Was the Pentagon Right to Lift Military Coffin Photo Ban?

March 9, 2009 RSS Feed Print

The Pentagon has lifted a ban on photos of service members' coffins as they are repatriated. Media will be allowed if families OK it. Ban critics argued that photos help the nation honor its fallen, but proponents said grieving families don't need more tough decisions. Was it the right call?

Was the Pentagon right to lift military coffin photo ban?

Pro

Ron Milam
Vietnam vet, interim director of Texas Tech's Center for War and Diplomacy in the Post-Vietnam War Era.

"On behalf of a grateful nation" is a phrase that we who have worn the uniform of our country's military know may eventually be heard by our families and friends as they gather at our final resting place. The American flag draped over our coffin—stars above our left shoulder—will be folded with great dignity by an honor guard and handed to our loved ones. This burial ceremony is repeated hundreds of times a day as we bury our veterans of America's wars.... Read more >>

Con

Bill Martel
Associate professor of international security studies at the Fletcher School at Tufts University.

The ban on photographing soldiers' coffins as they return to Dover Air Force Base in Delaware was not simply about images but also about shielding grief-stricken military families from a media maelstrom. It was not an issue of freedom of the press but one of respect and one of fairness.... Read more >>

Corrected on 03/09/09: An earlier version of this article incorrectly identified Bill Martel.

Tags:
military,
Department of Defense,
national security terrorism and the military,
Pentagon

Reader Comments Read all comments (5)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I think that the dignified transfer should be made public by the family, only if they agree. My family did it because we wanted the country to see our loss. It wasn't about the war per say, it was about a 23 year old that died trying to stand up for people that is weaker than he was. My biggest problem isn't the public knowing, it is the demonstrators knowing. It's okay for the country to share in our grief, but it's not something to protest. Remember that the military is given an order, and they are doing thier jobs. Most of them don't want to leave thier families and go to war, but they do it as a sense of duty so that it doesn't come here to get us!

Grieving Sister of a Fallen Hero of FL 5:49PM November 16, 2010

I served in the US Navy for a number of years, and lost 47 shipmates in turret explosion aboard the USS Iowa in April 1989. I know all too well the cost of serving in the military, whether in wartime or peacetime. These American Heroes deserve the utmost respect and honor. If the famalies wish to share such a personal moment with the rest of the country, we should feel honored to do so with them.

Chuck Lands of VA 6:21PM April 06, 2009

should see the coffins if it is alright with families. the war in iraq was a lie but the fact that the brave men and woman have given thier lives to protect the usa. they should be honored by seeing them in thier finaly trip home, they are not just a coffins as some say they are ours, our heros, are children, fathers, brothers, sisters,wives, mothers, husbands, friends, etc. they are our heros they belong to all of us, we sheed tears for all that have been lost, injured, and have served. they belong to all of us cause they are fighting for all of us americans

karen of AZ 10:48PM April 05, 2009

advertisement

Debate Club

Was 2011 One of the Worst Years for the U.S. Government in American History?

Experts debate where 2011 ranks among Washington's worst years.

Latest Video

Thomas Jefferson Street Blog

It’s Washington’s Birthday—Not Presidents' Day

It's time for Obama and Congress to give Presidents’ Day back to George Washington.

Cuba Is Reforming, But Not Nearly Enough

Cuban officials exaggerate the extent of reforms being enacted in the Castro brothers' Cuba.

Rick Santorum Will Spell Doom for Republicans in November

If it nominates Rick Santorum over MItt Romney, the GOP will lose the White House and elections at all other levels.

Obama's Energy Policy Isn't 'Crony Capitalism'

A majority of the energy companies who have received funds under Obama are thriving

Michigan Is a Must-Win ... For Rick Santorum

Winning in Michigan is at least as important to Santorum's campaign as it is to Romney's.

Why the Catholic Contraception Controversy Is So American

Politically speaking, the contraception controversy is a quirk of the way we pay for healthcare.

The Upside of the Racist Hoekstra Ad

In this era of nasty political rhetoric and advertising, the public will draw the line at something brazenly racist.

Barack Obama's Budget Is Even Worse Than It Looks

If Obama's budget for FY 2013 is adopted as written, the federal budget would never balance again.

advertisement