In India, Some Call for Attacking Pakistan Over Mumbai Terrorist Assault

December 12, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (20)

MUMBAI, INDIA—In the wake of last month's deadly terrorist attacks, locals took to the streets, with some bellowing jingoistic slogans and others vowing never again to pay taxes to an inept government that took a whopping 60 hours to reign in a "handful of 21-year-olds." A few saber rattlers brazenly clamored for "tough action" against Pakistan.

In a public square abutting the bullet-pocked Taj Mahal Palaces and Tower hotel, a heaving crowd of protestors wielding placards gathered to mark the attack on India's financial capital that took nearly 200 lives. One of the many rabble-rousing placards that stood out read: "Let's Declare War."

India isn't unfamiliar with terrorist attacks—it is the most-attacked nation on Earth, after war-torn Iraq, according to data compiled by the National Counterterrorism Center. However, this terrorist strike has come to be a defining moment for India, just as the United States had one seven years ago.

Mumbai, targeted several times before, was convulsed by the audacity, style, and scale of this attack and by the high-profile targets.

Nearly a quarter of India's burgeoning urban middle class believes that India should engage in a war with Pakistan, on whose soil India believes this terror attack originated, according to a recent opinion poll by Outlook, an Indian weekly.

Both countries came perilously close to war seven years ago, when the Indian parliament was attacked by a group of militants believed to have emanated from Pakistan. Both sides amassed thousands of troops along the border before tensions between the nuclear-armed rivals were de-escalated with the help of international mediation. Pakistan and India have fought three wars in the past, two of them over Kashmir, a divided territory that both countries claim in its entirety.

Now, despite mounting public pressure, neither country is eager for a confrontation. Pakistan's economy is deep in the red, and India's economic juggernaut is losing steam. With America firmly by its side, India is maneuvering to create international pressure on Pakistan to clamp down on militants. And Pakistan is complying, or so it claims.

Pakistan refused to extradite anyone from a list of what India calls 20 hard-core terrorists but has promised to crack down on Lashkar-e-Taiba, a militant group founded in the 1980s to wrest control of Kashmir from India. Lashkar-e-Taiba is suspected of orchestrating the recent rampage across Mumbai.

Pakistan's defense minister, Chaudhury Ahmed Mukhtar, declared this week that Pakistani forces had raided the group's properties in Pakistani-occupied Kashmir and arrested Zaki ur Rehman Lakhvi, a senior LeT commander who, Indian investigators say, "planned out the whole assault" and trained the 10 gunmen who carried out the Mumbai attack.

On India's insistence, the United Nations Security Council this week banned Jamaat-ud-Dawa, which was registered as a charitable group in Pakistan but is believed to be a front organization of LeT. After the ban was imposed, Pakistan began raiding JuD properties and apprehending thousands of men.

Hafiz Mohammed Saeed, the henna-bearded founder of LeT and current head of JuD, was placed under house arrest. He strongly refutes allegations against JuD and LeT. "I can say with authority that the Lashkar does not believe in killing civilians," he said in an interview before he was arrested. "The Indian leadership is using Pakistan as a punching bag to cover up its failures at home."

However, Ajmal Amir Kasab, the sole terrorist nabbed alive during the Mumbai attacks, has reportedly told Indian investigators that along with maritime training and lessons in explosives and weapons, all 10 terrorists received "motivational sermons" from Saeed.

Despite the large-scale crackdown, terrorism analysts are skeptical about Pakistan's sincerity about neutralizing these groups. "Based on past experiences," says Sajjan Gohel, the director of International Security at the London-based Asia Pacific Foundation, "there's fear that Islamabad will once again do too little, too late, and the clampdown on militant groups will be an ineffective, cosmetic exercise."

Tags:
Mumbai,
national security terrorism and the military,
India,
Pakistan,
terrorism

Reader Comments Read all comments (20)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

India is under Muslim presedent. Sonia Khan changes his name to sonia gandhi. They make all indian fool. indian people are looking for money. In india there are more than one billion god. People are fight between hindu to hindu for their own stupid god. THey do not have team play method. if pak put nucelar bomb in india, indian goverement does not do anything. IF pak totaly destroy india, still india always forgive their enomy... God Belss India.

karan of IL 6:45PM March 05, 2009

World is aware of that pakistan is the basic centre for the terrorism which is denied by it.and which is rubbish. I feel indians are not taking any action against them and thats the reason terror is widely spread in india compared to any other country. Its not that we dont have power to vanish pakistan,but we indians always have the policy of forgiveness. INDIA HAS ENOUGH POWER,MILLITANT,AND FORCE THAT COULD VANISH PAKISTAN ONLY IN FEW 7MINUTES.I always thougt that its only due to some terrorist camp that we indians suffered alot, but it is the pak govw that helps terror. and the reason pakistan should be severly punished.

indian of IN 6:39AM March 05, 2009

You do make some valid points Kevin. The motive of the attack has its roots somewhere deep down. As of now, it could be anything, from the LTTE sympathisers in LeT to pure blatant terrorist attack of Taliban to some dark controversial implications as you state.

Not even a single terrorist neutralised despite being outnumbered, all escaping despite being so open and facing elite commandos providing 'head-of-state' level security, sketches of them despite wearing masks, the tampering (deliberate?) of crucial evidence of guns and RPGs being left behind by handling them without gloves which implies no fingerprints will be obtained, the knowledge of the route to be taken by the convoy, the revelations about rations and other things carried by the terrorists implying that they wanted to take the cricketers as hostages along with the arguments you have put forth does make the whole thing look very suspicious.

Although they did fire the RPG which missed the bus, not sure by what distance, its really a point to ponder that they managed to kill so many commandos in the front convoy but couldn't manage to take out the driver of the bus which had a front of all but glass and no metal body! Instead they managed to flat out all the tyres of the bus in an attempt to stop the bus but not hit the driver. Strange indeed! And the fact that the terrorist would throw a grenade of Indian make without pulling its string as shown on TV is really too far-fetched to be practical. You would expect that atlest the string would be pulled for the nade to detonate. Needless to mention why would any terrorist leave only one rifle (not a side weapon) behind at the scene and take all others with them which seems far too convenient to be again of the kind that Indian army uses.

Also, comments like terrorists would never attack cricketers don't augur well for the sport as the terrorists would only take it as a challenge as if they are being taken for granted and would more than want to prove they are capable of anything and are the real boss. If they had really cared for the public sentiment going against them, they wouldn't have killed so many citizens and stopped womens eductaion, would they?

But even though the whole thing does raise some doubts, it sure is bad news for cricket at home as far as Pakistan is concerned and my heart goes out for them. Terming the whole country as terrorist organisation would be somewhat wrong as a few wrong people are damaging the image of the whole country. But the government, the army and the intelligence does need to come clean and the sane minded people in Pakistan do need to start a revoultion demanding an end to this sort of madness.

Heres hoping that the good folks in Pakistan do realise what is at fault, realise that the real enemy is within and not outside its borders and defeat it to become a prosperous country that it can very well be.

Dr. Samir More of IN 7:58AM March 04, 2009

Photo Galleries

History of U.S. Bombings, Failed Attempts

A look at some of the worst bombings in the U.S. and infamous failed attempts.

advertisement

Latest Videos