Should Worker Electronic-Privacy Rights Be Upheld?

February 1, 2010 RSS Feed Print

It’s generally agreed that there are legitimate reasons for bosses to check up on employees’ electronic communication, such as protecting intellectual property or preventing harassment. But must a firm continue to spell out its policy for it to be valid?
Edited by Steve St. Angelo

Yes

By Lewis Maltby
President of the National Workrights Institute in Princeton, N.J., which fights for employee rights

Is it unreasonable to expect your boss to keep his word? The recent privacy case of Quon v. Arch Wireless raises the simple but important question of whether public employers must be honest with employees about their monitoring practices. Look at the case as the equivalent of the children’s game of making up something untrue and then saying, “It doesn’t count. I had my fingers crossed.” Before long, reasonable individuals...

READ MORE...

No

By Mitch Danzig
San Diego-based attorney with the law firm Mintz Levin LLC specializing in labor issues

 

Employers provide workers with devices and give them access to E-mail, the Internet, and instant messaging to make them more efficient as employees. Technology-related budgets are constantly increasing to keep up with improvements. It defies logic to say that employees should be able to send personal messages on company time and property without being subject to employer review. This is like...

READ MORE...

What do you think?down arrow

Should Worker Electronic-Privacy Rights Be Upheld?

View Results
Tags:
privacy,
technology

Reader Comments Read all comments (3)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

If an employer pays a person to do business, they have every right to deny workers free time on the employer's property.

Terry Devon of CA 4:57PM February 04, 2010

I work in an office with a manager who is a real b***ch about personal cell phones and their ringing sounds (and I am really understating her behavior!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) I see people more and more during my commute (I ride a bus to and from work daily), who are using their personal Blackberry, Verizon Droid, iPhones and now, the netbooks. In my office, personal e-mail is not even accessible. Working all day, I have zero time to check my own messages from people. I am seriously considering buying a netbook just so I can read my Hotmail messages during the commute. Expensive, but worth it. I hate missing out on my life because of the commuting and work time that eats up my day. Over 1/2 of the 24 hours that we are given each day are spent on working, getting to work and getting home from work. Once home, I want to be with my family. I am on a computer all day in the office, I really don't want to take away time from my kids & husband to be on the computer at home. Would it really kill my office to let us access our personal e-mail at lunch? Or during breaks?! I don't smoke, so I could easily surf the web during my breaks instead. Quality of life is important.

Indentured Servitude of OH 12:06PM February 04, 2010

At our 30,000+ employee fortune 500 company, most communications / devices are monitored. Everyone assumes that everything is monitored, including those "anonymous employee surveys" which always come up as everyone is happy, etc. I do see employees bring netbooks and their own smartphones to have non-monitored communications.Everyone uses https (encryption) when possible. There is a level of trust, yet a lot of mistrust of mangement becuase of the monitoring.

Susan of OH 1:27AM February 04, 2010

advertisement

Debate Club

Was 2011 One of the Worst Years for the U.S. Government in American History?

Experts debate where 2011 ranks among Washington's worst years.

Latest Video

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

May Unemployment Rate Dooms Barack Obama

With unemployment now at 8.2 percent, Mitt Romney is poised to gain ground with voters.

Planned Parenthood Pulls a Komen on Mitt Romney

Planned Parenthood successfully targeted the Susan G. Komen Foundation and is now getting political by campaigning against Mitt Romney.

Bill Clinton Undercuts Barack Obama in Wisconsin

Former President Bill Clinton is campaigning for Democrats across the country, disregarding Obama's campaign strategies.

Barack Obama Doesn’t Get a Pass on Poland Gaffe

The president's error and half-hearted apology is a serious diplomatic mistake.

Mitt Romney's Ridiculous Unemployment Reaction

Romney's dramatic reaction to the May jobs report makes him look false and calculating.

What John Edwards Tells Us About the Legal Profession

The legal profession is experiencing a very serious breakdown of ethics.

What the GOP Should Do if Obamacare Falls

If Obamacare is struck down by the Supreme Court, the Democrats are responsible for proposing another plan.

Barack Obama and George Bush Show Congress How to Act Like Adults

Obama and Bush are capable of acting like adults. Why isn't Congress?

advertisement