Barack Obama and John McCain on Abortion and Gay Marriage

October 23, 2008 RSS Feed Print

For much of the summer, the culture wars seemed dormant, if not completely over. Neither candidate was talking much about divisive issues like abortion or same-sex marriage. Barack Obama was playing down his support for abortion rights and searching for common ground with conservative voters. John McCain, an opponent of abortion rights, didn't appear comfortable bringing up the old "wedge" issues to rally the Republican base.

Turning point. The truce didn't last. In mid-August, at the Saddleback Forum, the Rev. Rick Warren pressed both candidates on abortion and marriage. McCain, appearing at ease with the subject, promised to have a "pro-life presidency" that would "have pro-life policies." Obama demurred when asked when life begins, saying the matter was "above my pay grade." Evangelical voters were suddenly energized behind McCain. A week later, McCain attacked Obama for his response in a blistering radio address, accusing him of being extreme on abortion. When McCain chose Sarah Palin, an evangelical Christian who has said abortion should be illegal even in cases of rape and incest, as his running mate, it was clear: The culture wars were back.

Where McCain stands. A strong opponent of abortion rights, McCain has said Roe v. Wade "should be overturned." McCain believes abortion should be legal in cases of rape and incest and to protect the life, but not the health, of the mother. He supports state-level initiatives to ban gay marriage this fall in California and Arizona.

Where Obama stands. Obama is a supporter of a woman's right to choose to have an abortion. On marriage, Obama has said same-sex couples should be able to enter into civil unions with all the legal benefits of marriage, but he believes "marriage" should refer to the union of a man and a woman.

Bottom line. They both oppose same-sex marriage, butMcCain and Obama could not be further apart when it comes to abortion. McCain promises to appoint justices to the Supreme Court who will try to overturn Roe v. Wade. Obama has said he will select judges who support a woman's right to choose.

Tags:
abortion,
presidential election 2008,
marriage,
Barack Obama,
John McCain,
gay rights

Reader Comments Read all comments (40)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Let me begin by saying I am a single, straight female. This subject is the source of much controversy and debate. I personally think that a homosexual person can be just as loving and concerned as a parent than any straight person or couple.

I am a college freshman doing a research paper, and the information I have found on this subject has been for the most part a function of sorting through the data and trying to guess who skewed the numbers more to make their side look like the "correct" version of the truth. While I am not as yet ready to say that I have found a large amount of facts for this paper, I am able to surmise from the information I have unearthed so far, that the subject is not likely to become a clear-cut matter any time soon.

I have the fortune to know someone who was raised in a family situation where a lesbian couple adopted him, and have been supportive and loving parents for over 16 years of his life. His attitude is that of a straight male, though a bit nerdy, and somewhat shy. Though a straight male, he has an appreciation of the homosexual lifestyle, and the prejudice that can be put toward those choosing that kind of attraction.

This person could have ended up in any number of situations where the parents he was adopted to could have harmed him mentally, or physically. He was very fortunate to end up with someone who loved him unconditionally, and gave him everything he needed to become a fully functioning, educated adult in society today.

Being in a certain geographical region does not change the way you feel about something. For some situations, there is a knowledge of the danger in an area, and then there is the decision to either change who and what you are to suit your environment, or to change your environment to suit your wants and needs. We as a nation (US) changed many things over the last 100 years to suit the ever changing face of social awareness. Slavery, the Feminist Movement, Equality, and a variety of other issues have been debated and changed the face of what we accept as everyday facts.

Equality in particular is something I would like to point out as an indicator for the current sexuality issue. Just 50 years ago, we judged people on the color of their skin. Anyone without pale skin was harshly suppressed and punished for simply being who they were. Today, we criticize, ridicule, and attempt to suppress those who choose a form of love that is not socially upheld as being "right". However, in our not so distant past, we chose to acknowledge that being of a different skin tone was not something to belittle someone else for. Perhaps, in the near future, we can find a way as a people to realize that the personal choice of sexual orientation is not a mental disease, but rather, simply a choice, that should be respected, just like the choice we once made, that has shown us that those with different skin tones can be just as good or better than any of us.

Debra of TX 1:33PM March 17, 2010

Okay. I am also a high school student doing a paper on the subject and i completely disagree with the EWWWWHHHH post. Just because you live down south and you might have been raised to see that homosexuality is wrong doesn't in any means mean that you can criticize people because of their homosexuality. Yeah i think i same-sex couple should be allowed to adopt. Why not give a child the right to have a loving caring family instead of leaving them in an orphanage their whole life. If i was in that situation gay adoption would be an option because i know i wouldn't want to be stuck in an orphanage. So the person whose post is above me maybe you should take into consideration that not everyone is like you and just because you may think that homosexuality is "Wrong" and "Sick" doesn't mean you should put someone down because of it. So think about what you say before you say it.

Marissa of OH 11:04AM February 19, 2010

I dont see why people care. If gay people want a kid let them have one. Its better for two gay people to love a kid then a man and a woman to treat the child wrong

AHHHHHHHHHH of CA 2:06PM May 27, 2009

Photo Galleries

Before and After the Joplin Tornado

A look at Joplin one year after the deadly tornado.

advertisement

Latest Video