Gay Marriage Legalized in Iowa: Both Sides of the Debate

Bloggers on gay marriage in Iowa, Obama, and Levi Johnston's flub on safe sex with Bristol Palin

April 3, 2009 RSS Feed Print

Our daily look at stories and topics that are lighting up the Internets:

The Next Frontier

The debate over the constitutionality of gay marriage hit a turning point today with the Iowa Supreme Court ruling gay marriage bans unconstitutional. Here are bloggers' reactions to the ruling breakdown:

Unhappy: Conservative Kathryn Jean Lopez posts this analysis of the court's decision here, attempting to show the major flaws in the ruling. "The lawless judicial attack on traditional marriage and on representative government continues," writes conservative Ed Whelan. "What gobbledygook." Conservative Erick Erickson thinks there's only one way to stop rulings like this from happening again: "Until we make a regular habit in this nation of impeaching activist judges who put their personal policy preferences ahead of the constitutions of the several states and nation, we will just keep bowing lower and lower to our black robed masters." And this Iowa State Rep. doesn't like the ruling at all.

Ecstatic: "Damn straight," is liberal BarbinMD's reaction (pun so clearly intended). Andrew Sullivan is very, very happy with this development, and posts this roundup of varying views on the decision. In one of many posts on the subject, Sullivan writes: "Imagine: actually thinking about the welfare of gay citizens as equal members of society. What a concept." Liberal Emma Ruby-Sachs posts her analysis of the ruling here. Don't get her wrong—she's happy about the Iowa Court's decision, she thinks they've only taken the first of many steps. "Good for the court," writes Robert Schlesinger in one post on the subject. In another, he argues that conservative politicians with big hopes are no doubt salivating over the ruling: "Anyone want to place bets on which of the 2012 contenders first gets this ruling into a fundraising appeal?"

Undoing Bush, et al.

This is, at least, what many see as the goal of Obama's post G-20 summit trip in Europe. Johanna Neuman gives her take on Obama's town hall meeting in Strasbourg, Germany (White House press release available there too). Liberal Beth Arnold thinks Obama's performance was a "resounding success," lifting "people up instead of whipping them down." The Daily Beast gives this media roundup of Obama's performance. Conservative Jean Granville turns to French President Nicolas Sarkozy, arguing that Sarko is a stereotypically unpredictable French politician. A number of conservatives were very, very unhappy with the bow Obama gave to the Saudi king—conservative Ed Morrissey devotes a long post to the controversy here. Conservative Rick Brookhiser remembers a "shameful" Bush bow, too. And here's a post on the trivial rivalry between French first lady Carla Bruni and Michelle Obama.

...Meanwhile ...

Levi Johnston awkwardly admits to not (always) having safe sex with Bristol Palin... Unemployment in the U.S. is now worse than in France... Dog owners really do look like their pets... And Rutgers breaks the Guinness World Record for the largest gathering of people dressed as Waldo.

Reader Comments Read all comments (18)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

After listening to all the religious garbage of the right and played out emotional hype of the left I have only one question for homosexuals seeking a piece of paper to tell them their married. Why do you want to even get tangled up in this mess anyway?

If you're looking for insurance, retirement benefits, etc. then why haven't we as a nation already granted these citizens these things?

If your looking for equality (and this comes with the utmost respect) look elsewhere. This is America. We are free to be who we are and who we think we are. We are free to be as bigoted and biased as we please. We are free to be ignorant and force-fed whatever comes from the pulpit 57 rows deep.

Yes we are a nation of many freedoms, but we will always be enslaved to our own culture. Unfourtunatly for the GLBT community that means a quasi-christan culture complete with its own definition of marriage.

Don't get the wrong idea. Many of us want to abolish the fence between us but to do so would require the deconstuction of our current cultural climate. (I personally think a revolution and a little fighting in the streets is exactly what this nation needs right now but that would seem somewhat extreme to most)

If however, what you want is a confirmation from you community that you and your spouse are truly 'one of the Jones' then the answer is simply to wait.

Ignorance, like disease, is most easily cured with time.

steve of OH 11:07AM April 23, 2009

I am a lesbian, and i am engaged. Having something more then a commitment ceremony would be amazing. I believe that i deserve to have the same rights as heterosexual couple. Marriage opens doors for insurance purposes, plus makes things like adoption easier. I am very exited that Iowa is taking a step to the future, and hope that Illinois (my home state) will soon follow. Many other countries have lagalized gay marriage, and hopefully the United Stated will become more progressive as well.

Cassandra of IL 3:41AM April 08, 2009

I have a feeling most Iowans aren't going to be bothered by relationship decisions that don't affect them (we tend to have a live-and-let-live attitude) nor will they they respond to alarmist propaganda (we have a pretty high leve of education, too). As for "activist judges," I think Iowans understand and respect the role of the courts enough that they won't really fall for the theory that Justice Cady, appointed by Terry Branstad, is somehow part of a leftist attempt to legislate from the bench. Finally, Iowans are fairly independent and proud (if you couldn't tell) and won't respond well to folks from California, Florida, or New York trying to change their minds.

Carl of IA 12:56AM April 06, 2009

advertisement

Debate Club

Was 2011 One of the Worst Years for the U.S. Government in American History?

Experts debate where 2011 ranks among Washington's worst years.

Latest Video

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

Barack Obama and George Bush Show Congress How to Act Like Adults

Obama and Bush are capable of acting like adults. Why isn't Congress?

Mitt Romney Should Put Up or Shut Up on Syria

The Republican candidate has proven he doesn't have the foreign policy credentials necessary to be president.

Mitt Romney's Colorado Disconnect

The presumptive GOP nominee seems unwilling or unable to talk about local issues in a swing state he desperately needs to win.

Donald Trump Makes Kim Kardashian Look Good

At least Kim Kardashian doesn't take herself seriously.

The Vietnam War Still Haunts Us

History rhymes once again, thanks so much.

'Transcripters' Make Birthers Look Smart

Now the fringe right wants the president's university grades to prove he wasn't a good student.

Obama Must Do More to Protect the Intellectual Property Industry

The Obama administration needs to protect the industry's creativity and innovation.

Is Congress Getting Dumber?

That Congress is speaking at a lower grade level than it was seven years ago may be due to the unfortunate tendency to equate education with elitism.

advertisement