Catholics Call for Obama Aide to Resign

February 4, 2010 RSS Feed Print

Vatican defenders are calling for the resignation of a religious adviser to President Obama who this week reiterated a charge made last March that Pope Benedict XVI hurt people "in the name of Jesus" when the pontiff suggested that condom use increases the spread of AIDS in Africa.

The St. Michael Society, devoted to defending the pope, is distributing a petition calling for the resignation of Harry Knox from the president's Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships. The White House had no immediate comment.

Knox was asked this week if he still felt that Benedict was wrong to suggest that the use of condoms can help spread AIDS. "I do," he said.

That sparked a renewed recall effort by the St. Michael Society. Director Pat Looby told Whispers: "It is astonishing that someone who is appointed by the president to serve on an Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships would perpetuate two all-out attacks on the pope, saying he was harming people in the name of Jesus.

"These comments demonstrate Mr. Knox's prejudice and open hostility towards Catholics and their religious leader and should disqualify him from public service in an organization that 'will work on behalf of Americans committed to improving their communities, no matter their religious or political beliefs.' These extreme and outrageous anti-Catholic statements not only undercut the idea of this council, they also call into question the president's views about Catholics, since he appointed Mr. Knox."

Last March, the pope flew to Africa and told reporters that halting the spread of AIDS requires more than money. He added: "If there is no human dimension, if Africans do not help [by responsible behavior], the problem cannot be overcome by the distribution of prophylactics: On the contrary, they increase it."

The Human Rights Campaign, the gay rights group for which Knox works, quoted him at the time as saying, "The pope's statement that condoms don't help control the spread of HIV, but rather condoms increase infection rates, is hurting people in the name of Jesus."

Tags:
Pope Benedict XVI,
Catholic Church,
White House,
religion

Reader Comments Read all comments (40)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I absolutely agree with you that Catholic doctrine provides a framework making it difficult to get AIDS through sexual relations, but as you say, that depends on people following that lifestyle. And even though the Bishops well know not everyone, not even all Catholics, will not live the sexual lifestyle in Catholic doctrine, as representatives of that doctrine, the Bishops can't violate it even though condoms can attenuate infection rates. I can't say, "Boxing is a terrible sport" and then remind you to wear gloves.

bezant of FL 3:08PM February 24, 2010

>but can't expect the head of the Catholic Church to contradict its own >doctrine

Of course NOT. It works. The more Catholic teaching the less AIDS. The doctrine works. Anybody following the Catholic doctrine has virtually NO CHANCE to contract AIDS. Furthermore, science tells that condoms are not a solution monogamous relation is.

George of AL 3:14PM February 23, 2010

We have the horrible reality of AIDS vs. religious morals here, but can't expect the head of the Catholic Church to contradict its own doctrine.

bezant of FL 12:31AM February 16, 2010

About this blog

About this blog

Washington Whispers has been featured in U.S. News & World Report since 1933, offering a fun, insider's view of Washington.

advertisement

Latest Video

advertisement