Obama's Secret Meeting With Historians

The president held a dinner at the White House for leading presidential scholars

July 10, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (18)

President Obama has found another way to break out of the White House "bubble"—holding private discussions with eminent historians who have studied the successes and failures of his predecessors. His goal is to better understand what has worked and what has failed in the past as he makes policy today.

Obama held a dinner at the White House residence with nine such scholars on June 30, and it turned out to be what one participant described as a "history book club, with the president as the inquisitor." Among those attending were Michael Beschloss, H. W. Brands, Douglas Brinkley, Robert Dallek, and Doris Kearns Goodwin. Obama asked the guests to discuss the presidencies that they were most familiar with and to give him insights into what remains relevant to the problems of today.

At one point, the discussion turned to whether Obama was trying to do too much too fast and whether he might overload the political circuits of Congress. He is pushing for legislation to overhaul the healthcare system, the financial industry, and energy policy, and at the same time, he is injecting the federal government into broad areas of the economy in order to end the recession and strengthen the economy's fundamentals. At least one historian said it's wise to push for such a bold agenda because the country is eager for change.

There was a warning note. Several of the scholars pointed out that previous presidents have also tried to make fundamental change in the healthcare system and failed. But Obama seemed undeterred from his goal of getting a massive healthcare bill enacted this year.

Participants were impressed with Obama's intellectual curiosity and his willingness to listen. And he told aides afterward that he wants to hold more such dinners to broaden his perspective.

Other presidents have held discussions with outside experts, but such outreach seems particularly important to Obama. One of his biggest concerns is losing touch with the country because of the isolation imposed by the White House "bubble," and he is doing all he can to stay connected. Among his other techniques are holding town-hall meetings with citizens, reading 10 letters from Americans each day, and having as normal a family life as possible by spending lots of time with his wife, Michelle, and two daughters, Malia and Sasha.

Tags:
Barack Obama

Reader Comments Read all comments (18)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

"If he was only going to do what he wanted to do then there would be no need for him to have meetings like this."

Three words: Public Affairs Stunt

In short, he did it to try to gain support from the public as his numbers plunge. Then again virtually any politician in a similar situation would pull some sort of PAS in order to revive their popularity.

As for the assumption that I am a 'hater', all one needs to do is look at the presidents who are listed as 'strong' by the historians in question. With the exception of Lincoln, the first Republican, all are left wing and highly ambitious, thus making it obvious that they are only re-enforcing his ideas. I honestly only believe that Lincoln is on that list because Obama repeatedly compared himself with him during his campaigns as well as in some speeches.

If one looks at Lincoln's policies, they had nothing in common with the rest of the presidents listed. During the Civil War, Lincoln had 18,000 suspected confederate sympathizers detained without trial, suspended habeas corpus and spend money before Congress authorized him to. He furthermore had former Ohio Senator Vallandigham deported to the Confederacy after he repeatedly gave speeches denouncing the Union and defending the Confederacy, something akin to if Bush had deported Pelosi to Syria after her stunt in Damascus. He also based his presidency on reviving the moral and traditional values of the founding fathers, something which is virtually as far from the truth as you can get with regard to Obama.

Stephen of WI 2:16PM July 17, 2009

@ken pon

He is doing that in order to stay in touch with the opinions of real people and like he said, avoid the white house bubble that Bush happily lived in for 8 years.

@H8ters

To those ppl that claim that he only got left wing historians and was only told what he wanted to hear....oh please... Give me a break. If he was only going to do what he wanted to do then there would be no need for him to have meetings like this. President Obama is an educated individual an knowns about the importance of counciling with individuals that are experts in their respective fields. Or would you rather have the leader of our country take advice from Joe-the-Plumber?

Kubush of CA 9:07PM July 16, 2009

Wow! Ten whole 'hand-picked' letters a day. Now that's doing something for the country.

ken pon of FL 5:17AM July 16, 2009

Photo Galleries

Storms, Wildfires Tear Across U.S.

Heavy rain, high winds and fire continue to plague regions throughout the country.

advertisement

Latest Videos