 2011 ranks among Washington's worst years.

Latest Video

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

With Jeremy Lin, Harvard Finally Makes the Big Time

As Jeremy Lin's success proves, a rigorous education and professional level athletics are not mutually exclusive.

Happy Birthday to George Washington and Abraham Lincoln

February marks the birthdays of two great, but very different, presidents.

Rick Santorum Didn't Restart the Culture War--It Never Stopped

When conservatives mention economics, they're really talking about culture.

Vatican Endorses Pro-Life Movie Doonby

Hollywood starts to explore the other side of the abortion controversy.

Hey Liberals, Mitt Romney Can Still Beat Barack Obama

The Obama campaign should feel no more assured of victory than the Romney campaign

Anthony Shadid, Foiled Terrorist Plot Remind Us Heroes Do Exist

Anthony Shadid took huge risks to tell the stories of what was happening in the Middle East.

It’s Washington’s Birthday—Not Presidents' Day

It's time for Obama and Congress to give Presidents’ Day back to George Washington.

Cuba Is Reforming, But Not Nearly Enough

Cuban officials exaggerate the extent of reforms being enacted in the Castro brothers' Cuba.

advertisement