GOP’s Dick Lugar Knocks Tea Party

January 26, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (19)

Dumping on the Tea Party isn’t just a Democratic hobby, though some take it to an art form, as when former Democratic Party boss Howard Dean recently called the movement “the last gasp of the generation that has trouble with diversity.” Republicans do it too, especially those facing a Tea Party challenge. Long-serving Indiana Republican Sen. Dick Lugar, whose reelection bid is under Tea Party attack, offers this review of the movement: “I think there are a great number of Americans, not just in Indiana, who are genuinely angry about how things have turned out for them. Sometimes they are unemployed or they have family members who have been unemployed or they are in situations in which they feel a heavy governmental restriction of their activities. In essence, they are unhappy about life in America and they want to express themselves.” Lugar says most just want to be heard, but really can’t focus on what’s bugging them. “We want this or that stopped or there is spending, big government—these are all, we would say, sort of large cliché titles, but they are not able to articulate all the specifics,” he says.
 

Tags:
Tea Party,
Richard Lugar,
Republican Party

Reader Comments Read all comments (19)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Richard Lugar is a careful, thoughtful person. No wonder the Tea Party Tantrum Throwers have him in their 'crosshairs' - to use a Palin term. Few politicians are willing to process issues with a 'nobody' - an average citizen. I always found Mr. Lugar to be not only courteous, but analytic and thoughtful in his responses to my letters when I lived in Indiana. We seldom agreed, in total. But we engaged in dialogue and I learned, and hoped he learned from our efforts. I find the Republican Party to be a dangerous entity; yet I would work to assure the success of Mr. Lugar's campaign. The Tea Party does the country a disservice by attacking him. We should not let that stand.

Kathleen Walsh RN Chicago of IL 2:30PM September 07, 2011

Social Security is not an entitlement program. It is a forced, collective retirement plan . . . and it is fully funded for the next 25 or so years. It could be made whole in perpetuity by simply adjusting the SS Wage Base. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Wage_Base

A person making $106,000 per year has the same amount of SS "Tax" withheld from her paycheck as someone who makes $1,000,000 per year. If we doubled the SS Wage Base to $212,000 . . . I'm pretty sure the million dollar taxpayers affected would be able to bear the pain of the extra five Benjamins per month, and we could assuage corporate fears by maintaining the current wage base for their "contributions" to the plan. Bingo - Bango, Social Security is back in the black for another 50 years or so.

As far as government run healthcare...oops...I mean Medicare...come on...have you no sense of decency. Let the elderly have access to doctors and medicine, fer cryin out loud. Medicare works, unlike the "death panels" at Big Insurance, who thought Nancy Reagan was training them when she said "Just say NO!"

Defense should be a slam dunk. Get out of Afghanistan, Iraq, close the torture chambers of Guantanamo and 1/3 of the redundant bases around the world, then repower the rest with green energy mods and quit invading countries unless they actually attack us first. Bingo! Budget balanced. Now lets go fix out roads, water and gas deliver infrastructure and develop efficient high speed rail so that we might continue to be a force for good and a playa on the world's stage.

Sarge of CA 7:02PM January 27, 2011

Kevin,

I agree Medicare is a big problem, and not sustainable. Whether you want to reform medicare or replace it, there is one fundamental issue that needs to be addressed. I don't believe we can reform medicare or private insurance or offer free market solutions enough to lower costs to a degree to provide the same level of care that we do currently. The hard fact is that 50% of health care dollars are spent on people who are in their last year of their life.

Health care is currently rationed by private insurance companies and the Federal and state governments through medicare and medicaid. Consequently the elderly and wealthy are over insured and recieve more and better health care than the young and poor. I would love to see the replacement plan that would address this situation.

Also, will they be replacng the VA? This is a 100% government run health care plan.

FYI, My wife has been denied access to health insurance because of pre-existing condition. So I would like to see how a replacement program would deal with this issue, as it has consequences for my wife and two boys.

Social Security. I don't agree this is a Ponzi Scheme and agree with Rick from Washington that with relatively minor adjustments we can insure the solvency of this program for another 20 to 30 years. But if the Tea Party wishes to replace this, then I have another question. According to my most recent letter from the SSA, I have paid around $100,000 in SS taxes. I am 49. If you want to replace a program that I have paid into for 33 years, and just 16 years before I can start collecting benefits then I want my money back. The Federal Government under Republicans and Democrats made a deal with me and promised me something in return. I kept my end of the bargain.

Given the time value of money, my guess is they owe me probably $250,000-$300,000.

I noticed one glaring omission, Defense spending. This is not sustainable either, and tends to be a sacred cow. This is where the right tends to be unrealistic in what we can afford. Keep in mind, we won the Cold War by bankrupting the Soviets. The Chinese economy will overtake the US in 5-15 years and will be in a position to do the same to us. We cannot continue to operate 700+ bases in 100+ countries. Do the British, Germans, and French, heirs to historical figures like Napoleon, The Duke of Wellington, Frederick the Great, really need our protection? From who?

In any event, I do appreciate your response to my question.

Harvey of CA 8:59PM January 26, 2011

About this blog

About this blog

Washington Whispers has been featured in U.S. News & World Report since 1933, offering a fun, insider's view of Washington.

advertisement

Latest Videos

advertisement